← AiTimeline Home

Supreme Court of India · 1975-2017 · Emergency, detention and the writ of liberty

ADM Jabalpur Case: Habeas Corpus, Emergency, and Rights in India

📅 Last updated: 19 November 2026⏱ 20 dated entries✎ By Nazish Fatima

View as Web Story

In short

Explore the ADM Jabalpur case timeline, the 1976 Emergency verdict, Justice H.R. Khanna's dissent and the Supreme Court's 2017 overruling in Puttaswamy.

Latest Story

On 28 April 1976, ten months into the Emergency, the Supreme Court of India was asked a simple question: could a person locked up without trial ask a judge whether the detention was lawful? Four of five judges said no. This ADM Jabalpur case timeline follows the dispute from the June 1975 proclamation and the Presidential Order that shut the courts, through nine High Court rulings for the detainees, the 4-1 judgment and Justice H.R. Khanna’s lone dissent, to the Forty-fourth Amendment and the 2017 Puttaswamy judgment that expressly overruled it. Quotations are taken from the judgments themselves.

Read this first: four common errors

1 September 1975 is not the date the Supreme Court consolidated the appeals. It is the date of the Madhya Pradesh High Court judgment in Shivkant Shukla’s own petition, the one that gave the case its name. The Emergency was revoked on 21 March 1977, three days before Morarji Desai’s government took office, not after it. The High Courts were not unanimous in every petition: Justice Khanna counted nine that rejected an absolute bar, while Chief Justice Ray noted others that upheld it. And the 2007 Coelho judgment did not overrule the case; it said it stood “impliedly overruled”. The express overruling came in 2017.

💡 Short Answer

The ADM Jabalpur case (ADM Jabalpur v. Shivkant Shukla, 1976) is the Emergency-era Supreme Court judgment, decided 4-1 on 28 April 1976, which held that because of the Presidential Order of 27 June 1975 detainees could not seek habeas corpus to challenge their detention, even for illegality or bad faith. Justice H.R. Khanna dissented. Parliament barred suspension of Article 21 through the Forty-fourth Amendment, effective 20 June 1979, and the Supreme Court expressly overruled the judgment on 24 August 2017 in the Puttaswamy privacy case.

⚡ Facts at a Glance
Popular nameThe Habeas Corpus case
Decided28 April 1976, 4-1
CitationAIR 1976 SC 1207; (1976) 2 SCC 521
DissentJustice H.R. Khanna
Order at issue27 June 1975, Articles 14, 21, 22
Overruled24 August 2017, Puttaswamy
⚡ Quick Answers — AI Overview Ready

ADM Jabalpur Case: Key Questions

What did the ADM Jabalpur case decide?
That while the Presidential Order of 27 June 1975 was in force, no detainee had standing to move a High Court for habeas corpus to challenge a detention order, even on the ground that it was illegal, outside the Act or made in bad faith. The majority also upheld Section 16A(9) of MISA.
Why did Justice Khanna dissent?
He held that Article 21 was not the sole repository of the right to life and liberty. That right existed before the Constitution and in ordinary law, so suspending a constitutional remedy did not give the State power to detain people without the authority of law.
When was ADM Jabalpur overruled?
On 24 August 2017. In the nine-judge Puttaswamy privacy judgment, Justice D.Y. Chandrachud wrote for four judges that “ADM Jabalpur must be and is accordingly overruled,” and Justice S.K. Kaul agreed. In 2007 the Coelho bench had called it impliedly overruled.
Can Article 21 be suspended in an Emergency now?
No. The Forty-fourth Amendment changed Article 359 so a Presidential Order can no longer suspend the enforcement of Articles 20 and 21. That change took effect on 20 June 1979.
📚 Key Takeaways

The Case in Ten Points

  • The trigger: the Allahabad High Court voided Indira Gandhi’s election on 12 June 1975.
  • The proclamation: a second Emergency, for “internal disturbance”, on 25 June 1975.
  • The order: on 27 June 1975 the right to move courts under Articles 14, 21 and 22 was suspended.
  • The detentions: thousands were held without trial under MISA.
  • The High Courts: nine, by Justice Khanna’s count, held the order was not an absolute bar.
  • The ruling: 4-1 for the government on 28 April 1976.
  • The dissent: Khanna said Article 21 was not the sole repository of life and liberty.
  • The cost: Khanna was passed over for Chief Justice in January 1977 and resigned.
  • The fix: the Forty-fourth Amendment put Articles 20 and 21 beyond suspension from 20 June 1979.
  • The end: expressly overruled on 24 August 2017 in the Puttaswamy privacy case.
The ADM Jabalpur case in figures: 4-1 majority on 28 April 1976; nine High Courts rejected an absolute bar; three articles, 14, 21 and 22, suspended by the 27 June 1975 order; about 21 months of Emergency; 41 years until the express overruling; nine judges on the 2017 Puttaswamy bench.
By the numbers

The Question Before the Court

A suspended remedy, or a suspended right?

