← AiTimeline Home

Karnataka · 1989-1994 · Article 356, floor tests and federalism

S.R. Bommai Case: How a Landmark Ruling Changed Indian Governance

📅 Last updated: 18 November 2026⏱ 21 dated entries✎ By Nazish Fatima

View as Web Story

In short

Explore the S.R. Bommai case timeline: the 1994 Supreme Court ruling on Article 356, floor tests, President's Rule and Centre-State federalism in India.

Latest Story

On 21 April 1989 the Union government dismissed Karnataka Chief Minister S.R. Bommai, dissolved the state Assembly and imposed President’s Rule, six days before the House was due to meet and test his majority. Five years later, nine Supreme Court judges used his challenge to rewrite the rules on how New Delhi can remove an elected state government. This S.R. Bommai case timeline follows the dispute from the Karnataka crisis to the 1994 judgment and the cases that still rely on it.

Read this first: three common errors

The judgment is often summarised wrongly. Justice S. Ratnavel Pandian was not Chief Justice; the Chief Justice, M.N. Venkatachaliah, was not on the bench. The verdict was not unanimous: on Karnataka the split was 5 to 4. And while summaries say the Court struck down the Nagaland proclamation, only the Sawant-Kuldip Singh opinion declared it unconstitutional. We set out each opinion below.

💡 Short Answer

S.R. Bommai v. Union of India (11 March 1994) is the Supreme Court judgment that limited President’s Rule under Article 356. A nine-judge bench held that proclamations can be reviewed by courts, that a ministry’s majority should be tested on the Assembly floor, that an Assembly cannot be dissolved before Parliament approves the proclamation, and that secularism is part of the basic structure.

⚡ The Case at a Glance
Government dismissedKarnataka, 21 April 1989
Chief MinisterS.R. Bommai, Janata Dal
High CourtPetition dismissed, 4 August 1989
Supreme CourtNine judges, 11 March 1994
Karnataka verdictUnconstitutional, 5 to 4; no restoration
Citation(1994) 3 SCC 1; AIR 1994 SC 1918
⚡ Quick Answers — AI Overview Ready

Bommai Judgment: Key Questions

What did Bommai decide?
That President’s Rule can be reviewed by courts; that majority is ordinarily tested on the Assembly floor; that an Assembly can only be suspended, not dissolved, until Parliament approves; that courts can restore a dismissed government; and that secularism is a basic feature.
Why was Bommai dismissed?
The Governor reported he had lost his majority after a legislator handed over 19 letters withdrawing support. Seven retracted the next day and Bommai offered a floor test on 27 April, but President’s Rule was imposed on 21 April 1989.
Did Bommai get his government back?
No. The Court held the dismissal unconstitutional in 1994, but Karnataka had elected a new Assembly in November 1989, so it granted no relief. Actions taken under President’s Rule were treated as valid.
Is Bommai still relevant?
Yes. It was applied to the Bihar dissolution in 2005-06, to Uttarakhand and Arunachal Pradesh in 2016, to the floor-test orders in Karnataka in 2018 and Maharashtra in 2019, and discussed in the Article 370 judgment of December 2023.
📚 Key Takeaways

The Case in Ten Points

  • The trigger: 19 letters of withdrawal handed to Karnataka’s Governor on 18 April 1989.
  • The retraction: seven of the 19 MLAs said their signatures had been obtained by misrepresentation.
  • The dismissal: President’s Rule and dissolution on 21 April 1989, without a floor test.
  • The first loss: the Karnataka High Court rejected Bommai’s petition on 4 August 1989.
  • The bench: nine judges, six opinions, decided on 11 March 1994.
  • Judicial review: proclamations under Article 356 can be challenged in court.
  • Floor test: the Assembly, not the Governor, is the place to test a majority.
  • No early dissolution: the House can only be suspended until Parliament approves.
  • Secularism: part of the basic structure; the 1992 dismissals of three BJP governments were upheld.
  • No relief: Karnataka, Meghalaya and Nagaland had held new elections, so nothing was restored.

From a Dismissal to a Doctrine

Four dates across 34 years.

The S.R. Bommai case in four stages: 21 April 1989, the Karnataka government is dismissed and the Assembly dissolved under Article 356; 4 August 1989, the Karnataka High Court dismisses the challenge; 11 March 1994, a nine-judge Supreme Court bench holds the Karnataka proclamation unconstitutional by 5 to 4 and sets limits on President's Rule; 11 December 2023, the Article 370 judgment discusses Bommai again.
Dismissal, defeat, doctrine, revisited

A state crisis. A week of defections, letters and Governor’s reports in April 1989 ended with an elected government gone and its Assembly dissolved.

