← AiTimeline Home

India · 1837 to 2026 · Section 124A IPC to Section 152 BNS

Kedar Nath Singh Case: Sedition Law Timeline in India

📅 Last updated: 20 November 2026⏱ 34 dated entries✎ By Nazish Fatima

View as Web Story

In short

Explore the Kedar Nath Singh case, the 1962 Supreme Court ruling on sedition, Section 124A's repeal and the pending challenge to BNS Section 152.

Latest Story

India’s sedition law was written by a colonial government in 1870 and used to jail Bal Gangadhar Tilak and Mahatma Gandhi. After Independence it survived because of one judgment. In Kedar Nath Singh v. State of Bihar, decided on 20 January 1962, a five-judge Supreme Court Bench upheld Section 124A of the Indian Penal Code but confined it to words or acts with an intention or tendency to cause public disorder or incite violence. Criticism of the government, however harsh, was not enough. This timeline follows the Kedar Nath Singh case from a 1953 speech in Bihar to the Constitution Bench, and the law it shaped from Macaulay’s 1837 draft to the 2022 freeze, the repeal of Section 124A in 2024 and the pending challenge to Section 152 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. Dates and holdings are checked against the judgments and orders themselves.

Read this first: what is often got wrong

Kedar Nath Singh lost. The Court upheld the law, dismissed his appeal and left his one-year sentence in place. He belonged to the Forward Communist Party, according to the judgment, not the CPI. The First Amendment (1951) added ‘public order’ to Article 19(2); ‘security of the State’ was there from the start. Allahabad’s ruling against Section 124A came on 16 May 1958, and the 1951 ruling came from the Punjab High Court; the Punjab and Haryana High Court did not exist until 1966. Parliament passed the revised BNS on 20 and 21 December 2023; it was introduced on 12 December.

💡 Short Answer

In Kedar Nath Singh v. State of Bihar (20 January 1962), a five-judge Supreme Court Bench led by Chief Justice B.P. Sinha upheld the sedition offence in Section 124A IPC but limited it to acts involving an intention or tendency to create disorder, disturb law and order or incite violence. Strong criticism of the government was held to be protected speech. The Court put Section 124A on hold on 11 May 2022, and the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita replaced it on 1 July 2024. Its Section 152, on acts endangering India’s sovereignty, unity and integrity, is now under constitutional challenge, with no final ruling as of November 2026.

⚡ Facts at a Glance
Decided20 January 1962, AIR 1962 SC 955
Bench5 judges, led by CJ B.P. Sinha; unanimous
The speechBarauni, Bihar, 26 May 1953
ResultLaw upheld, narrowed; appeal dismissed
Section 124A1870 to 30 June 2024; frozen from 11 May 2022
Section 152 BNSIn force 1 July 2024; challenge pending
⚡ Quick Answers — AI Overview Ready

The Kedar Nath Singh Case: Key Questions

What did the Kedar Nath judgment hold?
That Section 124A is constitutional only if read narrowly: it covers words or acts with an intention or tendency to create public disorder or incite violence, not criticism of the government, however strongly worded.
Who won the case?
The State. The Supreme Court upheld the law and dismissed Kedar Nath Singh’s appeal, so his one-year sentence stood. The narrowing helped later defendants, not him.
Is sedition still law in India?
Section 124A does not apply to offences after 1 July 2024. The BNS has no offence named sedition, but Section 152 punishes acts endangering India’s sovereignty, unity and integrity.
What is pending in the Supreme Court?
A larger Bench reference on whether Section 124A was valid, and petitions, first heard on 8 August 2025, arguing that Section 152 is sedition under a new name. Neither has been decided.
📚 Key Takeaways

Sedition Law in India in Ten Lines

  • Colonial birth: Section 124A was added to the IPC in 1870 and rewritten in 1898.
  • Famous targets: Tilak in 1897 and 1908; Gandhi in 1922, who called it the ‘prince’ of political sections.
  • Dropped from the Constitution: ‘sedition’ was deleted from Article 19(2) in 1948.
  • Public order added: the First Amendment of 1951 gave the State a new ground to defend the law.
  • The speech: Kedar Nath called the ruling party ‘Congress goondas’ at Barauni in 1953.
  • The judgment: on 20 January 1962 the Court upheld Section 124A, but only for incitement or a tendency to disorder.
  • The irony: the narrowing saved the law, and Kedar Nath’s own conviction.
  • The freeze: the Supreme Court put Section 124A in abeyance on 11 May 2022.
  • The replacement: the BNS replaced the IPC on 1 July 2024; Section 152 took sedition’s place.
  • Still open: neither Section 124A’s validity nor Section 152’s has been decided.
The sedition law in figures: Section 124A added in 1870; 92 years until the Kedar Nath judgment in 1962; a five-judge unanimous Bench; Kedar Nath sentenced to 1 year of rigorous imprisonment; 326 cases and 6 convictions from 2014 to 2019; frozen on 11 May 2022; replaced by Section 152 of the BNS on 1 July 2024, with a maximum of life imprisonment.
The sedition law by the numbers

Two Tracks: The Law and the Courts

What legislatures wrote, and what judges made of it.

Two-track timeline. The law, above: 1870 Section 124A added; 1898 amended with three explanations; 1948 sedition deleted from the draft Article 19(2); 1951 First Amendment adds public order; 1973 sedition made cognisable; 2023 Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita passed; 1 July 2024 Section 124A replaced by Section 152. The courts, below: 1897 Tilak, disaffection means absence of affection; 1942 Federal Court requires tendency to disorder; 1947 Privy Council rejects that; 1950-58 Punjab and Allahabad High Courts strike 124A down; 20 January 1962 Kedar Nath upholds it, narrowed; 11 May 2022 abeyance; 2025-26 Section 152 challenge pending.
The law above, the courts below

The history of sedition in India runs on two tracks. On one, legislatures kept the offence alive: the colonial government created it in 1870 and widened it in 1898; the Constituent Assembly dropped ‘sedition’ from the Constitution in 1948 but left Section 124A on the statute book; Parliament gave it a new constitutional footing with the First Amendment in 1951 and made it easier to use with the 1973 Criminal Procedure Code; and in 2023 it replaced it with Section 152 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita.

On the other track, courts argued over what the words meant. The colonial judges in Tilak’s 1897 trial said that disaffection meant the absence of affection. The Federal Court in 1942 said there had to be a tendency to public disorder, and the Privy Council in 1947 said there did not. Two High Courts struck the section down after Independence. Then, in 1962, the Supreme Court picked the Federal Court’s reading and used it to save the law. Since 2021 the courts have been back on centre stage, first freezing Section 124A and now examining its successor.

The Case: From Barauni to the Constitution Bench

A district-level speech that became the leading authority on free speech and sedition.

