← AiTimeline Home

Haryana · 1967 to 2026 · Defections and the Tenth Schedule

Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram: Haryana Defections Explained

📅 Last updated: 19 November 2026⏱ 27 dated entries✎ By Nazish Fatima

View as Web Story

In short

Discover how Gaya Lal's party-switching in Haryana in 1967 created the phrase Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram and led to India's Anti-Defection Law of 1985.

Latest Story

In March 1967, weeks after Haryana’s first Assembly election, an Independent MLA named Gaya Lal changed sides so often in so few days that the man who won him back, Rao Birender Singh, presented him to the press with a joke: “Gaya Ram is now Aaya Ram.” This Aaya Ram Gaya Ram timeline follows the episode from the Speaker vote that broke the Congress majority to President’s Rule in November 1967, and then traces what the phrase led to: the Committee on Defections, the Anti-Defection Law of 1985, the 2003 amendment, and the Supreme Court cases that still shape how defections are judged. Dates and quotations are checked against the court record.

Read this first: five common errors

Haryana voted in February 1967, with the general election, not in March; the government was sworn in on 10 March. Accounts of Gaya Lal’s switches differ: three times in nine hours, twice in nine hours, or three times in a fortnight, depending on the source. Rao Birender Singh did not leave office on 2 November 1967; the President’s Proclamation that ended his government is dated 21 November 1967. The Chavan Committee was not a 1973 body: the Lok Sabha asked for it on 8 December 1967 and its report is dated 7 January 1969. And 12 November 1991 was not a hearing date in Kihoto Hollohan: it is the day the Court announced its conclusions, with reasons on 18 February 1992.

💡 Short Answer

“Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram” is the Indian political phrase for a legislator who keeps switching parties. It comes from Haryana in March 1967, when Independent MLA Gaya Lal moved between the Congress and the United Front several times in a few days, and Rao Birender Singh, newly Chief Minister, announced that “Gaya Ram is now Aaya Ram.” Defections brought down Haryana’s Assembly in November 1967 and helped lead to the Anti-Defection Law, the Tenth Schedule added by the 52nd Amendment on 15 February 1985.

⚡ Facts at a Glance
OriginHaryana, March 1967
The MLAGaya Lal, Hassanpur (SC)
Coined byRao Birender Singh
Assembly dissolved21 November 1967
Anti-Defection Law52nd Amendment, 15 Feb 1985
Split exception removed91st Amendment, 2003
⚡ Quick Answers — AI Overview Ready

Aaya Ram Gaya Ram: Key Questions

What does “Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram” mean?
Literally “Ram came, Ram went”. It describes politicians who switch parties, often back and forth, for office or advantage. It was coined after Haryana MLA Gaya Lal’s repeated switches in March 1967.
Who said “Gaya Ram is now Aaya Ram”?
Rao Birender Singh, who became Haryana’s Chief Minister on 24 March 1967. He said it at a press conference in Chandigarh when Gaya Lal came back to his United Front.
What happened to Haryana’s government?
The Congress ministry fell in March 1967 after 12 of its MLAs defected in the Speaker vote. Rao Birender Singh’s government lasted until a President’s Rule Proclamation dated 21 November 1967 dissolved the Assembly.
How is it linked to the Anti-Defection Law?
Haryana became the leading example of the post-1967 defection wave. A committee reported in 1969, and Parliament finally added the Tenth Schedule through the 52nd Amendment, which received assent on 15 February 1985.
📚 Key Takeaways

The Story in Ten Lines

  • The election: Congress won 48 of 81 seats in Haryana in February 1967.
  • The first break: 12 Congress MLAs voted against their own Speaker nominee on 17 March.
  • The switch: Rao Birender Singh became Chief Minister on 24 March at the head of a United Front.
  • The phrase: Gaya Lal’s back-and-forth produced “Gaya Ram is now Aaya Ram”.
  • The collapse: about 30 of 79 members defected, some three or four times, the Governor reported.
  • The end: President’s Rule and dissolution, by Proclamation dated 21 November 1967.
  • The national wave: at least 438 defections across India in 12 months, against about 542 in the previous 15 years.
  • The law: the Tenth Schedule, added by the 52nd Amendment in 1985.
  • The fix: the 91st Amendment in 2003 removed the one-third split exception.
  • The courts: Speakers’ decisions are reviewable (1992) and should come within three months (2020).
Aaya Ram Gaya Ram in figures: 81 Assembly seats in 1967; 48 won by the Congress; 12 Congress MLAs voted against their party in the Speaker election on 17 March 1967; Gaya Lal switched sides more than once within about nine hours; some 30 of 79 members defected by November 1967; 438 defections nationally in 12 months.
By the numbers

Haryana, 1967: A Majority That Lasted Twelve Days

From the first election to President’s Rule in nine months.

Haryana Assembly election, February 1967, 81 seats: Indian National Congress 48, Bharatiya Jana Sangh 12, Independents 16, Swatantra Party 3, Republican Party of India 2. Majority mark 41.
The first Assembly, 1967

A new State, a familiar party. Haryana was carved out of Punjab on 1 November 1966, and Bhagwat Dayal Sharma, a minister in undivided Punjab, became its first Chief Minister. In February 1967 the Congress won 48 of the 81 seats, a majority of seven.