A national question. By the time the case reached the Supreme Court it had been joined by challenges from five other states, covering both disputed majorities and the dismissals that followed the Babri Masjid demolition.

A lasting rule. The judgment did not restore a single government. Its importance lies in the rules it set for every dismissal since.

The Week That Ended a Government

Karnataka, 15 to 21 April 1989.

The week that ended the Bommai government: 15 April 1989, 13 ministers added; 17 April, K.R. Molakery defects and withdraws support; 18 April, he hands the Governor 19 letters from 17 Janata Dal MLAs, one independent and one BJP MLA; 19 April, Governor P. Venkatasubbaiah recommends President's Rule; 20 April, seven MLAs retract and the Cabinet calls the Assembly for 27 April; 21 April, the President dismisses the government and dissolves the Assembly.
Seven days in April

Letters, not votes. The Governor’s case rested on a bundle of letters. He did not ask Bommai for his response before reporting to the President, the Supreme Court recorded.

The offer. When seven signatories retracted, the Cabinet called the Assembly for 27 April and Bommai offered to prove his majority there. The Governor answered with a second report alleging horse-trading.

The proclamation. The President acted on 21 April, giving no reasons beyond the Governor’s report and “other information”. Parliament later approved it.

S.R. Bommai Case Timeline, Newest First

Tagged by phase: the Karnataka crisis, the dismissal, the other states in the case, the court battle, and the legacy.

Karnataka crisisDismissalOther statesIn courtLegacy
11 Dec 2023

The Article 370 judgment revisits Bommai Legacy

In Re: Article 370Five-judge Constitution Bench

What happened: Upholding the 2019 changes to Jammu and Kashmir’s status, the Supreme Court discussed Bommai at length while deciding what the Union may do on a state’s behalf while President’s Rule is in force.

What it said about Bommai: The Court described Bommai as the case that moved Indian constitutional law away from a centralising reading of Article 356 and towards protecting state legislatures. It also drew on Bommai’s test that the Union’s actions under the provision can be struck down if they are mala fide or based on extraneous grounds.

Why it matters: The ruling did not overturn Bommai. It applied the framework to a different situation, and critics argue it gave the Union more room during President’s Rule than Bommai had suggested.

The Article 370 ruling came 29 years and nine months after the Bommai judgment.
26 Nov 2019

Maharashtra: the Supreme Court orders a floor test Legacy

Shiv Sena v. Union of IndiaWithin about 30 hours

What happened: After Devendra Fadnavis was sworn in early on 23 November 2019, the Supreme Court ordered a floor test by 5 pm on 27 November, with an open ballot and live broadcast. Fadnavis resigned on 26 November without facing the vote.

The Bommai link: The order followed the Bommai principle that majority is tested on the floor of the House, not in the Governor’s office or through letters of support.

The Court said the vote should not be by secret ballot and should be telecast live.
18 May 2018

Karnataka again: a floor test in 24 hours Legacy

B.S. YeddyurappaOrder for 19 May

What happened: The Governor had given B.S. Yeddyurappa 15 days to prove his majority. The Supreme Court cut that to about a day and ordered a floor test for 4 pm on 19 May 2018. Yeddyurappa resigned before the vote.

The Bommai link: The order turned on the same question as 1989 in the same state: the House, not a Governor’s assessment, decides who has the numbers.

H.D. Kumaraswamy, son of former Prime Minister H.D. Deve Gowda, formed the next government; Deve Gowda was a Janata leader in Karnataka in the 1980s.
13 Jul 2016

Arunachal Pradesh: a dismissed government is restored Legacy

Nabam Rebia v. Deputy SpeakerFive-judge Constitution Bench

What happened: The Supreme Court set aside the Governor’s decisions that led to the fall of Nabam Tuki’s Congress government and ordered the position as of 15 December 2015 restored.

The Bommai link: Bommai had said courts can restore a dismissed government. In 1994 the Court declined to do it because new elections had been held. In Arunachal it actually did.

The restored government did not last: Tuki was replaced days later, and most Congress MLAs later moved to another party.
11 May 2016

Uttarakhand: a floor test under court supervision Legacy

Harish RawatPresident’s Rule from 27 March 2016

What happened: President’s Rule was imposed in Uttarakhand on 27 March 2016, a day before Chief Minister Harish Rawat was due to face a floor test. The High Court quashed it on 21 April. The Supreme Court then ordered a floor test on 10 May; the result, announced on 11 May, went to Rawat, and President’s Rule was withdrawn.

The Bommai link: The High Court and the Supreme Court both relied on Bommai: the Assembly, not the Union, should decide whether the ministry had a majority.