On 26 May 1953, Kedar Nath Singh addressed a meeting at Barauni, then in Bihar’s Monghyr district. According to the charge quoted in the judgment, he said ‘the dogs of the C.I.D.’ were in the audience, called the ruling party ‘Congress goondas’ who were ‘just like the Britishers’, and said the Forward Communist Party believed in a revolution in whose flames capitalists, zamindars and Congress leaders would be ‘reduced to ashes’.

A magistrate at Begusarai convicted him under Sections 124A and 505(b) and sentenced him to one year’s rigorous imprisonment. Justice Naqui Imam of the Patna High Court dismissed his appeal on 9 April 1956, calling the speech ‘full of incitements to revolution’. Only in his petition to the Supreme Court did Kedar Nath argue that the sections themselves violated Article 19(1)(a). A Division Bench sent the case to a Constitution Bench on 5 May 1959, and it was heard with three appeals by Uttar Pradesh against a 16 May 1958 Allahabad High Court ruling that had declared Section 124A void.

The judgment of 20 January 1962 answered the constitutional question in the State’s favour and then applied it to the facts. Because Kedar Nath’s lawyers had not argued that his speech fell outside sedition as now defined, his appeal was dismissed. The Uttar Pradesh appeals were allowed and sent back to the High Court to decide afresh.

The Kedar Nath Test

Where the Court drew the line in 1962.

The Kedar Nath line. Protected: criticism of government policies, however strongly worded; disapproval of government action; demands for change by lawful means; hostility to the government without any connection to violence or disorder. Punishable under Section 124A: words or acts with an intention or tendency to create public disorder; disturbance of law and order; incitement to violence.
Criticism on one side, incitement on the other
IssuePosition under Kedar Nath
Criticism of government policiesNot sedition, however strongly worded
Demand for change by lawful meansProtected by the explanations to Section 124A
Disapproval of government actionNot an offence by itself
Incitement to violenceCan fall within Section 124A
Intention or tendency to create public disorderCan fall within Section 124A
Hostility to the government with no link to violence or disorderNot enough
Two readings of sedition. Federal Court, Niharendu Dutt Majumdar, 1942: sedition requires an intention or tendency to incite public disorder. Privy Council, Sadashiv Narayan Bhalerao, 1947: exciting disaffection is enough, with no need for any tendency to violence. Supreme Court, Kedar Nath Singh, 1962: the Privy Council view would make Section 124A unconstitutional, the Federal Court view saves it, so the Federal Court view is adopted.
The choice the 1962 Court made

The Court reached this line by choosing between two readings it inherited. Chief Justice Sinha wrote that if Section 124A were read literally, as the Privy Council had read it, it would be unconstitutional; read as the Federal Court had read it in Niharendu Dutt Majumdar, it was a reasonable restriction in the interest of public order. Relying on the principle that courts should prefer the interpretation that saves a law, the Bench held that the section aimed ‘at rendering penal only such activities as would be intended, or have a tendency, to create disorder or disturbance of public peace by resort to violence’.

The judgment’s critics make two points. First, a ‘tendency’ to disorder is a loose standard, much wider than the ‘incitement’ test the Court later adopted for speech in Shreya Singhal (2015). Second, because the narrowing lived in a judgment rather than the text, police could still register cases on the section’s wide words and leave courts to apply Kedar Nath later. Its defenders reply that without it Section 124A would have been far broader for six decades.

Sedition Law Timeline, 1837 to 2026

Newest first. Each entry is tagged by type.

Colonial eraConstitution and ParliamentCourtsProsecutionsNew law

Both constitutional questions are still open New law

Section 124A IPC: reference to a larger BenchSection 152 BNS: notice issued, no ruling

Where things stand: As of 20 November 2026 the Supreme Court has not decided whether Section 124A was unconstitutional, and it has not ruled on the validity of Section 152 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita. The 2023 reference of the old law to a larger Bench is still waiting for that Bench to be constituted, and the Section 152 petitions are tagged with it.

What that means in practice: Old sedition cases registered before 1 July 2024 stay frozen unless the accused asks for them to proceed. New conduct is prosecuted, if at all, under Section 152, which is fully in force and has not been stayed.

Kedar Nath Singh (1962) therefore remains the governing interpretation of Section 124A for every pending case under the old law.
21 May 2026

Supreme Court lets frozen sedition cases move if the accused agrees Courts

Kamran v. State of Madhya PradeshChief Justice Surya Kant, Justices Joymalya Bagchi and Vipul M. Pancholi

What happened: The Court clarified that its May 2022 order did not stop trials, appeals and other proceedings involving Section 124A from continuing where the accused has no objection. The petitioner had reportedly been in custody for about 17 years; he was sentenced to life in 2017 under Sections 122, 124A and 153A of the IPC, the UAPA and the Arms Act, and his appeal was stuck in the Madhya Pradesh High Court.

Why it mattered: The 2022 freeze was meant to protect the accused, but it also left people like the petitioner unable to get their appeals heard. The clarification gave them a way out. It did not decide whether Section 124A is valid.

The Court directed the Madhya Pradesh High Court to take up the petitioner’s appeal.
27 Feb 2026

Court says the Centre’s 2022 promise cannot bind Parliament Courts

Section 152 BNS challengeChief Justice Surya Kant and Justice Joymalya Bagchi

What happened: Petitioners argued that the Union had told the Court in 2022 it would reconsider sedition and then re-enacted it as Section 152. The Bench observed that an undertaking given by the government in court could not bind Parliament’s legislative choices, while adding that the Court could still examine the new provision on judicial review.

What it was not: These were observations during a hearing. The Bench did not rule on whether Section 152 is constitutional, and the matter was listed for further hearing.

Senior advocate Menaka Guruswamy was among the counsel arguing that Section 152 brings back the old offence in a new form.
8 Aug 2025

Supreme Court issues notice on the challenge to Section 152 Courts

S.G. Vombatkere v. Union of India, W.P.(C) 720 of 2025Chief Justice B.R. Gavai, Justices K. Vinod Chandran and N.V. Anjaria

What happened: Retired Major General S.G. Vombatkere, one of the petitioners who had challenged Section 124A, filed a fresh petition arguing that Section 152 is ‘repackaged sedition’ that violates Articles 14, 19(1)(a) and 21. The Court issued notice to the Centre and tagged the case with the pending challenge to the old law.

Related cases: In the following weeks the Court issued notice on similar challenges, including one by The Wire and its founding editor Siddharth Varadarajan, who were given interim protection from coercive action over an Assam Police FIR under Section 152, and one by journalist Abhisar Sharma, whose FIR challenge it sent to the High Court.