The Speaker vote. Sharma was sworn in on 10 March. On 17 March the official Congress nominee for Speaker lost because 12 Congress members, among them Rao Birender Singh of Pataudi, voted against him. Rao Birender Singh became Speaker. “So 12 Congress members defected from that party,” the Punjab and Haryana High Court later wrote.

A new government. The Sharma ministry resigned on 22 March. Two days later Rao Birender Singh formed a ministry of the Haryana Samyukta Dal, a United Front of Congress rebels, Independents and opposition members, with 47 members behind him.

No settling down. “Thereafter there were efforts to win over members on both sides and so defections followed,” the court recorded. By November the Governor counted about 30 defectors in a House of 79.

How Haryana’s first elected government fell: February 1967 election, Congress 48 of 81; 10 March Bhagwat Dayal Sharma sworn in; 17 March Congress Speaker nominee defeated as 12 Congress MLAs vote against him; 22 March Sharma ministry resigns; 24 March Rao Birender Singh forms a United Front ministry; 17 November Governor’s report; 21 November President’s Rule and dissolution.
Nine months in 1967

Gaya Lal and the Birth of a Phrase

One MLA, several switches, and a line that outlived them all.

The MLA. Gaya Lal won Hassanpur, a seat reserved for Scheduled Castes, as an Independent, beating the Congress candidate by 360 votes. Within days he joined the Congress.

The switches. As the Congress majority unravelled, he crossed to the United Front, came back to the Congress, and crossed again. The Indian Express’s 2024 explainer says all three moves happened within nine hours; its history of Haryana’s elections says two of them did, with the final move within a fortnight. Either way, the speed was the point.

The line. When Gaya Lal returned to the United Front, Rao Birender Singh brought him before reporters in Chandigarh and said: “Gaya Ram is now Aaya Ram.” The rhyme was too good to fade. Union Home Minister Y.B. Chavan later used it in Parliament to describe turncoats, and it became the standard Hindi shorthand for a politician who changes sides.

The career. Gaya Lal did not stop. He contested on the Arya Sabha ticket in 1972, joined the Bharatiya Lok Dal in 1974, and won in 1977 as a Janata Party candidate.

Gaya Lal’s moves in 1967: elected as an Independent from Hassanpur (SC); joined the Congress after the result; moved to the United Front; returned to the Congress; went back to the United Front, where Rao Birender Singh presented him as “Aaya Ram”. Sources disagree on timing: three switches in nine hours, two in nine hours plus one within a fortnight, or three in a fortnight.
Independent to United Front, with stops in between

Aaya Ram Gaya Ram Timeline, 1966 to 2026

Newest first. Each entry is tagged by type.

Haryana 1967Defections nationwideParliament and the lawCourtsRecent disputes
3 Aug 2026

The merger exception comes under fresh scrutiny Recent disputes

The New Indian Express explainerQuestions pending before the Supreme Court

What was reported: The New Indian Express reported that the Supreme Court is examining important questions on the Tenth Schedule, including whether legislators can claim the merger exception on the strength of numbers alone, without the original political party itself merging with another party.

Why it matters: Many constitutional experts read Paragraph 4 as needing two things: a merger of the original party, and the agreement of at least two-thirds of its legislators. If numbers alone were enough, a group of legislators could switch sides without any party decision at all.

Status: These proceedings are pending. Until the Court rules, the questions are open and should not be read as settled law.

The same report noted that the Tenth Schedule still sets no time limit for a Speaker to decide a disqualification petition.
2025-26

TMC and AAP defections revive the debate Recent disputes

Petitions before the Lok Sabha SpeakerNo statutory deadline

What happened: According to The New Indian Express, the Trinamool Congress asked the Lok Sabha Speaker for an early decision on disqualification petitions against MPs elected on its symbol who later aligned with another formation. The Aam Aadmi Party also saw elected representatives resign or join rival parties.

Why it matters: The cases put the spotlight back on the gap the courts have repeatedly flagged: a petition can stay pending while the member keeps sitting and voting.

The phrase coined in Haryana in 1967 is still the shorthand used in coverage of these disputes.
31 Jul 2025

Supreme Court sets a three-month deadline in the Telangana case Courts

Padi Kaushik Reddy v. State of Telangana2025 INSC 912Chief Justice B.R. Gavai, Justice A.G. Masih

What happened: Ten MLAs elected on the Bharat Rashtra Samithi ticket in 2023 were alleged to have joined the Congress in 2024. The Supreme Court directed the Telangana Speaker to decide the disqualification petitions against them within three months of the judgment, and not to let the MLAs drag out the proceedings.

The warning: The Court said that without a direction it would be allowing the Speaker to repeat the “widely criticized situation of ‘operation successful, patient died’”.

A question for Parliament: It added that it was for Parliament to consider whether giving the Speaker the job of deciding defection cases is “serving the purpose of effectively combating political defections or not”.

The Court declined to decide the disqualifications itself, saying every Constitution Bench from Kihoto Hollohan onward had left the first decision to the Speaker.
28 Jan 2024

Kharge revives the phrase after Nitish Kumar switches sides Recent disputes

BiharNitish Kumar sworn in for the ninth time

What happened: Nitish Kumar took oath as Bihar Chief Minister for the ninth time after his Janata Dal (United) left the Mahagathbandhan, which included the Congress, and allied with the BJP.