The sealed result of the 10 May vote was opened in the Supreme Court the next day.
10 Oct 2007

S.R. Bommai dies at 84 Legacy

Former Chief MinisterLater a Union minister

Who he was: Somappa Rayappa Bommai, born on 6 June 1924, was Chief Minister of Karnataka for about eight months in 1988-89. He later served as Union Human Resource Development Minister in the United Front government.

His legacy: He is remembered less for his time in office than for the case that carries his name, which is still cited whenever an elected state government is dismissed or a majority is disputed.

His son Basavaraj Bommai became Chief Minister of Karnataka on 28 July 2021.
24 Jan 2006

Bihar: an Assembly dissolution is held unconstitutional Legacy

Rameshwar Prasad v. Union of IndiaFive-judge Constitution Bench

What happened: The Supreme Court held that the dissolution of the Bihar Assembly on 23 May 2005, ordered before any government was formed after the February 2005 election, was unconstitutional. The Governor had reported that MLAs were being lured to form a government.

Why no restoration: Fresh elections were already under way, so the Court did not revive the old Assembly. The reasons, given later, criticised the Governor’s report.

The Bommai link: The Court applied Bommai: a Governor cannot block a claim to form a government on a personal assessment that support was obtained improperly.

The short order came on 7 October 2005; the full reasoned judgment followed on 24 January 2006.
11 Mar 1994

Nine judges set limits on Article 356 In court

(1994) 3 SCC 1; AIR 1994 SC 1918[1994] 2 SCR 644

What happened: A nine-judge bench delivered six opinions. Five judges held the Karnataka proclamation unconstitutional: P.B. Sawant and Kuldip Singh in one opinion, B.P. Jeevan Reddy and S.C. Agrawal in another, and S. Ratnavel Pandian, who agreed with Jeevan Reddy. A.M. Ahmadi, J.S. Verma, Yogeshwar Dayal and K. Ramaswamy treated it as non-justiciable.

Meghalaya and Nagaland: All the opinions found the Meghalaya proclamation invalid or vulnerable. The Sawant-Kuldip Singh opinion also declared the Nagaland proclamation unconstitutional; the Jeevan Reddy-Agrawal opinion disposed of the Nagaland appeals on its reading of Article 74(2).

The relief: None of the dismissed governments came back. Fresh elections had been held, so the Court declared the proclamations invalid but gave no relief, and treated actions taken during President’s Rule as valid.

The case is often described as unanimous. It was not: on Karnataka itself, the split was 5 to 4.
11 Mar 1994

What the Court laid down In court

Judicial reviewFloor testNo dissolution before approval

Judicial review: A proclamation under Article 356 can be challenged in court. Judges can examine whether there was relevant material for the President’s satisfaction and strike down action that is mala fide or based on wholly irrelevant grounds.

Floor test: Whether a ministry has a majority should ordinarily be tested on the floor of the Assembly, not decided on the Governor’s assessment or a bundle of letters.

Dissolution: Until both Houses of Parliament approve the proclamation, the Assembly may be suspended but not dissolved.

Restoration and secularism: If a proclamation is struck down, courts can restore the ministry and Assembly. Secularism is part of the basic structure, and a state government acting against it can be dismissed.

The Court noted that by 1991, President’s Rule had been used 82 times in states, according to a Lok Sabha Secretariat table quoted by Justice Pandian.
15 Dec 1992

Three BJP governments dismissed after Ayodhya Other states

Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan, Himachal PradeshUpheld in 1994

What happened: After the Babri Masjid was demolished on 6 December 1992, the Union dismissed the BJP governments of Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Himachal Pradesh on 15 December. The Uttar Pradesh government had already gone on 6 December.

In court: The Madhya Pradesh High Court struck down that state’s proclamation, and the Union appealed. In 1994 the Supreme Court upheld all three proclamations, holding that a government that undermines secularism can be dismissed under Article 356.

Why it matters: These cases made secularism, and not only floor majorities, central to the Bommai judgment.

The Uttar Pradesh proclamation was not challenged before the nine judges.
11 Oct 1991

Meghalaya: a government dismissed before the House could vote Other states

B.B. LyngdohAssembly dissolved

What happened: The Speaker had disqualified five independent MLAs, and the Supreme Court had stayed that order. While the dispute was unresolved, the President issued a proclamation on 11 October 1991, dismissing the Lyngdoh government and dissolving the Assembly.

In 1994: Every opinion found the proclamation invalid or vulnerable. Jeevan Reddy said the Court would have restored the Lyngdoh ministry and the Assembly if elections had not been held.

This was the one proclamation that all nine judges treated as reviewable.
24 Nov 1989

Karnataka votes again Dismissal

224 seatsCongress wins 178

What happened: Seven months after the dismissal, Karnataka held a fresh Assembly election. The Congress won 178 of 224 seats and Veerendra Patil became Chief Minister.