The petition’s main targets are the words ‘subversive activities’ and ‘encourages feelings of separatist activities’, which the BNS does not define.
1 Jul 2024

The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita comes into force; Section 124A is gone New law

IPC repealed for new offencesSection 152: ‘Act endangering sovereignty, unity and integrity of India’

What changed: The IPC, including Section 124A, stopped applying to offences committed from this date. The word ‘sedition’ does not appear in the BNS. Section 152 instead punishes anyone who ‘purposely or knowingly’, by words, signs, visible representation, electronic communication, financial means or otherwise, excites or attempts to excite secession, armed rebellion or subversive activities, encourages feelings of separatist activities, or endangers India’s sovereignty, unity and integrity.

Punishment: Imprisonment for life, or up to seven years, and a fine. Under Section 124A the alternatives were life, up to three years, or a fine alone. An explanation protects comments disapproving of government measures with a view to changing them by lawful means.

The target of the offence shifts from ‘the Government established by law’ to the sovereignty, unity and integrity of India.
23 Feb 2024

Commencement date notified New law

Ministry of Home Affairs notificationEffective 1 July 2024

What happened: The Home Ministry notified 1 July 2024 as the date on which the BNS would take effect, except Section 106(2) on hit-and-run cases, which was held back after protests by truck drivers.

Why it matters: From that date Section 124A could no longer be used for fresh offences. Cases already registered under it continued under the old law.

Companion laws replacing the Code of Criminal Procedure and the Evidence Act were brought into force on the same day.

Parliament passes the revised Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita New law

Revised Bill introduced 12 December 2023Lok Sabha 20 December, Rajya Sabha 21 December; assent 25 December

What happened: The government withdrew the August Bill and introduced a revised version on 12 December 2023, incorporating changes suggested by a parliamentary standing committee. The Lok Sabha passed it on 20 December and the Rajya Sabha on 21 December. President Droupadi Murmu gave assent on 25 December 2023.

Correction: The revised Bill was introduced, not passed, on 12 December. It was passed during a session in which a large number of opposition MPs had been suspended.

The provision that became Section 152 was Clause 150 in the August version of the Bill.
12 Sep 2023

Challenge to Section 124A referred to a larger Bench Courts

Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, Justices J.B. Pardiwala and Manoj MisraKedar Nath was a five-judge ruling

What happened: A three-judge Bench could not overrule a five-judge Constitution Bench, so it referred the challenge to a larger Bench. It refused the Union’s request to wait for the new criminal laws, reasoning that any new law would apply only prospectively and that prosecutions already brought under Section 124A would still have to be judged by its validity.

What is pending: According to Supreme Court Observer, the reference awaits a seven-judge Bench that has yet to be constituted.

Petitioners want the Court to test sedition against modern standards of proportionality under Articles 14 and 21, not only Article 19.
11 Aug 2023

Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita Bill introduced New law

Lok SabhaHome Minister Amit Shah

What happened: Amit Shah introduced three Bills to replace the IPC, the CrPC and the Evidence Act, and told the Lok Sabha that the offence of sedition was being repealed. The Bill dropped Section 124A but included a new clause on acts endangering the sovereignty, unity and integrity of India.

Reaction: Critics said the new clause was wider than the old one because it covered acts against the country, not just the government, and used undefined terms. The government said it targeted threats to the nation, not criticism of those in power.

The Bill was referred to the Standing Committee on Home Affairs before being withdrawn and re-introduced in December.

Law Commission recommends keeping sedition, with changes Constitution and Parliament

22nd Law Commission, Report No. 279Chairperson: Justice Ritu Raj Awasthi

What it said: The Commission advised the government to retain Section 124A, writing Kedar Nath’s test of a ‘tendency to incite violence or cause public disorder’ into the text and adding a procedural safeguard of a preliminary inquiry before an FIR. It also proposed raising the alternative jail term from three years to seven.

What happened next: The government did not adopt the recommendation in that form. Two months later it introduced a Bill that dropped Section 124A altogether.

The proposal to raise the alternative sentence was widely criticised, but Section 152 of the BNS also uses seven years as its alternative to life.
11 May 2022

Supreme Court puts Section 124A in abeyance Courts

S.G. Vombatkere v. Union of India, interim orderChief Justice N.V. Ramana, Justices Surya Kant and Hima Kohli

What the order said: The Court expected the Centre and the States to refrain from registering FIRs, continuing investigations or taking coercive steps under Section 124A while it was being re-examined. Pending trials, appeals and proceedings on the sedition charge were to be kept in abeyance, though other charges could proceed if the accused would not be prejudiced. Anyone newly booked could approach the courts for relief.

What it was not: It was an interim order, not a ruling that Section 124A was unconstitutional. The Court said it was trying to balance the security of the State and civil liberties while the government reconsidered the law.

It was the first time since 1962 that the Supreme Court had effectively stopped the use of Section 124A.
9 May 2022

Centre tells the Court it will re-examine sedition Constitution and Parliament

Union of India affidavitTwo days after defending Kedar Nath

What happened: On 7 May 2022 the government’s written submissions had defended Section 124A and argued that Kedar Nath was good law. On 9 May it filed an affidavit saying the Prime Minister wanted colonial-era laws reviewed and that it had decided to re-examine and reconsider the provision, and asked the Court not to hear the challenge in the meantime.

Why it mattered: The Court did not simply adjourn. Two days later it froze the law’s use until the review was done.

This undertaking is the one the Bench said in February 2026 could not bind Parliament.
15 Jul 2021

Supreme Court issues notice on the challenge to Section 124A Courts

Petitions by Maj Gen S.G. Vombatkere (retd) and the Editors Guild of India, among othersChief Justice N.V. Ramana

What happened: Issuing notice, Chief Justice Ramana asked the Attorney General why a colonial law used against Mahatma Gandhi and Bal Gangadhar Tilak was still needed 75 years after Independence, and compared its misuse to a carpenter given a saw who cuts down the whole forest.

The argument: The petitioners said the words ‘disaffection’, ‘hatred’ and ‘contempt’ are vague, that Kedar Nath’s narrowing had not stopped misuse, and that the law chills legitimate criticism.

National Crime Records Bureau figures reported at the time showed 326 sedition cases registered from 2014 to 2019, and convictions in six.
3 Jun 2021

Supreme Court quashes sedition FIR against Vinod Dua Courts

Vinod Dua v. Union of IndiaJustices U.U. Lalit and Vineet Saran

What happened: A Himachal Pradesh FIR accused the journalist of sedition over a YouTube show criticising the government’s handling of the 2020 Covid lockdown. Applying Kedar Nath, the Court held that his statements were criticism of government action, not incitement to violence or public disorder, and quashed the case.

Why it matters: It is one of the clearest recent applications of the 1962 test, and a reminder that the judgment’s protection depended on courts applying it after an FIR had already been filed.

The Court said every journalist is entitled to protection under Kedar Nath, but declined to order that FIRs against journalists need prior clearance by a committee.
5 Sep 2016

Court tells authorities to follow Kedar Nath Courts

Common Cause v. Union of IndiaJustices Dipak Misra and U.U. Lalit

What happened: Hearing a plea about misuse of the sedition law, the Court said authorities must follow the principles laid down in Kedar Nath when invoking Section 124A, and that it saw no need for fresh guidelines.