The comment: Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge said: “There are many aaya Ram, gaya Rams in the country. He could have stayed had he wanted.”

Why it matters: A change of alliance by a party is not a defection under the Tenth Schedule, but the phrase from 1967 is still how such switches are described in public debate.

The Indian Express marked the moment with an explainer on Gaya Lal, the Haryana MLA behind the phrase.

The NCP splits Recent disputes

Ajit Pawar sworn in as Deputy Chief Minister, 2 July 2023Rival claims to the party

What happened: Ajit Pawar and a group of NCP legislators joined the Shiv Sena-BJP government in Maharashtra, setting off rival claims over the party’s name, symbol and leadership.

The questions: As in the Shiv Sena dispute, the fight was over which faction was the “real” party, and how the Speaker’s role under the Tenth Schedule fits with the Election Commission’s power over party recognition.

Why it matters: In February 2024 the Election Commission and then the Maharashtra Speaker recognised Ajit Pawar’s faction as the NCP, and no legislator was disqualified.

Neither the 1985 law nor the 2003 amendment says how to decide which of two factions is the original party.
11 May 2023

Supreme Court rules on the Shiv Sena split Courts

Subhash Desai v. Principal Secretary, Governor of MaharashtraFive-judge Constitution Bench

What happened: The Court held that the legislature party cannot act on its own, cut off from the political party, when appointing a whip, and that the Governor had not had objective material to call a floor test in June 2022.

What it could not do: Because Uddhav Thackeray had resigned rather than face the floor test, the Court said it could not restore his government.

The Speaker’s role: It left the disqualification petitions for the Speaker to decide within a reasonable period. In January 2024 the Speaker recognised Eknath Shinde’s faction as the Shiv Sena and disqualified no one.

The ruling drew a sharp line between a political party and its group of legislators, the same distinction at the heart of the merger debate.

The Shiv Sena split Recent disputes

MaharashtraEknath Shinde sworn in as Chief Minister, 30 June 2022

What happened: A majority of Shiv Sena MLAs led by Eknath Shinde rebelled against Chief Minister Uddhav Thackeray. Thackeray resigned on 29 June and Shinde became Chief Minister the next day with BJP support.

Why it matters: Both sides filed disqualification petitions. The case raised questions about party organisation against legislature party, rival whips and the Speaker’s powers.

In February 2023 the Election Commission allotted the Shiv Sena name and bow-and-arrow symbol to the Shinde faction.
21 Jan 2020

Decide within three months, the Court tells Speakers Courts

Keisham Meghachandra Singh v. Speaker, Manipur Legislative AssemblySupreme Court

What happened: A Congress MLA in Manipur had joined the BJP government as a minister while a petition to disqualify him lay undecided. The Court held that Speakers must decide disqualification petitions within a reasonable period and that, absent exceptional circumstances, three months is the outer limit.

A wider suggestion: It asked Parliament to consider whether disputes should go to an independent body instead of the Speaker, who usually belongs to a political party.

Why it matters: Later cases, including the 2025 Telangana judgment, treat this as the benchmark.

The three-month rule is a judicial guideline, not a deadline written into the Constitution.

Rajendra Singh Rana: a claimed split does not save defectors Courts

Rajendra Singh Rana v. Swami Prasad MauryaFive-judge Constitution Bench

What happened: BSP MLAs in Uttar Pradesh had claimed in 2003 that they formed a one-third split, and the Speaker had accepted it. The Supreme Court held that the claimed split did not protect them and that they stood disqualified.

The principle: A Speaker’s failure to decide a disqualification petition is itself open to judicial review. Delay cannot be used to defeat the purpose of the Tenth Schedule.

In this case the Court decided the disqualification question itself, a step later benches have declined to repeat.

The 91st Amendment removes the split exception Parliament and the law

Constitution (Ninety-first Amendment) Act, 2003Paragraph 3 of the Tenth Schedule deleted

What changed: The exception that protected a “split” of at least one-third of a legislature party was deleted. It had come to be seen as a route for engineered defections.

What stayed: The merger exception in Paragraph 4 survived: protection applies when the original party merges with another and at least two-thirds of its legislators agree.

New limits: The Council of Ministers was capped at 15% of the House, with a minimum of 12 in the States, and a member disqualified for defection cannot become a minister or hold a remunerative political post until re-elected.

The ministerial cap was aimed at one of the oldest motives for defection: the 1969 Committee on Defections found that 116 of 210 defectors in seven States had become ministers.
18 Feb 1992

Kihoto Hollohan: the law upheld, the Speaker made reviewable Courts

Kihoto Hollohan v. ZachillhuFive-judge Constitution Bench, 3-2

What happened: The Court gave its reasons for upholding the Tenth Schedule. The majority, Justices Venkatachaliah, K. Jayachandra Reddy and S.C. Agrawal, held that the Speaker acts as a tribunal and that the decision is open to judicial review, ordinarily only after it has been made.

Paragraph 7 struck down: Paragraph 7, which barred courts from disqualification matters, changed the jurisdiction of the High Courts and the Supreme Court, so it needed ratification by half the State legislatures under Article 368. It had not been ratified, and the majority held it invalid and severable.

The minority: Justices L.M. Sharma and J.S. Verma agreed Paragraph 7 needed ratification but would have struck down the whole amendment.