The question before the Court in ADM Jabalpur. The government, through Attorney General Niren De, argued that Article 21 is the sole source of the right to life and liberty and that once its enforcement is suspended no court can look into a detention. The detainees argued that liberty existed before the Constitution and in ordinary law, that only a remedy was suspended, and that courts could still check whether a detention was under the Act, by an authorised officer and in good faith.
Two readings of the same order

Two articles collide. Article 21 says no person shall be deprived of life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law. Article 359 lets the President suspend the right to move a court to enforce named fundamental rights during an Emergency. The 27 June 1975 order named Article 21.

The government’s reading. If Article 21 is the only source of the right to liberty, suspending its enforcement leaves a detainee nothing to rely on. Whether the detention was lawful or not, no court could ask.

The detainees’ reading. The order suspended a remedy, not the law. An officer who detains someone must still act under a statute, and ordinary courts had always been able to ask whether he had. A habeas corpus petition asks exactly that.

Nine High Courts Said the Courts Stayed Open

The rulings the Supreme Court set aside.

High Courts that, according to Justice Khanna, held the Presidential Order was not an absolute bar to habeas corpus: Delhi, Karnataka, Bombay (Nagpur Bench), Allahabad, Madras, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh, and Punjab and Haryana. Appeals decided on 28 April 1976 came from Madhya Pradesh (1 September 1975), Delhi (31 October 1975), Allahabad (12 November 1975) and Karnataka (26 November 1975), among others.
The High Courts, 1975

What they held. The courts broadly accepted that a detainee could still show that an order was passed by an officer without power, was not under the Act at all, or was made in bad faith. They differed on how far a court could go beyond that.

Not a clean sweep. Chief Justice Ray’s opinion records that the Andhra Pradesh, Kerala and Madras High Courts had upheld the government’s preliminary objection in petitions before them. Khanna’s count of nine refers to courts that, in the matters he examined, found no absolute bar.

ADM Jabalpur Case Timeline, 1971 to 2017

Newest first. Each entry is tagged by type.

Political crisisEmergency powersHigh CourtsSupreme CourtAftermath and reform
24 Aug 2017

Nine judges expressly overrule ADM Jabalpur in the privacy case Supreme Court

Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of IndiaWrit Petition (Civil) 494 of 2012(2017) 10 SCC 1

What happened: A nine-judge Constitution Bench unanimously held that privacy is a fundamental right. In the lead opinion, written by Justice D.Y. Chandrachud for himself, Chief Justice J.S. Khehar, Justice R.K. Agrawal and Justice S. Abdul Nazeer, the Court turned to what it called the “discordant notes” in Indian liberty law and dealt with ADM Jabalpur directly.

The words: “The judgments rendered by all the four judges constituting the majority in ADM Jabalpur are seriously flawed,” the opinion said, adding: “ADM Jabalpur must be and is accordingly overruled.” It also overruled Union of India v. Bhanudas Krishna Gawde, which had followed the 1976 decision.

Khanna vindicated: The opinion said “Justice Khanna was clearly right” and that his view “must be accepted, and accepted in reverence for the strength of its thoughts and the courage of its convictions.” Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul, writing separately, agreed with overruling the case and spoke of burying the majority opinion “ten fathom deep, with no chance of resurrection.”

Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, who wrote the overruling opinion, is the son of Justice Y.V. Chandrachud, one of the four judges in the 1976 majority.
11 Jan 2007

I.R. Coelho: the Court says ADM Jabalpur stood “impliedly overruled” Supreme Court

I.R. Coelho v. State of Tamil NaduNine-judge bench(2007) 2 SCC 1

What happened: In a judgment about laws placed in the Ninth Schedule, a nine-judge bench reviewed how fundamental rights had been read over the decades. It said that during the Emergency rights were “read even more restrictively as interpreted by the majority” in ADM Jabalpur, and that the restrictive reading of the right to life and liberty “stood impliedly overruled by various subsequent decisions.”

Why it was not enough: “Impliedly overruled” is not the same as an express overruling by a bench larger than the one that decided the case. ADM Jabalpur was a five-judge ruling, and it stayed formally on the books for another ten years.

Why it matters: The 2017 privacy bench quoted this passage and then went further, overruling the 1976 judgment in terms.

Justice Kaul’s 2017 opinion pointed out that Coelho had treated the Forty-fourth Amendment as the “supervening event” that took away ADM Jabalpur’s force.
25 Feb 2008

Justice H.R. Khanna dies at 95 Aftermath and reform

Born 3 July 1912, AmritsarSupreme Court judge, 1971-1977

What happened: Hans Raj Khanna died in Delhi aged 95. Besides his ADM Jabalpur dissent, he was one of the judges in the 1973 Kesavananda Bharati case, whose opinion is usually counted as decisive in establishing the basic structure doctrine.