Why it matters: Petitioners later pointed to this order as proof that repeating the 1962 test had not been enough to stop arrests for speech.

The Court refused to issue directions specific to particular cases, saying those had to be dealt with by the courts concerned.

JNU students arrested on sedition charges Prosecutions

Jawaharlal Nehru University, New DelhiKanhaiya Kumar arrested 12 February 2016

What happened: After an event on campus on 9 February 2016 at which slogans were allegedly raised, Delhi Police arrested JNU Students’ Union president Kanhaiya Kumar under Section 124A; Umar Khalid and Anirban Bhattacharya surrendered later that month. Kumar got interim bail in March.

What followed: The police filed a charge sheet in January 2019, and the Delhi government granted sanction to prosecute in February 2020. The case became the most prominent national test of where slogans end and sedition begins.

Because of the 2022 order, the sedition charge in cases like this remains in abeyance unless the accused asks for it to proceed.
24 Mar 2015

Shreya Singhal strikes down Section 66A of the IT Act Courts

Shreya Singhal v. Union of IndiaJustices J. Chelameswar and R.F. Nariman

What happened: The Court struck down the online-speech offence in Section 66A as vague and overbroad. It distinguished three levels of speech: discussion and advocacy, however unpopular, are protected; only incitement can be restricted on grounds such as public order.

Link to sedition: The case did not decide the validity of Section 124A, but its discussion, advocacy and incitement distinction is cited in almost every argument that the sedition law and Section 152 are too broad.

Like Kedar Nath, the case was decided under Article 19(2), but it struck the law down rather than reading it narrowly.

New criminal procedure code makes sedition cognisable Constitution and Parliament

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 (in force 1 April 1974)Section 196: prior sanction

What changed: Under the 1898 Code, sedition was non-cognisable, so police needed a magistrate’s permission to investigate. The 1973 Code made it cognisable, allowing arrest without a warrant, while Section 196 required the sanction of the Central or State government before a court could take cognisance.

Why it matters: Arrests could now come first and sanction later. Critics have long pointed to this change, made under Indira Gandhi’s government, as a reason the law’s use grew despite Kedar Nath.

The BNSS, which replaced the 1973 Code in 2024, keeps a sanction requirement for prosecutions under Section 152.
20 Jan 1962

Kedar Nath Singh v. State of Bihar: sedition upheld, but narrowed Courts

Five-judge Constitution BenchChief Justice B.P. Sinha, Justices S.K. Das, A.K. Sarkar, N. Rajagopala Ayyangar and J.R. Mudholkar

The holding: Writing for a unanimous Bench, Chief Justice Sinha held that Section 124A was valid but must be confined to acts ‘involving intention or tendency to create disorder, or disturbance of law and order, or incitement to violence’. Criticism of public measures or comment on government action, ‘however strongly worded’, was protected. Read that way, the section was a reasonable restriction in the interest of public order under Article 19(2). Section 505 was upheld too.

The outcome for Kedar Nath: His own appeal was dismissed and his conviction stood. His counsel had not argued that his speech fell outside sedition as the Court now defined it. The connected Uttar Pradesh appeals were sent back to the Allahabad High Court to decide in the light of the new interpretation.

The Court chose between two colonial readings: the Federal Court’s 1942 view requiring a tendency to public disorder, and the Privy Council’s 1947 view that it did not. It adopted the Federal Court’s.

The appeal reaches a Constitution Bench Courts

Criminal Appeal 169 of 1957, by special leaveAttorney General notified 4 November 1960

What happened: Kedar Nath had not challenged the law’s validity in the High Court, but raised it in his petition to the Supreme Court. A Division Bench sent the case to a Constitution Bench on 5 May 1959. On 4 November 1960 that Bench issued notice to the Attorney General, and on 9 February 1961 it adjourned the case for States to decide their positions.

Connected cases: It was heard with three appeals by Uttar Pradesh against the Allahabad High Court’s ruling, one involving Mohd Ishaq Ilmi, prosecuted for a speech at Aligarh on 30 October 1953.

The conflicting High Court decisions made a Supreme Court ruling unavoidable.
16 May 1958

Allahabad High Court strikes down Section 124A Courts

Ram Nandan v. State, Full BenchReported as AIR 1959 All 101

What happened: A Full Bench held that Section 124A violated Article 19(1)(a) because it was not confined to the interest of public order and its restrictions were not reasonable. It acquitted the accused in the connected cases.

Correction: The judgment was delivered on 16 May 1958. It is often dated 1959 because that is the year of the law report.

This was the ruling Uttar Pradesh appealed, and the Supreme Court reversed, in 1962.
9 Apr 1956

Patna High Court upholds Kedar Nath’s conviction Courts

Criminal Appeal 445 of 1955Justice Naqui Imam, sitting alone

What happened: The High Court dismissed the appeal. It said the speech was ‘nothing but a vilification of the Government’, ‘full of incitements to revolution’ and, taken as a whole, ‘certainly seditious’.

Next step: Kedar Nath obtained special leave to appeal to the Supreme Court, where he raised the constitutional challenge for the first time.

The trial magistrate at Begusarai had sentenced him to one year’s rigorous imprisonment.
26 May 1953

Kedar Nath Singh’s speech at Barauni Prosecutions

Village Barauni, then in Monghyr district, BiharForward Communist Party

What he said: Speaking for the Forward Communist Party, Kedar Nath said ‘the dogs of the C.I.D.’ were loitering around the meeting, called the ruling party ‘Congress goondas’ who were ‘just like the Britishers’, and said his party believed in a revolution in whose flames capitalists, zamindars and Congress leaders would be reduced to ashes.

The charge: He was prosecuted before a first-class magistrate at Begusarai under Section 124A and Section 505(b), convicted on both and sentenced to one year’s rigorous imprisonment.

Correction: the judgment identifies him with the Forward Communist Party, not the Communist Party of India.
18 Jun 1951

First Amendment rewrites Article 19(2) Constitution and Parliament

Constitution (First Amendment) Act, 1951Nehru: section 124A ‘highly objectionable and obnoxious’

What changed: Parliament added ‘public order’, ‘friendly relations with foreign States’ and ‘incitement to an offence’ as grounds for restricting speech, and required restrictions to be ‘reasonable’. ‘Security of the State’ was already in the original text.

Nehru on sedition: During the debate Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru said that Section 124A was ‘highly objectionable and obnoxious’ and that ‘the sooner we get rid of it the better’. His government did not repeal it.

Correction: the amendment added public order, not security of the State. It was the ‘public order’ ground that later saved Section 124A in 1962.
1950-51

Punjab High Court holds Section 124A void Courts

Tara Singh Gopi Chand v. The StateReported as AIR 1951 Punj 27

What happened: The Punjab High Court held that Section 124A was an unreasonable restriction on free speech under the Constitution as it then stood and was therefore void.