The Court relied on the 1969 Committee on Defections report, which singled out Haryana as “a conspicuous example” of repeated defections.
12 Nov 1991

The Court announces its conclusions Courts

Hearing ended 1 November 1991Reasons given on 18 February 1992

What happened: After a hearing that ended on 1 November, the five judges pronounced their operative conclusions on 12 November 1991, after the Diwali vacation, with reasons to follow.

Correction: Some accounts list 12 November 1991 as the date the challenge was heard. It is the date the conclusions were pronounced.

Counsel challenging the law included F.S. Nariman, Shanti Bhushan, Kapil Sibal and Ram Jethmalani.
15 Feb 1985

The 52nd Amendment becomes law Parliament and the law

Constitution (Fifty-second Amendment) Act, 1985Tenth Schedule inserted

What happened: The President gave assent on 15 February 1985, and the Act was published in the Gazette the same day. It amended Articles 101, 102, 190 and 191 and added the Tenth Schedule.

The grounds: A member elected on a party ticket is disqualified for voluntarily giving up party membership, or for voting or abstaining against the party’s direction without permission unless the party condones it within 15 days. An Independent who joins a party after election is disqualified, as is a nominated member who joins one more than six months after taking the seat.

The exceptions: A split of at least one-third of a legislature party, and a merger backed by at least two-thirds. The Speaker or Chairman decides.

The Statement of Objects and Reasons began: “The evil of political defections has been a matter of national concern.”

Rajiv Gandhi’s government brings the anti-defection bill Parliament and the law

Lok Sabha passed it 30 JanuaryRajya Sabha passed it 31 January

What happened: After the Congress won a large majority in December 1984, the President’s Address promised an anti-defection bill in the current session. Both Houses passed it unanimously within two days.

Why it matters: Earlier attempts after the 1969 report had lapsed. This time the government had the numbers for a constitutional amendment.

The bill was meant, in its own words, for “outlawing defection”.
7 Jan 1969

The Committee on Defections reports Defections nationwide

Chaired by Union Home Minister Y.B. ChavanReport quoted by the Supreme Court in 1992

The numbers: “Compared to roughly 542 cases in the entire period between the First and Fourth General Election, at least 438 defections occurred in these 12 months alone,” the report said of March 1967 to February 1968. Of 376 Independents elected, 157 joined parties.

The motive: Of 210 defecting legislators in Bihar, Haryana, Madhya Pradesh, Punjab, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal, 116 became ministers in governments they helped form.

Haryana: The report named “multiple acts of defections by the same persons or set of persons” as a disturbing feature, “Haryana affording a conspicuous example”.

Some accounts date the Chavan Committee to 1973. Its report is dated 7 January 1969; a later anti-defection bill was introduced in 1973.
12 May 1968

Haryana votes again Haryana 1967

81 seatsBansi Lal becomes Chief Minister, 21 May 1968

What happened: In the fresh election the Congress won 48 seats, the same number as in 1967. Rao Birender Singh’s Vishal Haryana Party came second with 16.

What followed: Indira Gandhi chose Bansi Lal as Chief Minister. He held the post until 30 November 1975, when he moved to the Centre.

Rao Birender Singh went on to the Lok Sabha and became a Union minister; he merged his party with the Congress in 1978.
1 Mar 1968

High Court dismisses Rao Birender Singh’s challenge Courts

Rao Birinder Singh v. Union of IndiaPunjab and Haryana High CourtChief Justice Mehar Singh, Justice Narula

What happened: The former Chief Minister asked the court to quash the President’s Proclamation, arguing that he still had a majority and that the action was mala fide.

The ruling: The court held that the facts in the Governor’s report could not be questioned and that the President’s satisfaction was not open to its review. The petition was dismissed.

Why it matters: The judgment records the official version of the 1967 events, from the Speaker vote to the Governor’s report.

A quarter-century later, the Supreme Court’s 1994 S.R. Bommai judgment opened President’s Rule proclamations to much closer review.
8 Dec 1967

The Lok Sabha asks for a committee on defections Defections nationwide

Unanimous resolutionFourth Lok Sabha

What happened: The Lok Sabha unanimously resolved that a high-level committee of representatives of political parties and constitutional experts be set up “to consider the problem of legislators changing their allegiance from one party to another and their frequent crossing of the floor”.

Why it matters: This was Parliament’s first formal step against defection, taken weeks after Haryana’s Assembly was dissolved.

Home Minister Y.B. Chavan, who chaired the committee, is also said to have used the phrase “Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram” in Parliament.
21 Nov 1967

President’s Rule: the Assembly is dissolved Haryana 1967

Proclamation by President Zakir HusainArticle 356

What happened: Acting on the Governor’s report, the President assumed the functions of the State government and dissolved the Haryana Assembly. Rao Birender Singh’s government ended.

Correction: Some accounts say Rao Birender Singh left office on 2 November 1967. The High Court record gives the Proclamation date as 21 November 1967; some lists date the change to 20 November.

Rao Birender Singh argued in court that he still commanded a majority when he was removed.
17 Nov 1967

The Governor’s report: defection “has become endemic” Haryana 1967

Governor B.N. ChakravartyReport to the President

What it said: “In an Assembly with an effective strength of 79, some 30 members have defected one way or the other. Some members have defected not once but even three or four times.”