Why it matters: The new Assembly made it impossible to restore the Bommai government, even after the Supreme Court found the dismissal unconstitutional.

The Janata Dal, which had 139 seats in 1985 as the Janata Party, won 24 seats.
4 Aug 1989

Karnataka High Court rejects Bommai’s petition In court

AIR 1990 Kant 5Special bench led by Chief Justice Prem Chand Jain

What happened: Bommai and others challenged the proclamation under Article 226. The High Court dismissed the writ petition, accepting the Governor’s reports as relevant material and declining to examine whether they were sufficient.

Next step: Bommai appealed to the Supreme Court, where his case (Civil Appeal 3645 of 1989) was later heard with challenges from Nagaland, Meghalaya and the three states dismissed in December 1992.

The case number of Bommai’s appeal shows how long it waited: filed in 1989, decided in 1994.
21 Apr 1989

President’s Rule is imposed in Karnataka Dismissal

Article 356 proclamationAssembly dissolved

What happened: The President issued a proclamation under Article 356 dismissing the Bommai ministry and dissolving the Assembly. It gave no reasons beyond reciting the Governor’s report and “other information”.

In Parliament: Both Houses of Parliament later approved the proclamation.

The dispute: The Assembly was due to meet on 27 April. Its majority was never tested, which became the heart of the case.

Rajiv Gandhi’s Congress government was in power at the Centre; the Janata Dal was its main rival nationally.
20 Apr 1989

Seven MLAs retract; Bommai offers a floor test Dismissal

Assembly called for 27 AprilGovernor’s second report

What happened: Seven of the 19 legislators wrote to the Governor that their signatures had been obtained by misrepresentation and that they still supported the ministry. The Cabinet decided to convene the Assembly on 27 April, and Bommai and his Law Minister told the Governor, citing the Sarkaria Commission’s advice that majority be tested in the House.

The Governor’s view: Governor P. Venkatasubbaiah sent a second report the same day, saying the seven letters had been obtained under pressure and that horse-trading was going on. He repeated his recommendation for President’s Rule.

Bommai also sent a telex to the President offering to prove his majority.
19 Apr 1989

The Governor recommends President’s Rule Dismissal

P. VenkatasubbaiahFirst report

What happened: The Governor reported to the President that the ministry had lost its majority and that no other party could form a government, and recommended action under Article 356.

What he did not do: According to the Supreme Court’s account, the Governor did not ask Bommai for his view after receiving the letters, or before sending the report.

The Governor’s report counted the letters, not votes in the House.
17-18 Apr 1989

K.R. Molakery’s letters Karnataka crisis

19 letters17 Janata Dal, 1 independent, 1 BJP

What happened: On 17 April, Janata Dal legislator K.R. Molakery defected and wrote to the Governor withdrawing support. The next day he handed over 19 letters said to be signed by 17 Janata Dal MLAs, one associated independent and one BJP MLA.

Why it mattered: The Governor read the letters as proof that the ministry had lost its majority.

The brief we started from spells his name Kalyan Rao Molakery; the judgment uses K.R. Molakery.
15 Apr 1989

Bommai expands his ministry Karnataka crisis

13 new ministersTwo days before the defection

What happened: Bommai added 13 members to his ministry.

Why it mattered: Those left out had a grievance. Within two days the defections that would bring down the government had begun.

The Supreme Court’s account notes the defection came “within two days” of the expansion.

The Janata Dal is formed Karnataka crisis

Janata Party + Lok Dal (B)National merger

What happened: The Janata Party and Lok Dal (B) merged to form the Janata Dal. In Karnataka, the Janata legislature party was renamed accordingly.

Why it mattered: The merger brought together groups with different loyalties, and the April 1989 defections came from within the new party.

The Janata Dal was launched nationally on 11 October 1988.
30 Aug 1988

S.R. Bommai becomes Chief Minister Karnataka crisis

After Ramakrishna Hegde’s resignationJanata Party

What happened: Ramakrishna Hegde, Chief Minister since 1983, resigned in August 1988. Bommai was chosen leader of the legislature party and sworn in on 30 August 1988.

Context: The Supreme Court’s account dates Hegde’s resignation to 1 August 1988.

Bommai lasted 234 days as Chief Minister before the proclamation.

Janata Party wins Karnataka Karnataka crisis

Ramakrishna Hegde returnsMajority in the Assembly

What happened: The Janata Party won a majority in the 1985 Assembly election, and Ramakrishna Hegde, who had led a minority government since 1983, became Chief Minister again.

Why it matters: This was the Assembly that would be dissolved in April 1989, with about a year of its five-year term still to run.

Karnataka’s first non-Congress government had taken office in January 1983, also under Hegde.

What the Supreme Court Held

Seven principles, drawn mainly from the Sawant and Jeevan Reddy opinions.