Why it matters: It was the first High Court ruling to strike down the sedition law after Independence, and helped prompt the First Amendment.

Correction: this was the Punjab High Court. The Punjab and Haryana High Court did not exist until 1966.
26 May 1950

Romesh Thapar and Brij Bhushan Courts

Supreme Court of IndiaBans on Cross Roads and the Organizer

What happened: In two rulings on the same day, the Court struck down orders against a left-wing journal in Madras and pre-censorship of an RSS weekly in Delhi. Under the original Article 19(2), speech could be restricted only to protect the ‘security of the State’, and the Court held that ordinary public-order concerns did not qualify.

Why it matters: The rulings suggested that a law penalising speech merely because it disturbed public order could not survive, and the government responded with the First Amendment a year later.

Justice Patanjali Sastri wrote that freedom of speech and of the press lay at the foundation of all democratic organisations.
26 Jan 1950

Constitution comes into force without ‘sedition’ as a ground Constitution and Parliament

Article 19(1)(a) and 19(2)K.M. Munshi’s amendment, 1 December 1948

What happened: The draft Constitution had listed sedition among the grounds on which speech could be restricted. In the Constituent Assembly on 1 December 1948, K.M. Munshi moved to delete it, arguing that criticism of government is the essence of democracy. The word was dropped from the final text.

Why it matters: Section 124A survived as existing law under Article 13, but its validity now depended on whether it fitted one of the grounds that remained.

The IPC, including Section 124A, had continued in force after Independence on 15 August 1947.
1942 & 1947

Federal Court and Privy Council split on what sedition means Courts

Niharendu Dutt Majumdar v. King Emperor (1942)King Emperor v. Sadashiv Narayan Bhalerao (1947)

Two readings: In 1942 the Federal Court, led by Chief Justice Maurice Gwyer, held that words were seditious only if they were intended, or tended, to incite disorder. In 1947 the Privy Council rejected that view and held that exciting disaffection was enough, with no need for any tendency to violence.

Why it matters: Fifteen years later, the Supreme Court said the Privy Council’s reading would make Section 124A unconstitutional and the Federal Court’s would save it. It chose the Federal Court’s.

The whole of the 1962 ruling turns on this choice between two pre-Independence courts.
18 Mar 1922

Mahatma Gandhi’s ‘Great Trial’ Colonial era

AhmedabadJudge C.N. Broomfield

What happened: Gandhi and the publisher Shankarlal Banker were tried under Section 124A over three articles in Young India. Gandhi pleaded guilty and asked for the severest penalty, calling Section 124A ‘the prince among the political sections of the Indian Penal Code designed to suppress the liberty of the citizen’. He was sentenced to six years’ simple imprisonment.

Afterwards: He was released in February 1924 on health grounds after about two years.

Judge Broomfield said that if the government later reduced the sentence, ‘no one would be better pleased than I’.
22 Jul 1908

Tilak sentenced to six years’ transportation Colonial era

Bombay High Court, Justice Dinshaw DavarArticles in Kesari

What happened: Tilak was convicted of sedition over Kesari articles on the Muzaffarpur bombing and sentenced to six years’ transportation. He served it in Mandalay, in Burma, where he wrote Gita Rahasya.

Why it matters: It was the best-known use of the law against the nationalist press. His defence counsel in the 1916 sedition case brought against him later was Muhammad Ali Jinnah.

Tilak told the court that there were higher powers that rule the destiny of things, a line now inscribed in the Bombay High Court.
1898

Section 124A amended Colonial era

Indian Penal Code (Amendment) Act IV of 1898Three explanations replace one

What changed: The amendment extended the offence to bringing the government into ‘hatred or contempt’, defined disaffection to include ‘disloyalty and all feelings of enmity’, and replaced the single explanation with three. Two of them protected comments disapproving of government measures or actions with a view to changing them by lawful means.

Why it matters: These explanations are the textual hook Kedar Nath used in 1962, and the explanation to Section 152 of the BNS repeats the same idea.

Section 153A, on promoting enmity between classes, was added by the same Act.
Sep 1897

Tilak’s first sedition trial Colonial era

Queen Empress v. Bal Gangadhar TilakJustice Arthur Strachey, Bombay

What happened: Tilak was prosecuted over Kesari pieces published after the murder of plague commissioner W.C. Rand in Pune. Justice Strachey directed the jury that disaffection meant ‘the absence of affection’ and that it did not matter whether any disturbance followed. Tilak was sentenced to 18 months’ rigorous imprisonment.

Why it matters: Strachey’s reading, that hostile feeling alone was enough, was the wide view the Privy Council later endorsed and Kedar Nath rejected.

The first reported prosecution under Section 124A was against the editor of Bangobasi in Calcutta in 1891.
1870

Section 124A enters the Indian Penal Code Colonial era

Act XXVII of 1870Introduced by Sir James Fitzjames Stephen

What happened: Ten years after the IPC was enacted, the colonial government inserted Section 124A, ‘Exciting disaffection’, punishing anyone who excited or attempted to excite feelings of disaffection to the government established by law, with transportation for life or up to three years’ imprisonment.

The context: It came amid fears of Wahabi activity in British India. The 1962 judgment notes that the clause had been left out of the 1860 Code for reasons that are not clear.

The penalty of life imprisonment that Section 124A carried until 2024 descends from the ‘transportation for life’ of 1870.
1837

Sedition appears in Macaulay’s draft Penal Code Colonial era

Draft Indian Penal CodeLaw Commission under Thomas Babington Macaulay

What happened: Macaulay’s draft code included a clause on exciting disaffection to the government. When the Indian Penal Code was finally enacted in 1860, the clause was missing.

Why it matters: Its omission and later return in 1870 are why the 1962 Court treated the history of the provision as key to reading it.

The 1860 Code came into force on 1 January 1862, exactly a century before Kedar Nath was decided.

Colonial Origins: 1837 to 1947

A law written to protect the Raj from Indian opinion.

Colonial sedition. 1837: Macaulay’s draft includes a sedition clause. 1860: left out of the enacted IPC. 1870: Section 124A added by Act XXVII. 1891: first reported prosecution, of the Bangobasi editor. 1897: Tilak jailed for 18 months. 1898: section rewritten with three explanations. 1908: Tilak sentenced to six years’ transportation. 1922: Gandhi sentenced to six years. 1942 and 1947: Federal Court and Privy Council split on its meaning.
The colonial life of Section 124A

A sedition clause appeared in Thomas Babington Macaulay’s draft Penal Code of 1837 but was missing from the Code enacted in 1860. It was inserted ten years later, as Section 124A, by Act XXVII of 1870, introduced by Sir James Fitzjames Stephen. The Indian Penal Code (Amendment) Act of 1898 added ‘hatred or contempt’ to the offence and the three explanations that distinguished disaffection from lawful disapproval.