The motive: “It is not for any ideological reasons that members are defecting from one party to another. The motive is obviously to secure some personal gain.”

The recommendation: He wrote that no stable ministry could be formed without a fresh election and recommended dissolving the Assembly.

The report singled out one MLA, Hira Nand Arya, who defected after serving as a minister for five days.

“Gaya Ram is now Aaya Ram” Haryana 1967

Gaya Lal, MLA from Hassanpur (SC)Press conference in Chandigarh

What happened: Gaya Lal, elected as an Independent, had joined the Congress soon after the result. In the scramble around Rao Birender Singh’s takeover he moved between the Congress and the United Front, the Haryana Samyukta Dal, more than once.

Accounts differ: The Indian Express’s 2024 explainer says he switched three times within nine hours: to the United Front, back to the Congress, then to the United Front again. Its electoral history of Haryana says he switched twice in nine hours and moved to the United Front within a fortnight. Other accounts say three times in a fortnight.

The line: When Gaya Lal returned to his side, Rao Birender Singh presented him to reporters in Chandigarh and declared: “Gaya Ram is now Aaya Ram.” The phrase stuck, and came to mean any legislator who changes sides for advantage.

Gaya Lal kept moving: he contested on the Arya Sabha ticket in 1972, joined the Bharatiya Lok Dal in 1974 and won in 1977 as a Janata Party candidate.
24 Mar 1967

Rao Birender Singh becomes Chief Minister Haryana 1967

Haryana Samyukta Dal (United Front)47 members, per the High Court

What happened: Elected leader of the Haryana Samyukta Dal, a combination of Congress defectors, Independents and opposition members, Rao Birender Singh formed a ministry with himself as Chief Minister.

What followed: “Thereafter there were efforts to win over members on both sides and so defections followed,” the High Court later recorded. He later formed the Vishal Haryana Party.

He had been Speaker for only six days, from 17 to 23 March 1967.
22 Mar 1967

The Congress ministry resigns Haryana 1967

Bhagwat Dayal Sharma steps down

What happened: Five days after losing the Speaker’s election, the Sharma ministry resigned. It had lasted less than two weeks after the election.

Why it matters: A party that had won a majority at the polls was out of office without any fresh vote by the people.

The resignation came twelve days after the swearing-in.
17 Mar 1967

Twelve Congress MLAs defeat their own party in the Speaker vote Haryana 1967

Election of the SpeakerRao Birender Singh, MLA from Pataudi

What happened: The official Congress nominee for Speaker was defeated because 12 Congress members, including Rao Birender Singh, voted against him. Rao Birender Singh was elected Speaker.

Why it matters: “So 12 Congress members defected from that party,” the High Court later summed up. It was the first crack in the new government.

The Indian Express describes the 12 as forming a group called the Haryana Congress.
10 Mar 1967

Bhagwat Dayal Sharma forms the first elected government Haryana 1967

Congress, 48 of 81 seats

What happened: With a majority of 48 in the 81-member Assembly, the Congress formed the government with Bhagwat Dayal Sharma as Chief Minister.

Why it matters: On paper it was a comfortable majority of seven. It lasted twelve days.

Sharma had been Haryana’s Chief Minister since the State was created, before any Haryana election.

Haryana’s first Assembly election Haryana 1967

Held with the fourth general election81 seats

The result: Congress 48, Bharatiya Jana Sangh 12, Swatantra Party 3, Republican Party of India 2, Independents 16.

The national picture: The Congress lost ground across India; it won 283 Lok Sabha seats, down from 361, and lost power in several States.

Gaya Lal’s win: In Hassanpur, a seat reserved for Scheduled Castes, Gaya Lal won as an Independent with 10,458 votes, 360 more than the Congress candidate.

Some accounts place this election in March 1967. Polling was in February, with the general election; the new government was sworn in on 10 March.
1 Nov 1966

Haryana becomes a State Haryana 1967

Punjab Reorganisation Act, 1966Chandigarh a shared Union Territory capital

What happened: Haryana was carved out of Punjab. Bhagwat Dayal Sharma, a minister in undivided Punjab, became its first Chief Minister.

Why it matters: The new State’s first elected Assembly would become the most famous example of defection in Indian politics within months.

The State began with 54 Assembly seats carried over from undivided Punjab; the number rose to 81 for 1967.

Not Just Haryana: The 1967 Defection Wave

What the Committee on Defections found.

Defections in India according to the Committee on Defections report of 7 January 1969: about 542 cases between the first general election in 1951-52 and the fourth in 1967; at least 438 in the 12 months from March 1967 to February 1968; 157 of 376 elected Independents joined parties; 116 of 210 defecting legislators in seven States became ministers.
The 1969 report in numbers

A national pattern. The 1967 elections cut the Congress to 283 Lok Sabha seats from 361 and cost it power in several States. Where majorities were thin, legislators found their votes in demand. The Committee on Defections counted at least 438 defections in the year after the election, against about 542 in the fifteen years before it.

Office as the prize. In Bihar, Haryana, Madhya Pradesh, Punjab, Rajasthan, Uttar Pradesh and West Bengal, 116 of 210 defectors ended up as ministers in the governments their switches created.

Haryana as the example. Among the “disturbing features” the committee listed were “multiple acts of defections by the same persons or set of persons (Haryana affording a conspicuous example)”. The Supreme Court quoted that passage when it upheld the Anti-Defection Law in 1992.