Seven principles from S.R. Bommai v. Union of India: 1, an Article 356 proclamation is open to judicial review; 2, majority is ordinarily tested on the floor of the Assembly; 3, the Assembly can be suspended but not dissolved before Parliament approves; 4, courts can restore a dismissed ministry and Assembly; 5, parliamentary approval does not end judicial review; 6, a different party ruling at the Centre is not a ground for dismissal; 7, secularism is part of the basic structure.
Seven rules on President’s Rule
Review

Courts can examine a proclamation

Judges can ask whether there was relevant material for the President’s satisfaction. They do not reweigh the politics, but they can strike down action that is mala fide or based on irrelevant grounds.

Majority

The floor test

A disputed majority should be settled by a vote in the House, not by the Governor counting letters.

Dissolution

Suspend first

Until both Houses of Parliament approve the proclamation, the Assembly can only be suspended. Dissolution cannot be undone.

Relief

Restoration is possible

If a proclamation is struck down, a court can bring back the ministry and the Assembly, and can stop new elections while the case is heard.

Article 74(2)

Advice secret, material not

Courts cannot ask what ministers advised the President, but the Union can be made to produce the material behind the advice.

Secularism

A basic feature

A state government acting against secularism can be dismissed. A political difference with the Centre, or a defeat in a Lok Sabha election, is not enough.

How the Nine Judges Split

Six opinions, two camps on Karnataka.

How the nine judges in S.R. Bommai split on the Karnataka proclamation: unconstitutional, five judges, P.B. Sawant and Kuldip Singh in one opinion, B.P. Jeevan Reddy and S.C. Agrawal in another, and S. Ratnavel Pandian agreeing with Jeevan Reddy; not justiciable, four judges, A.M. Ahmadi, J.S. Verma and Yogeshwar Dayal, and K. Ramaswamy. All found Meghalaya invalid or vulnerable and upheld the December 1992 dismissals.
5 to 4 on Karnataka
OpinionJudgesKarnatakaNagalandMP, Rajasthan, HP
SawantP.B. Sawant, Kuldip SinghUnconstitutionalUnconstitutionalUpheld
Jeevan ReddyB.P. Jeevan Reddy, S.C. AgrawalUnconstitutionalDisposed of on Article 74(2)Upheld
PandianS. Ratnavel PandianAgreed with Jeevan ReddyAgreed with Jeevan ReddyUpheld
VermaJ.S. Verma, Yogeshwar DayalNot justiciableNot addressedNot justiciable
AhmadiA.M. AhmadiNot justiciableNot addressedNot justiciable
RamaswamyK. RamaswamyWould dismiss Bommai’s appealNot addressedUpheld

The narrow majority. The rules on review, floor tests and dissolution come from the five-judge majority. The other four took a narrower view of what courts may examine, though Verma and Dayal agreed Meghalaya was justiciable and invalid.

Common ground. All nine accepted that secularism is a basic feature, and none would have reversed the December 1992 dismissals.

The Six-State Verdict

What happened to each proclamation.

The six proclamations in the Bommai case: Nagaland, 7 August 1988, declared unconstitutional in the Sawant-Kuldip Singh opinion; Karnataka, 21 April 1989, unconstitutional by 5 to 4; Meghalaya, 11 October 1991, invalid; Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Himachal Pradesh, 15 December 1992, upheld on secularism grounds. No government was restored because new elections had been held.
Three struck, three upheld
StateProclamationOutcome in 1994
Nagaland7 August 1988Unconstitutional in the Sawant-Kuldip Singh opinion; no relief
Karnataka21 April 1989Unconstitutional, 5 to 4; no relief
Meghalaya11 October 1991Invalid; no relief because elections had been held
Madhya Pradesh15 December 1992Upheld; the High Court’s contrary ruling set aside
Rajasthan15 December 1992Upheld
Himachal Pradesh15 December 1992Upheld

How Later Courts Used Bommai

From Bihar in 2005 to Jammu and Kashmir in 2023.

Later cases built on S.R. Bommai: 2005-06, Rameshwar Prasad, the dissolution of the Bihar Assembly held unconstitutional; May 2016, a court-supervised floor test in Uttarakhand; July 2016, Nabam Rebia, the Arunachal Pradesh government restored; May 2018, Karnataka, a floor test ordered within about a day; November 2019, Maharashtra, a floor test ordered; December 2023, the Article 370 judgment discusses Bommai.
Bommai in later cases
YearCase or stateHow Bommai was used
2005-06Rameshwar Prasad (Bihar)Dissolution held unconstitutional; Governor’s report criticised
2016UttarakhandPresident’s Rule quashed by the High Court; floor test under Supreme Court supervision
2016Nabam Rebia (Arunachal Pradesh)Dismissed government restored, as Bommai allowed
2018Karnataka15-day window cut to a floor test the next day
2019MaharashtraFloor test ordered with open ballot and live telecast
2023Article 370 (Jammu and Kashmir)Bommai discussed on the Union’s powers during President’s Rule

Fewer dismissals. Before 1994, President’s Rule had been used 82 times in states, by the count Justice Pandian cited. It has been used far less since, though it has not disappeared.