The section was used against the nationalist press almost from the start. Bal Gangadhar Tilak was jailed for 18 months in 1897 after Justice Arthur Strachey told the jury that disaffection meant ‘the absence of affection’, and was sentenced to six years’ transportation in 1908, which he served in Mandalay. Mahatma Gandhi, tried in Ahmedabad on 18 March 1922 for articles in Young India, pleaded guilty, called Section 124A ‘the prince among the political sections of the Indian Penal Code designed to suppress the liberty of the citizen’, and was sentenced to six years.

Sedition Meets the Constitution: 1948 to 1958

A word dropped, a ground added and two High Courts in revolt.

The Constituent Assembly deliberately left sedition out. On 1 December 1948, K.M. Munshi moved to delete it from the grounds for restricting speech, and Article 19(2) as adopted in 1950 allowed restrictions only for libel, slander, defamation, contempt of court, decency or morality, and matters undermining the security of, or tending to overthrow, the State. In Romesh Thapar and Brij Bhushan on 26 May 1950, the Supreme Court read that narrowly, and the Punjab High Court then held Section 124A void.

The First Amendment of 18 June 1951 changed the terms of the argument by adding ‘public order’, ‘friendly relations with foreign States’ and ‘incitement to an offence’. Nehru called Section 124A ‘highly objectionable and obnoxious’ during the debate but did not repeal it. Even with the new ground, the Allahabad High Court’s Full Bench struck Section 124A down on 16 May 1958, holding that it was not confined to the interest of public order. That set up the confrontation the Supreme Court resolved in 1962.

The Freeze and the Replacement: 2021 to 2026

From a Chief Justice’s question to a new law under challenge.

From freeze to replacement. 15 July 2021: Supreme Court issues notice on the challenge to Section 124A. 9 May 2022: Centre says it will re-examine the law. 11 May 2022: Section 124A put in abeyance. 12 September 2023: challenge referred to a larger Bench. 25 December 2023: Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita receives assent. 1 July 2024: BNS in force, Section 152 replaces Section 124A for new offences. 8 August 2025: notice on the Section 152 challenge. 27 February 2026: Court says the Centre’s promise cannot bind Parliament. 21 May 2026: old cases may proceed if the accused agrees. November 2026: no final ruling on either provision.
From the 2022 freeze to Section 152

The challenge that ended Section 124A’s active life began in 2021. Issuing notice on 15 July 2021, Chief Justice N.V. Ramana asked why a law used against Gandhi and Tilak was still needed. The Centre at first defended Kedar Nath, then on 9 May 2022 told the Court it would re-examine the provision. Two days later, on 11 May 2022, the Court asked governments not to register FIRs or take coercive steps under Section 124A and put pending sedition proceedings in abeyance. On 12 September 2023 a Bench led by Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud referred the challenge to a larger Bench.

Parliament then replaced the IPC. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, introduced in August 2023 and passed in its revised form on 20 and 21 December 2023, came into force on 1 July 2024 without Section 124A. Its Section 152 was challenged almost at once. The Court issued notice on 8 August 2025, and on 27 February 2026 a Bench led by Chief Justice Surya Kant said the Centre’s 2022 promise to reconsider sedition could not bind Parliament, while keeping judicial review open. On 21 May 2026 the Court clarified that old sedition cases could proceed if the accused did not object. As of 20 November 2026 neither constitutional question had been decided.

Section 124A and Section 152: What Changed?

Not textually identical, and Section 152’s validity is still pending.

Section 124A IPC versus Section 152 BNS. Status: 124A repealed for offences from 1 July 2024; 152 in force from that date. Target: 124A, hatred, contempt or disaffection towards the government established by law; 152, secession, armed rebellion, subversive or separatist activities and threats to sovereignty, unity and integrity. Mental element: 124A read through Kedar Nath; 152 says purposely or knowingly. Means: 152 adds electronic communication and financial means. Punishment: 124A life, up to 3 years, or fine; 152 life or up to 7 years, and fine. Constitutional position: 124A upheld in 1962, in abeyance since 2022; 152 challenge pending, no ruling.
Section 124A vs Section 152 (Section 152 challenge pending)
FeatureFormer IPC Section 124ABNS Section 152
Legal statusRepealed for offences from 1 July 2024; old cases continueIn force from 1 July 2024
What it protectsThe Government established by lawThe sovereignty, unity and integrity of India
Core conductBringing into hatred or contempt, or exciting disaffectionExciting secession, armed rebellion or subversive activities; encouraging separatist feelings; endangering sovereignty, unity and integrity
Mental elementNot in the text; read in through Kedar Nath‘Purposely or knowingly’
Means coveredWords, signs, visible representation or otherwiseAdds electronic communication and financial means
PunishmentLife with fine; or up to 3 years with fine; or fineLife; or up to 7 years; plus fine
Protection for criticismExplanations 2 and 3Explanation on lawful disapproval of government measures
Constitutional positionUpheld, narrowed, in 1962; in abeyance since 11 May 2022; larger Bench reference pendingChallenge pending; notice issued 8 August 2025; no ruling

Section 152 is not a copy of Section 124A. It no longer protects the government of the day, it writes in a requirement of purpose or knowledge, and it lists specific harms such as secession and armed rebellion. Those changes answer some of the objections to the old law. But petitioners point out that ‘subversive activities’ and ‘encourages feelings of separatist activities’ are undefined, that the alternative sentence has more than doubled, and that the new offence covers online speech and funding expressly. Whether the courts will read Kedar Nath’s link to violence or public disorder into Section 152, or require Parliament to narrow it, is the question the pending challenge has to answer.

Key People and Institutions

NameRole
Kedar Nath SinghForward Communist Party worker whose 1953 speech led to the 1962 ruling; his conviction was upheld
Chief Justice B.P. SinhaWrote the unanimous 1962 judgment for the five-judge Bench
Justice Naqui ImamPatna High Court judge who upheld the conviction in 1956
Thomas Babington MacaulayPrepared the 1837 draft Penal Code with an early sedition clause
James Fitzjames StephenIntroduced Section 124A in 1870
Bal Gangadhar TilakConvicted of sedition in 1897 and 1908
Mahatma GandhiSentenced under Section 124A in 1922
K.M. MunshiMoved the deletion of ‘sedition’ from the draft Constitution in 1948
S.G. VombatkereLead petitioner against Section 124A (2021) and Section 152 (2025)
Supreme Court of IndiaNarrowed Section 124A in 1962, froze it in 2022 and is examining Section 152

Conclusion: The Constitutional Question Continues

The Kedar Nath Singh judgment did two things at once. It kept a colonial offence alive for another six decades, and it fixed the line, criticism on one side and incitement or a tendency to disorder on the other, against which every prosecution under it was measured. Kedar Nath himself gained nothing from it; the people who benefited were the journalists, students and activists whose cases were later quashed because their words did not cross that line.

