Politics

NJAC Timeline: The Battle Over Judicial Appointments

The NJAC was a six-member commission created in 2014 to appoint judges in place of the collegium. The Supreme Court struck it down 4:1 on 16 October 2015 for u…

Swipe to explore ›
AiTimeline Home
25 APR 1973

Three Judges Passed Over

A day after Kesavananda Bharati, A.N. Ray was named Chief Justice over three senior judges, who all resigned.

AiTimeline Home
29 JAN 1977

Khanna Superseded

M.H. Beg became Chief Justice over H.R. Khanna, the lone dissenter in ADM Jabalpur. Khanna resigned.

AiTimeline Home
30 DEC 1981

First Judges Case

Seven judges held that consultation with the Chief Justice did not mean concurrence. The executive had the upper hand.

AiTimeline Home
6 OCT 1993

Judges Get the Last Word

The court gave the Chief Justice and senior judges primacy in appointments. The collegium was born.

AiTimeline Home
28 OCT 1998

The Collegium Takes Shape

Answering a Presidential reference, the court said the Chief Justice must consult the four senior-most judges.

AiTimeline Home
THE JUDGES CASES

How the Balance Moved

From executive primacy to the collegium.

AiTimeline Home
13-14 AUG 2014

Parliament Passes the NJAC

The 99th Amendment passed almost unanimously, with a single Rajya Sabha member abstaining.

AiTimeline Home
31 DEC 2014

The President Signs

Assent to the 99th Amendment and the NJAC Act created a six-member commission to choose judges.

AiTimeline Home
THE DESIGN

Six Seats on the NJAC

Who would have chosen India's judges.

AiTimeline Home
13 APR 2015

In Force, But Never Met

The commission existed on paper. The Chief Justice reportedly stayed away and no eminent persons were chosen.

AiTimeline Home
APR-JUL 2015

A Constitution Bench Hears It

Justice Dave stepped aside and Justice Khehar presided. Judgment was reserved on 15 July.

AiTimeline Home
THE NJAC LAW

Fourteen Months to a Verdict

From Parliament to the Supreme Court.

AiTimeline Home
16 OCT 2015

Struck Down, 4:1

The majority held the NJAC violated judicial independence, part of the basic structure. The collegium was restored.

AiTimeline Home
THE VERDICT

Four Against, One For

How the five judges voted.

AiTimeline Home
SIDE BY SIDE

Collegium vs NJAC

Two ways to choose a judge.

AiTimeline Home
16 DEC 2015

Fix the Collegium

The court asked for a revised Memorandum of Procedure on eligibility, transparency, a secretariat and complaints.

AiTimeline Home
27 NOV 2018

Review Dismissed

A review petition filed 470 days late was dismissed in chambers, for delay and on merits.

AiTimeline Home
7 DEC 2022

The Vice-President Objects

Jagdeep Dhankhar called the verdict a severe compromise of parliamentary sovereignty. The court said the collegium was the law of the land.

AiTimeline Home
24 APR 2024

Revival Petition Refused

The Registry would not receive a plea to abolish the collegium and revive the NJAC. The issue had been decided.

AiTimeline Home
3 APR 2025

No Word on a New Bill

Law Minister Arjun Ram Meghwal restated that the laws were struck down. He was silent on bringing the NJAC back.

AiTimeline Home
AFTER THE VERDICT

The Argument That Did Not End

2015 to 2026.

AiTimeline Home

Want the full timeline?

Read the complete story, FAQs and key facts.

AiTimeline Home