The floor test as habit. When a majority is disputed today, the first legal question is usually how soon the House can vote. That is Bommai’s most visible legacy.

By the Numbers

The S.R. Bommai case in numbers: 9 judges; 6 opinions; 6 proclamations examined; 5 to 4 on Karnataka; 19 letters, 7 retracted; 6 days between the dismissal and the planned Assembly session on 27 April 1989; 2 months for Parliament to approve under Article 356(3); 82 uses of President's Rule in states by 1991.
Key figures

The Constitutional Provisions

ProvisionWhat it doesRole in Bommai
Article 355Union’s duty to protect states and ensure government under the ConstitutionRead as the context for Article 356
Article 356President’s Rule on failure of constitutional machineryThe power under review
Article 356(3)Parliament must approve within two monthsNo dissolution before approval
Article 357Legislative powers during President’s RuleWho makes laws while the House is suspended
Article 74(2)Bars inquiry into ministers’ advice to the PresidentDoes not shield the underlying material
Article 163Council of Ministers aids and advises the GovernorLimits on the Governor’s discretion

Who Was Who

Petitioner

S.R. Bommai

Janata Dal Chief Minister of Karnataka, 30 August 1988 to 21 April 1989; later Union HRD Minister. Died 10 October 2007.

Governor

P. Venkatasubbaiah

Sent reports on 19 and 20 April 1989 recommending President’s Rule.

Defector

K.R. Molakery

Janata Dal MLA who withdrew support on 17 April and delivered 19 letters on 18 April.

Prime Minister

Rajiv Gandhi

Headed the Union government that advised the proclamation.

Majority opinions

P.B. Sawant and B.P. Jeevan Reddy

Wrote the two main opinions that set out the limits on Article 356.

Narrower view

A.M. Ahmadi and J.S. Verma

Both later Chief Justices; held the Karnataka proclamation not justiciable.

Did You Know?

  • Six days: the gap between the dismissal and the Assembly session Bommai had called for 27 April 1989.
  • Five years: how long the appeal took, from 1989 to March 1994.
  • 234 days: how long S.R. Bommai lasted as Chief Minister.
  • Father and son: Basavaraj Bommai became Chief Minister of Karnataka in 2021, 32 years after his father’s dismissal.
  • Same state, new test: in 2018 the Supreme Court ordered a Karnataka floor test within about a day, on the principle set in Bommai’s case.
  • No winners: none of the six governments in the case came back to office as a result of it.

Explore More Timelines

People Also Ask

What is the S.R. Bommai case?
S.R. Bommai v. Union of India is a 1994 Supreme Court judgment that set limits on President's Rule under Article 356. It arose from the dismissal of Karnataka Chief Minister S.R. Bommai's government on 21 April 1989. A nine-judge bench held that such proclamations can be reviewed by courts, that majority should be tested on the Assembly floor, and that an Assembly cannot be dissolved before Parliament approves the proclamation.
Why is the Bommai judgment important?
Before 1994, courts rarely questioned a dismissal under Article 356. Bommai made proclamations open to judicial review, made the floor test the normal way to settle a disputed majority, barred dissolution of an Assembly before Parliament approves the proclamation, and declared secularism part of the basic structure. Dismissals of state governments became far less frequent after it.
What did the Supreme Court decide in S.R. Bommai?
It held that an Article 356 proclamation is subject to judicial review on grounds such as mala fides or irrelevant material; that a ministry's majority should ordinarily be tested on the floor of the House; that the Assembly can be suspended but not dissolved until both Houses of Parliament approve; that courts can restore a dismissed government; and that secularism is a basic feature of the Constitution.
Was the Bommai judgment unanimous?
No. The nine judges wrote six opinions. On the Karnataka proclamation, five judges (Sawant, Kuldip Singh, Jeevan Reddy, Agrawal and Pandian) held it unconstitutional, while four (Ahmadi, Verma, Yogeshwar Dayal and Ramaswamy) treated it as non-justiciable. All agreed that the December 1992 dismissals of three BJP governments were valid and that secularism is a basic feature.
Who was the Chief Justice in the Bommai case?
The Chief Justice of India did not sit on the bench. Chief Justice M.N. Venkatachaliah was not one of the nine judges. The senior judge on the bench was Justice S. Ratnavel Pandian. Some summaries, including the brief we started from, wrongly call him Chief Justice.
What is the floor test rule from Bommai?
Bommai held that whether a government has lost its majority should be decided by a vote in the Assembly, not by the Governor's personal assessment or letters from legislators. The Jeevan Reddy opinion said the Karnataka High Court erred in holding that the floor test is not obligatory. Courts since then treat it as the normal method for settling a disputed majority.