The repeal of Section 124A in 2024 did not end the argument. Section 152 is written differently, but it raises the same question the 1962 Court faced: whether a law that punishes words can be precise enough to leave room for dissent. Whatever the offence is called, the test is whether its wording and its use keep the distinction between opposing a government and threatening the State.

Explore More Timelines

People Also Ask

What is the Kedar Nath Singh case?
Kedar Nath Singh v. State of Bihar is the Supreme Court judgment of 20 January 1962 in which a five-judge Constitution Bench upheld the sedition offence in Section 124A of the Indian Penal Code but limited it to words or acts that involve an intention or tendency to create public disorder or incite violence. Strong criticism of the government alone is not sedition.
What did the Supreme Court decide in Kedar Nath Singh v. State of Bihar?
It held that Section 124A was a reasonable restriction on free speech in the interest of public order under Article 19(2), provided it was read narrowly: only speech with an intention or tendency to cause disorder, disturb law and order or incite violence is punishable. Criticism of government measures, however strongly worded, is protected. Section 505 was upheld too.
Is sedition still a crime in India?
Section 124A of the IPC no longer applies to offences committed after 1 July 2024, when the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita replaced the IPC. The BNS has no offence called sedition, but Section 152 punishes acts endangering India's sovereignty, unity and integrity, with up to life imprisonment. Its validity is being challenged in the Supreme Court.
Is Section 152 of the BNS the new sedition law?
Critics call it sedition in a new form, and the Supreme Court is examining that argument. Section 152 targets secession, armed rebellion, subversive activities and separatist feelings rather than disaffection towards the government, and requires the act to be done purposely or knowingly. But terms such as subversive activities are undefined, which petitioners say makes it as open to misuse as Section 124A.
Was Kedar Nath Singh acquitted?
No. The Supreme Court upheld the law, applied its narrow reading and dismissed his appeal, so his conviction and one-year sentence of rigorous imprisonment stood. His counsel had not argued that his 1953 speech fell outside sedition as the Court defined it. The connected Uttar Pradesh appeals were sent back to the Allahabad High Court.
Why was Section 124A put on hold in 2022?
On 11 May 2022, after the Centre said it would re-examine the law, the Supreme Court in S.G. Vombatkere v. Union of India asked governments not to register FIRs, continue investigations or take coercive steps under Section 124A, and kept pending sedition trials and appeals in abeyance. It was an interim order, not a finding that the law was unconstitutional.

Frequently Asked Questions

Based on the 1962 judgment, Supreme Court orders and legislative records.