How the Anti-Defection Law Works

The Tenth Schedule, in plain terms.

How the Tenth Schedule works. A member can be disqualified for: voluntarily giving up party membership; voting or abstaining against the party direction without permission, unless condoned within 15 days; an Independent joining a party after election; a nominated member joining a party after six months. The exception: a merger of the original party backed by two-thirds of the legislature party. The Speaker or Chairman decides, subject to judicial review.
Four grounds, one exception, one judge
SituationLegal position
Member voluntarily gives up party membershipCan be disqualified; no formal resignation needed
Member defies the party direction in a voteCan be disqualified unless condoned within 15 days
Independent joins a party after electionCan be disqualified
Nominated member joins a party after six monthsCan be disqualified
Original party merges, two-thirds agreeProtected under Paragraph 4
One-third of legislators claim a splitNo protection since 2003

Conduct counts. “Voluntarily giving up membership” has been read broadly. Public support for a rival party or taking part in its activities can be enough, without a resignation letter.

The merger condition. The two-thirds figure is often described as a licence for two-thirds of legislators to switch. The text is narrower: the original political party must merge, and two-thirds of the legislature party must agree. Whether numbers alone can satisfy it is now before the Supreme Court.

What Changed: the 52nd and 91st Amendments

1985 built the law; 2003 closed its biggest loophole.

The 52nd Amendment (1985) compared with the 91st Amendment (2003). Tenth Schedule: introduced in 1985, retained in 2003. One-third split exception: introduced in 1985, removed in 2003. Two-thirds merger exception: introduced, retained. Speaker as adjudicator: established, retained. Council of Ministers: no cap in 1985; capped at 15% of the House, minimum 12 in States, in 2003. Disqualified defectors: barred from ministerial and remunerative political posts from 2003.
1985 versus 2003
Feature52nd Amendment, 198591st Amendment, 2003
Tenth ScheduleIntroducedRetained
One-third split exceptionIntroducedRemoved
Two-thirds merger exceptionIntroducedRetained
Speaker as adjudicatorEstablishedRetained
Size of Council of MinistersNo cap15% of the House; minimum 12 in States
Disqualified defector as ministerNot barredBarred until re-elected

The Courts and the Tenth Schedule

Five judgments that shape every defection case.

CaseDateWhat it settled
Kihoto Hollohan12 Nov 1991 / 18 Feb 1992Law upheld; Speaker reviewable; Paragraph 7 struck down
Rajendra Singh RanaFeb 2007Claimed split no shield; Speaker’s inaction reviewable
Keisham Meghachandra Singh21 Jan 2020Three months as the outer limit
Subhash Desai11 May 2023Legislature party cannot act cut off from the party
Padi Kaushik Reddy31 Jul 2025Speaker ordered to decide within three months

Why the Law Is Still Argued Over

Stability against independence. The law stops governments being toppled by members who change sides for office. It also means a legislator who votes on conscience against the whip risks the seat. The Dinesh Goswami Committee and the Law Commission suggested limiting whips to votes that decide a government’s survival.

The Speaker as judge. Speakers are usually elected from the majority. The Supreme Court has twice, in 2020 and 2025, asked Parliament to consider whether someone else should decide.

Delay. With no deadline in the text, a petition can sit until the defector has served the purpose of the switch. The Court’s phrase for it in 2025 was “operation successful, patient died”.

Party against legislators. The Shiv Sena and NCP disputes turned on which faction was the original party, a question the 1985 law did not foresee.

The merger clause. Whether two-thirds of legislators can claim protection without a merger of the party itself is the open question of 2026.

Who Was Who

The MLA

Gaya Lal

Independent from Hassanpur (SC), whose switches in March 1967 gave the phrase its name.

Coined the phrase

Rao Birender Singh

Pataudi MLA, Speaker for six days, Chief Minister from 24 March to November 1967. Later a Union minister.

First Chief Minister

Bhagwat Dayal Sharma

Led Haryana from 1 November 1966; his elected ministry resigned on 22 March 1967.

Committee chairman

Y.B. Chavan

Union Home Minister; chaired the Committee on Defections, which reported on 7 January 1969.

Prime Minister, 1985

Rajiv Gandhi

His government passed the 52nd Amendment within weeks of the December 1984 election.

After 1968

Bansi Lal

Became Chief Minister on 21 May 1968, after the fresh election that followed the dissolution.

Did You Know?

  • A six-day Speaker: Rao Birender Singh was Speaker from 17 to 23 March 1967 before becoming Chief Minister.
  • A five-day minister: the Governor’s report named an MLA who defected after five days as a minister.
  • The same 48: the Congress won exactly 48 of 81 seats in both 1967 and 1968.
  • A family in politics: Gaya Lal’s son, Udai Bhan, later became president of the Haryana Congress.
  • Unanimous in 1985: both Houses passed the anti-defection bill without a vote against it.
  • Still in use: Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge used the phrase on 28 January 2024 about Nitish Kumar.