Frequently Asked Questions

Based on the Supreme Court and Karnataka High Court judgments and later rulings.

When was the S.R. Bommai judgment delivered?
The Supreme Court delivered the judgment on 11 March 1994. It is reported as (1994) 3 SCC 1, AIR 1994 SC 1918 and [1994] 2 SCR 644.
Who were the judges in the Bommai case?
The nine judges were S. Ratnavel Pandian, A.M. Ahmadi, Kuldip Singh, J.S. Verma, P.B. Sawant, K. Ramaswamy, S.C. Agrawal, Yogeshwar Dayal and B.P. Jeevan Reddy. Ahmadi later became Chief Justice of India, in October 1994, and Verma in 1997.
Why was the Bommai government dismissed?
Governor P. Venkatasubbaiah reported that the ministry had lost its majority after K.R. Molakery handed him 19 letters said to be from legislators withdrawing support. Seven of them later retracted. The Governor still recommended President's Rule, and the President dismissed the government on 21 April 1989 without a floor test.
When was President's Rule imposed in Karnataka?
On 21 April 1989. The proclamation dismissed the Bommai ministry and dissolved the Karnataka Legislative Assembly. Both Houses of Parliament later approved it.
Did Bommai offer to prove his majority?
Yes. On 20 April 1989 his Cabinet decided to convene the Assembly on 27 April, and he and his Law Minister told the Governor. He also sent a telex to the President offering to prove his majority. The Governor did not wait for the session.
Who was K.R. Molakery?
A Janata Dal legislator who defected on 17 April 1989 and wrote to the Governor withdrawing support. The next day he handed over 19 letters said to be signed by 17 Janata Dal MLAs, one independent and one BJP MLA.
What did the Karnataka High Court decide?
On 4 August 1989 a special bench led by Chief Justice Prem Chand Jain dismissed Bommai's writ petition. It held that the Governor's reports were relevant material and that the court could not test their sufficiency. Bommai appealed to the Supreme Court.
Which states were part of the Bommai case?
Six. Nagaland (proclamation of 7 August 1988), Karnataka (21 April 1989), Meghalaya (11 October 1991), and Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Himachal Pradesh (all 15 December 1992).
Was the Karnataka proclamation struck down?
Yes, by a majority of five to four. The Court declared it unconstitutional but did not restore the Bommai government because Karnataka had held a fresh election in November 1989 and a new Assembly was in place.
What happened to the Nagaland proclamation?
The Sawant-Kuldip Singh opinion declared it unconstitutional. The Jeevan Reddy-Agrawal opinion, with which Pandian agreed, disposed of the Nagaland appeals on its interpretation of Article 74(2) without making that declaration. Many summaries simply list Nagaland as struck down, which oversimplifies the split.
What happened to the Meghalaya proclamation?
All the opinions found it invalid or at least vulnerable. Because elections had been held, no relief was granted. Jeevan Reddy wrote that the Court would otherwise have restored the Lyngdoh ministry and the Assembly.
Why were the Madhya Pradesh, Rajasthan and Himachal Pradesh dismissals upheld?
The Court accepted that, after the Babri Masjid demolition on 6 December 1992, there was material that these BJP governments had not upheld secularism. It held that a government acting against secularism, a basic feature of the Constitution, can be dismissed under Article 356.
Can courts review President's Rule after Bommai?
Yes. A proclamation can be challenged, and courts can examine whether there was relevant material for the President's satisfaction. They will not reweigh the political merits, but they can strike down action that is mala fide, based on irrelevant grounds or outside Article 356.
Does parliamentary approval protect a proclamation from review?
No. Bommai held that approval by both Houses does not make an otherwise unconstitutional proclamation immune from judicial scrutiny.
Can an Assembly be dissolved immediately under Article 356?
Not before Parliament approves the proclamation. Until then the President can only suspend the Assembly. Dissolution is irreversible, and the Court wanted it possible to restore the House if the proclamation was found invalid.
How long does Parliament have to approve President's Rule?
Under Article 356(3), a proclamation lapses after two months unless both Houses of Parliament approve it within that period.
Can a dismissed state government be restored?
Yes. Bommai held that if a proclamation is struck down, courts can restore the dismissed ministry and Assembly, and can grant interim orders to stop fresh elections while a challenge is pending. The Supreme Court did this in Arunachal Pradesh in July 2016.
What did Bommai say about secularism?