Who was Kedar Nath Singh?
A member of the Forward Communist Party in Bihar. On 26 May 1953, at a meeting in Barauni, then in Monghyr district, he called the ruling party 'Congress goondas' and spoke of a revolution that would reduce capitalists, zamindars and Congress leaders to ashes. He was prosecuted for sedition and his appeal became the leading case on Section 124A.
Was Kedar Nath Singh a member of the Communist Party of India?
The Supreme Court judgment identifies him with the Forward Communist Party, and his speech, quoted in the judgment, refers to that party by name. Some summaries describe him as a CPI member, but that is not what the judgment records.
What was Kedar Nath Singh charged with?
Sedition under Section 124A and making statements conducing to public mischief under Section 505(b) of the Indian Penal Code. A first-class magistrate at Begusarai convicted him on both and sentenced him to one year of rigorous imprisonment. The Patna High Court upheld the conviction on 9 April 1956.
Who were the judges in the Kedar Nath Singh case?
Chief Justice Bhuvaneshwar Prasad Sinha, who wrote the judgment, and Justices S.K. Das, A.K. Sarkar, N. Rajagopala Ayyangar and J.R. Mudholkar. The decision was unanimous.
What is the citation of the Kedar Nath Singh case?
Kedar Nath Singh v. State of Bihar, AIR 1962 SC 955, also reported as 1962 Supp (2) SCR 769. It was decided on 20 January 1962 in Criminal Appeal No. 169 of 1957, heard with Criminal Appeals 124 to 126 of 1958.
What is the Kedar Nath test for sedition?
Words or acts fall under Section 124A only if they involve an intention or tendency to create public disorder, disturb law and order or incite violence. Comments on government measures, however strongly worded, and attempts to change them by lawful means are not sedition. Courts have applied this test to every sedition case since 1962.
Why did the Supreme Court not strike down Section 124A in 1962?
Because it found that the section could be read in a way that kept it within Article 19(2). Following the principle that courts should prefer a reading that saves a law, it adopted the Federal Court's 1942 interpretation, which required a tendency to public disorder, over the Privy Council's wider 1947 view, which would have made the section unconstitutional.
What did Section 124A of the IPC say?
It punished anyone who by words, signs or visible representation brought or attempted to bring into hatred or contempt, or excited or attempted to excite disaffection towards, the government established by law in India. The penalty was life imprisonment with fine, up to three years with fine, or a fine. Explanations protected disapproval of government measures sought to be changed by lawful means.
When was the sedition law introduced in India?
Section 124A was inserted into the Indian Penal Code by Act XXVII of 1870, introduced by Sir James Fitzjames Stephen. A similar clause had been in Thomas Babington Macaulay's 1837 draft code but was left out when the IPC was enacted in 1860. The section was rewritten in 1898.
Who were the famous people tried for sedition under British rule?
Bal Gangadhar Tilak was jailed for 18 months in 1897 and sentenced to six years' transportation in 1908, both over articles in Kesari. Mahatma Gandhi was sentenced to six years in 1922 over articles in Young India. The first reported prosecution, in 1891, was of the editor of the Bengali weekly Bangobasi.
What did Gandhi say about Section 124A?
At his trial in Ahmedabad on 18 March 1922 he called it 'the prince among the political sections of the Indian Penal Code designed to suppress the liberty of the citizen', and said affection cannot be manufactured or regulated by law. He pleaded guilty and asked for the highest penalty.
Why was sedition removed from the draft Constitution?
In the Constituent Assembly on 1 December 1948, K.M. Munshi moved to delete 'sedition' from the grounds on which speech could be restricted, arguing that criticism of the government is the essence of democracy and should not be confused with incitement to violence. The amendment was adopted, and the word does not appear in Article 19(2).
Did the First Amendment add security of the State to Article 19(2)?
No. 'Security of the State' was already in the original Article 19(2). The Constitution (First Amendment) Act, 1951 added 'public order', 'friendly relations with foreign States' and 'incitement to an offence', and required restrictions to be reasonable. The public order ground is what saved Section 124A in 1962.
What did Nehru say about the sedition law?
During the debate on the First Amendment in 1951, Prime Minister Jawaharlal Nehru said that Section 124A was 'highly objectionable and obnoxious' and that 'the sooner we get rid of it the better'. His government did not repeal it, and it remained in force until 2024.
Which High Courts struck down Section 124A before 1962?
The Punjab High Court in Tara Singh Gopi Chand v. The State, reported in 1951, and a Full Bench of the Allahabad High Court in Ram Nandan v. State on 16 May 1958. The Supreme Court overruled the Allahabad decision in Kedar Nath Singh.
What was Ram Nandan v. State of Uttar Pradesh?
A Full Bench decision of the Allahabad High Court, delivered on 16 May 1958 and reported as AIR 1959 All 101, holding Section 124A void because it was not confined to the interest of public order. Uttar Pradesh appealed, and the Supreme Court allowed those appeals in the Kedar Nath Singh judgment.
What was the difference between Niharendu Dutt Majumdar and Sadashiv Bhalerao?
In Niharendu Dutt Majumdar (1942) the Federal Court held that sedition required an intention or tendency to incite public disorder. In Sadashiv Narayan Bhalerao (1947) the Privy Council held that exciting disaffection was enough without any such tendency. In 1962 the Supreme Court followed the Federal Court.
When did sedition become a cognisable offence?
Under the Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973, which came into force on 1 April 1974. Under the old 1898 Code, police needed a magistrate's order to investigate sedition. The 1973 Code allowed arrest without a warrant, though Section 196 required government sanction before a court could take cognisance.
How many sedition cases were filed in India before the 2022 freeze?
National Crime Records Bureau figures reported in 2021 showed 326 sedition cases registered between 2014 and 2019, with convictions in six. Critics cited the low conviction rate as evidence that the law was being used to harass rather than to punish genuine threats to public order.
Which recent cases applied the Kedar Nath judgment?
In Vinod Dua v. Union of India (3 June 2021) the Supreme Court quashed a sedition FIR against the journalist, holding that his criticism of the government did not meet the Kedar Nath test. In Common Cause v. Union of India (5 September 2016) it told authorities to follow Kedar Nath when invoking Section 124A.
What is S.G. Vombatkere v. Union of India?
The lead petition challenging the constitutional validity of Section 124A, filed by retired Major General S.G. Vombatkere. The Supreme Court issued notice in July 2021, put the law in abeyance on 11 May 2022 and referred the challenge to a larger Bench on 12 September 2023. His 2025 petition against Section 152 is tagged with it.
Did the 2022 order declare sedition unconstitutional?
No. The 11 May 2022 order was an interim direction while the government reconsidered the law. It asked governments not to register FIRs or take coercive steps under Section 124A and kept pending sedition proceedings in abeyance, but it did not decide whether the provision was valid.
Why was the sedition challenge referred to a larger Bench in 2023?
Because Kedar Nath Singh was decided by five judges and a three-judge Bench could not overrule it. On 12 September 2023 a Bench led by Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud referred the matter, refusing to wait for the new criminal laws because they would apply only prospectively, leaving old prosecutions to be judged under Section 124A.
What did the Law Commission recommend on sedition in 2023?
In Report No. 279, released in June 2023, the 22nd Law Commission recommended retaining Section 124A, adding the Kedar Nath test of a tendency to incite violence or public disorder to the text, requiring a preliminary inquiry before an FIR, and raising the alternative prison term from three to seven years.
When was the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita passed?
A first version was introduced on 11 August 2023 and later withdrawn. The revised Bill was introduced on 12 December 2023, passed by the Lok Sabha on 20 December and the Rajya Sabha on 21 December, and received the President's assent on 25 December 2023. It came into force on 1 July 2024.
What does Section 152 of the BNS say?
It punishes anyone who purposely or knowingly, by words, signs, visible representation, electronic communication, financial means or otherwise, excites or attempts to excite secession, armed rebellion or subversive activities, encourages feelings of separatist activities, or endangers the sovereignty, unity and integrity of India. The penalty is life imprisonment or up to seven years, with a fine.
How is Section 152 different from Section 124A?
Section 124A protected 'the Government established by law' from disaffection; Section 152 protects India's sovereignty, unity and integrity. Section 152 adds an express requirement that the act be done purposely or knowingly, covers electronic communication and financial means, and raises the alternative sentence from three years to seven. Both carry a maximum of life imprisonment.
Does Section 152 protect criticism of the government?
Its explanation says that comments disapproving of government measures, administrative or other action, made with a view to changing them by lawful means and without exciting the prohibited activities, are not an offence. Petitioners argue that this protection is weaker in practice because terms such as subversive activities are not defined.
Has the Supreme Court decided whether Section 152 is valid?
No. It issued notice on 8 August 2025 in a petition by S.G. Vombatkere and has heard related matters since, including on 27 February 2026, when it said the Centre's earlier promise to reconsider sedition could not bind Parliament. We found no final ruling on Section 152 as of 20 November 2026.
What happens to sedition cases filed before July 2024?
They continue under the IPC because the BNS applies only to offences committed after 1 July 2024. Under the Supreme Court's 2022 order, the sedition charge in those cases stays in abeyance. On 21 May 2026 the Court clarified that such trials and appeals can proceed if the accused does not object.
What was Kamran v. State of Madhya Pradesh?
The case in which the Supreme Court clarified on 21 May 2026 that its 2022 freeze did not prevent sedition proceedings from going ahead if the accused had no objection. The petitioner had reportedly spent about 17 years in custody, and his appeal against a 2017 life sentence on charges including Section 124A was pending in the Madhya Pradesh High Court.
Why does the Kedar Nath judgment still matter after the BNS?
Because every case registered under Section 124A before 1 July 2024 is still governed by it, and because courts examining Section 152 are expected to draw on its distinction between criticism of the government and incitement to violence or public disorder. It also remains the precedent the larger Bench will have to confirm or overrule.

⚠️ Editorial Note: What We Checked

We checked the brief we started from against the text of the 1962 judgment, Supreme Court orders, the BNS and its commencement notification, and reports by Supreme Court Observer, LiveLaw and The Indian Express. Kedar Nath Singh’s party is given in the judgment as the Forward Communist Party, not the CPI. His appeal was dismissed; the brief did not say so. The First Amendment added public order; security of the State was in the original Article 19(2). The 1951 ruling came from the Punjab High Court, and the Allahabad Full Bench ruled on 16 May 1958, not 1959. The revised BNS was introduced on 12 December 2023 and passed on 20 and 21 December. We could not confirm the exact day in 1870 when Section 124A took effect, so only the year is given. Reports of the February and May 2026 hearings are based on court reporting, not full written orders. This article explains the law; it is not legal advice.

Related Reading on AiTimeline

Fodder Scam: A Timeline of India’s Notorious Corruption Case Tariff Walls and Trade Bridges: The Hidden Forces Reshaping Global Trade
New article
→
Next Article