Explore More Timelines

People Also Ask

What does Aaya Ram Gaya Ram mean?
Literally “Ram came, Ram went”. It describes a politician who changes party allegiance, often back and forth in a short time, usually for office or advantage. The phrase was coined in Haryana in 1967 after MLA Gaya Lal’s repeated switches.
Who coined the phrase Aaya Ram Gaya Ram?
Rao Birender Singh, who became Haryana’s Chief Minister on 24 March 1967. When Independent MLA Gaya Lal returned to his side, he presented him to reporters in Chandigarh and declared: “Gaya Ram is now Aaya Ram.”
Who was Gaya Lal?
An Independent MLA elected in 1967 from Hassanpur, a seat reserved for Scheduled Castes in Haryana, who joined the Congress after the result and then switched between the Congress and the United Front several times in a few days. He kept changing parties for years afterwards.
How many times did Gaya Lal change parties?
Accounts differ. The Indian Express’s 2024 explainer says three times within nine hours. Its electoral history of Haryana says twice within nine hours and once more within a fortnight. Other accounts say three times in a fortnight.
What is the Anti-Defection Law?
The Tenth Schedule of the Constitution, added by the 52nd Amendment in 1985. It disqualifies MPs and MLAs who voluntarily give up their party’s membership, defy its whip without permission, or, as Independents, join a party after election. The Speaker or Chairman decides.
Is the two-thirds rule a licence to switch parties?
No. Paragraph 4 protects legislators only when their original political party merges with another party and at least two-thirds of the legislature party agree. Whether numbers alone, without a party merger, are enough is one of the questions pending before the Supreme Court.

Frequently Asked Questions

Based on the 1968 High Court judgment, the 1969 Committee report as quoted in Kihoto Hollohan, the 52nd Amendment and later Supreme Court rulings.