It held that secularism is part of the basic structure of the Constitution and that a state government acting against it can be dismissed under Article 356. The Court said the state must treat all religions equally and keep religion separate from state functions.
Can a state government be dismissed because a different party rules at the Centre?
No. The Court rejected the argument that a change of government at the Centre, or a heavy defeat for the state's ruling party in a Lok Sabha election, is by itself a ground for President's Rule.
What role does Article 74(2) play in the Bommai case?
Article 74(2) bars courts from inquiring into what advice ministers gave the President. Bommai held that this does not shield the material on which the advice was based, so the Union can be asked to produce it.
What is the Sarkaria Commission's link to Bommai?
The Sarkaria Commission on Centre-State relations, whose report came in 1987-88, recommended that a ministry's majority be tested in the Assembly. Bommai cited it to the Governor in April 1989, and the Supreme Court drew on its guidelines in 1994.
Did President's Rule become rarer after Bommai?
Yes. Use of Article 356 declined in the years after 1994, though it has not stopped. The judgment, coalition politics and court challenges together made dismissals harder to justify.
How was Bommai used in later cases?
In Rameshwar Prasad (2006) the Court held the 2005 dissolution of the Bihar Assembly unconstitutional; in Uttarakhand and Arunachal Pradesh (2016) courts ordered a floor test and restored a government; and in Karnataka (2018) and Maharashtra (2019) it ordered quick floor tests.
What did the Article 370 judgment say about Bommai?
On 11 December 2023 the Supreme Court discussed Bommai while upholding the changes to Jammu and Kashmir. It described Bommai as protecting state autonomy and used its standard that the Union's actions during President's Rule can be challenged if they are mala fide or based on extraneous grounds.
What happened in Karnataka after the dismissal?
Karnataka was under President's Rule until a fresh election on 24 November 1989. The Congress won 178 of 224 seats and Veerendra Patil became Chief Minister. The Janata Dal won 24 seats.
Who was S.R. Bommai?
Somappa Rayappa Bommai (1924-2007) was Chief Minister of Karnataka from 30 August 1988 to 21 April 1989 and later Union Human Resource Development Minister from 1996 to 1998. He died on 10 October 2007.
Is Basavaraj Bommai related to S.R. Bommai?
Yes. Basavaraj Bommai is S.R. Bommai's son. He became Chief Minister of Karnataka on 28 July 2021, 32 years after his father's government was dismissed.
How long was S.R. Bommai Chief Minister?
About 234 days, from 30 August 1988 until the proclamation of 21 April 1989.
Who was the Governor of Karnataka in 1989?
P. Venkatasubbaiah. He sent two reports to the President, on 19 and 20 April 1989, recommending President's Rule.
Who was Prime Minister when Karnataka's government was dismissed?
Rajiv Gandhi. His Congress government advised the President to issue the proclamation of 21 April 1989.
Does Bommai make a floor test mandatory in every case?
For a dispute like Karnataka's, the Jeevan Reddy opinion said yes: the High Court had erred in holding the floor test not obligatory. The judgment does not set a rule for every situation, such as one where the House cannot meet at all, so it is best read as the normal method that a Governor should depart from only for strong reasons.
Did Bommai abolish Article 356?
No. The power to impose President's Rule remains. Bommai set out how it must be used and made its use reviewable by courts.
What is the case citation of S.R. Bommai v. Union of India?
(1994) 3 SCC 1; AIR 1994 SC 1918; [1994] 2 SCR 644. Bommai's own appeal was Civil Appeal No. 3645 of 1989.
Where can I read the S.R. Bommai judgment?
The full text is available from the Supreme Court's judgment archive and on Indian Kanoon. Both are linked in the sources below this article.

⚠️ Editorial Note: What We Corrected

We checked the brief we started from against the 1994 judgment. S. Ratnavel Pandian was a puisne judge, not Chief Justice; Chief Justice M.N. Venkatachaliah was not on the bench. The Karnataka ruling was 5 to 4, with Ahmadi, Verma, Yogeshwar Dayal and Ramaswamy treating it as non-justiciable. Nagaland was declared unconstitutional in the Sawant-Kuldip Singh opinion; the Jeevan Reddy-Agrawal opinion disposed of it on Article 74(2), so we do not present it as a clear majority holding. The defector is named K.R. Molakery in the judgment. The floor-test rule is the normal method for settling a disputed majority, not a formula for every situation. This article explains a court judgment and is not legal advice.

Related Reading on AiTimeline

Antulay Cement Scandal: Why Maharashtra CM A.R. Antulay Resigned in 1982 Mathura Custodial Rape Case: Law, Justice & Reform Timeline
New article
→
Next Article