When did the Aaya Ram Gaya Ram episode happen?
In March 1967, in the weeks after Haryana’s first Assembly election, as the Congress government of Bhagwat Dayal Sharma fell and Rao Birender Singh formed a United Front government on 24 March.
Which party won Haryana’s first Assembly election?
The Congress, with 48 of 81 seats. The Bharatiya Jana Sangh won 12, the Swatantra Party 3, the Republican Party of India 2, and Independents 16. Polling was in February 1967, alongside the general election.
Why did the Bhagwat Dayal Sharma government fall?
On 17 March 1967 twelve Congress MLAs, including Rao Birender Singh, voted against the party’s nominee for Speaker, and Rao Birender Singh was elected Speaker instead. The ministry resigned on 22 March 1967.
What was the Haryana Samyukta Dal?
The United Front formed in March 1967 from Congress defectors, Independents and opposition members. Rao Birender Singh was elected its leader and formed a ministry on 24 March 1967; the High Court later put its strength at 47.
Which constituency did Gaya Lal represent?
Hassanpur, a seat reserved for Scheduled Castes, in the area now covered by the Hodal constituency in Palwal district. He won in 1967 by 360 votes, 10,458 to 10,098, over the Congress candidate.
What did Gaya Lal do after 1967?
He kept changing parties. He contested on the Arya Sabha ticket in 1972, joined the Bharatiya Lok Dal in 1974, and won in 1977 as a Janata Party candidate after the Lok Dal merged into the Janata Party.
How did Rao Birender Singh’s government end?
Through President’s Rule. Governor B.N. Chakravarty reported on 17 November 1967 that about 30 of 79 members had defected, some three or four times. The President issued a Proclamation dated 21 November 1967 and the Assembly was dissolved.
Did Rao Birender Singh leave office on 2 November 1967?
That date appears in some accounts, but the Punjab and Haryana High Court’s judgment gives the Proclamation as dated 21 November 1967, after the Governor’s report of 17 November. Some lists use 20 November.
What did the Governor say about defections in Haryana?
That defection “has become endemic”, that it was “not for any ideological reasons”, and that “the motive is obviously to secure some personal gain”. He concluded that no stable ministry could be formed without a fresh election.
Did anyone challenge President’s Rule in Haryana?
Yes. Rao Birender Singh petitioned the Punjab and Haryana High Court, arguing he still had a majority. A bench of Chief Justice Mehar Singh and Justice Narula dismissed the petition on 1 March 1968.
What happened in the 1968 Haryana election?
Held on 12 May 1968, it gave the Congress 48 of 81 seats again. Rao Birender Singh’s Vishal Haryana Party won 16. Bansi Lal became Chief Minister on 21 May 1968.
How common were defections after 1967?
Very. The Committee on Defections counted about 542 cases between the first and fourth general elections, and at least 438 in the twelve months from March 1967 to February 1968 alone. Of 376 Independents elected, 157 joined parties.
What was the Chavan Committee?
The Committee on Defections, chaired by Home Minister Y.B. Chavan. It was set up after a unanimous Lok Sabha resolution on 8 December 1967 and reported on 7 January 1969. Its report singled out Haryana as a conspicuous example of repeated defections.
Was the Chavan Committee set up in 1973?
No. It followed the Lok Sabha resolution of December 1967 and its report is dated 7 January 1969. An anti-defection bill was introduced in 1973, but it lapsed, like other attempts before 1985.
Why did legislators defect in the 1960s?
The Committee on Defections pointed to the lure of office: of 210 defecting legislators in seven States, 116 became ministers in the governments their defections helped form. Haryana’s Governor attributed the defections there to personal gain.
When was the Anti-Defection Law passed?
Parliament passed the Constitution (Fifty-second Amendment) Bill unanimously on 30 and 31 January 1985. It received presidential assent on 15 February 1985 and inserted the Tenth Schedule.
Which government introduced the Anti-Defection Law?
Rajiv Gandhi’s Congress government, which had won a large majority in December 1984. The President’s Address had promised an anti-defection bill in that session.
What are the grounds for disqualification under the Tenth Schedule?
Voluntarily giving up party membership; voting or abstaining against the party’s direction without permission, unless condoned within 15 days; an Independent joining a party after election; and a nominated member joining a party more than six months after taking the seat.
Does a legislator have to resign from the party to be disqualified?
No. Courts have held that conduct can show a member has voluntarily given up membership, for example public support for a rival party or joining its activities, even without a formal resignation.
Who decides defection cases?
The Speaker of the Lok Sabha or the State Assembly, or the Chairman of the Rajya Sabha or Legislative Council. Since 1992 that decision is subject to judicial review by the High Courts and the Supreme Court.
What did Kihoto Hollohan decide?
In conclusions announced on 12 November 1991 and reasons given on 18 February 1992, a 3-2 majority upheld the Tenth Schedule, held that the Speaker acts as a tribunal open to judicial review, and struck down Paragraph 7, which barred the courts, for want of State ratification.
Why was Paragraph 7 struck down?
It took away the jurisdiction of the Supreme Court and High Courts over disqualification matters. Under Article 368, such a change needs ratification by at least half the State legislatures. That had not been done, so the majority held Paragraph 7 invalid and severed it.
What was the one-third split exception?
Under the original 1985 law, if at least one-third of a legislature party claimed a split in their party, they escaped disqualification. It was widely seen as a route for engineered defections.
When was the split exception removed?
By the Constitution (Ninety-first Amendment) Act, 2003, which deleted Paragraph 3 of the Tenth Schedule. Only the two-thirds merger exception remains.
What else did the 91st Amendment change?
It capped the Council of Ministers at 15% of the House, with a minimum of 12 in the States, and barred a member disqualified for defection from becoming a minister or holding a remunerative political post until re-elected.
What did the Rajendra Singh Rana case decide?
In February 2007 a Constitution Bench held that BSP MLAs in Uttar Pradesh who had claimed a split were disqualified, and that a Speaker’s failure to decide a disqualification petition can itself be reviewed by the courts.
Is there a time limit for a Speaker to decide?
The Constitution sets none. In Keisham Meghachandra Singh (21 January 2020) the Supreme Court said three months should ordinarily be the outer limit, and on 31 July 2025 it ordered the Telangana Speaker to decide petitions against 10 MLAs within three months.
What is “operation successful, patient died”?
A phrase the Supreme Court used in its July 2025 Telangana judgment for a Speaker who delays a disqualification decision until it no longer matters: the petition is eventually decided, but the defector has already served the purpose of the switch.
Should someone other than the Speaker decide defection cases?
The Supreme Court suggested in 2020 that Parliament consider an independent body. The Dinesh Goswami Committee (1990), the Law Commission and the Election Commission have proposed that the President or Governor decide on the Election Commission’s advice.
How did the Shiv Sena and NCP splits test the law?
Both raised the question of which faction is the original party. In 2023 the Supreme Court held a legislature party cannot act cut off from its political party. The Election Commission and the Maharashtra Speaker later recognised the Shinde and Ajit Pawar factions, and no one was disqualified.
Who used the phrase Aaya Ram Gaya Ram in 2024?
Congress president Mallikarjun Kharge, after Nitish Kumar returned to the BJP-led alliance and was sworn in as Bihar Chief Minister for the ninth time on 28 January 2024: “There are many aaya Ram, gaya Rams in the country.”
Does the Anti-Defection Law apply when a whole party changes alliance?
No. The Tenth Schedule deals with individual legislators leaving or defying their party. A party that leaves one coalition and joins another, as the JD(U) did in Bihar, is not defecting under the law, even though the phrase is often used for it.
Why is the Anti-Defection Law controversial?
It trades legislators’ freedom to vote their conscience for government stability, leaves decisions to Speakers who usually come from the ruling side, sets no deadline, and its merger exception is open to contested readings.
Who was Rao Birender Singh?
A former Punjab minister elected from Pataudi in 1967, briefly Speaker and then Chief Minister of Haryana from 24 March 1967. He founded the Vishal Haryana Party, later served in Union cabinets, and died in 2009.

⚠️ Editorial Note: What We Checked

We checked the brief we started from against the Punjab and Haryana High Court’s 1968 judgment in Rao Birinder Singh v. Union of India, the Kihoto Hollohan judgment, the Gazette text of the 52nd Amendment and the 2020 and 2025 Supreme Court judgments. Polling in Haryana was in February 1967, not March. The President’s Proclamation is dated 21 November 1967, not 2 November. The Committee on Defections reported on 7 January 1969; it was not a 1973 committee. 12 November 1991 is when the Kihoto conclusions were announced. Gaya Lal’s exact sequence and timing differ between sources, so we give the versions side by side. Matters still before the Supreme Court are described as pending, not as settled law. This article is a historical account and not legal advice.

Related Reading on AiTimeline

ADM Jabalpur Case: Habeas Corpus, Emergency, and Rights in India Kerala’s EMS Namboodiripad Government Dismissal: A Timeline of the 1957–59 Political Crisis
New article
→
Next Article