Later life: After resigning from the Supreme Court in 1977 he chaired the Law Commission, was briefly Union Law Minister in Charan Singh’s government in 1979, and was the joint opposition candidate for President in 1982, losing to Zail Singh.

Why it matters: He did not live to see the 2017 judgment that adopted his dissent as the law.

His autobiography is titled Neither Roses Nor Thorns.
20 Jun 1979

Articles 20 and 21 can no longer be suspended in an Emergency Aftermath and reform

Constitution (Forty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1978, Section 40Brought into force by notification G.S.R. 383(E) of 19 June 1979

What happened: The change to Article 359 took effect. Clauses (1) and (1A) now let the President suspend the enforcement of fundamental rights during an Emergency “except articles 20 and 21.”

What it means: Article 21 protects life and personal liberty. Article 20 protects against retrospective criminal laws, double punishment and self-incrimination. Neither can now be put beyond the reach of the courts by a Presidential Order, which is the exact route the government used in 1975.

Why it matters: This is the most direct answer Parliament gave to ADM Jabalpur. A future detainee can always ask a court to examine whether the detention is lawful.

The same amendment replaced “internal disturbance” with “armed rebellion” in Article 352, the ground used for the June 1975 proclamation.
30 Apr 1979

The Forty-fourth Amendment receives presidential assent Aftermath and reform

President N. Sanjiva ReddyRatified by more than half the State legislatures

What happened: The Constitution (Forty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1978, became law after ratification by the States. Its sections were brought into force on different dates in 1979.

What it changed: Besides the Article 359 safeguard, it required a written decision of the Union Cabinet before an Emergency could be advised, approval by each House of Parliament within one month by a special majority, and fresh approval every six months.

Why it matters: The safeguards were designed so that the 1975 sequence, a midnight proclamation followed by an order shutting the courts, could not be repeated in the same way.

The Janata Party government’s Law Minister who piloted the bill was Shanti Bhushan, who had argued for the detainees in ADM Jabalpur.
7 Dec 1978

Parliament completes passage of the Forty-fourth Amendment Aftermath and reform

Introduced in the Lok Sabha on 16 December 1977Rajya Sabha passed it with changes on 31 August 1978

What happened: The Lok Sabha accepted the Rajya Sabha’s amendments, completing the bill’s passage through Parliament. Some clauses the government wanted had failed to win the required majority in the Rajya Sabha, where the Congress was still strong.

Why it matters: The Article 359 change survived both Houses. That is why it is the Forty-fourth, not the Forty-fifth, Amendment: the bill had been renumbered while it was in Parliament.

The bill was originally introduced as the Constitution (Forty-fifth Amendment) Bill.
25 Jan 1978

Maneka Gandhi: the Court widens Article 21 Supreme Court

Maneka Gandhi v. Union of IndiaSeven-judge bench

What happened: In a challenge to the impounding of a passport, the Supreme Court held that a law depriving a person of liberty must lay down a procedure that is fair, just and reasonable, not merely any procedure enacted by the legislature.

Why it matters: This was the start of the line of decisions that, in the words of the 2007 Coelho bench, impliedly overruled ADM Jabalpur’s narrow reading of life and liberty.

Justices Y.V. Chandrachud and P.N. Bhagwati, both in the 1976 majority, sat on the Maneka Gandhi bench.
21 Mar 1977

The Emergency is revoked Political crisis

Acting President B.D. JattiCongress defeated in the March 1977 election

What happened: The internal Emergency proclaimed on 25 June 1975 was revoked as the general election results came in. The Congress lost power at the Centre.

What followed: Morarji Desai was sworn in as Prime Minister on 24 March 1977, three days after the revocation, at the head of the Janata Party government.

Why it matters: With the proclamation gone, the 27 June 1975 Presidential Order lapsed, and detainees could again go to court.

The Emergency had lasted about 21 months.

Khanna is superseded; M.H. Beg becomes Chief Justice Aftermath and reform

Chief Justice A.N. Ray retiresSeniority convention broken

What happened: When Chief Justice A.N. Ray retired, the government passed over Justice Khanna, the senior-most judge, and appointed Justice M.H. Beg Chief Justice of India from 29 January 1977. Khanna resigned.

Why it matters: It was the second supersession in four years: Ray himself had been appointed over three senior judges in 1973. It was widely read as a punishment for the dissent and became a central argument in later debates about how judges are appointed.

Reaction: Bar associations across the country protested.

Beg had written in his ADM Jabalpur opinion that the State’s care for detainees was “almost maternal.”
28 Apr 1976

The Supreme Court rules 4-1 against the detainees Supreme Court

ADM Jabalpur v. Shivkant ShuklaAIR 1976 SC 1207; (1976) 2 SCC 521; 1976 SCR 172Ray CJ, Beg, Chandrachud, Bhagwati; Khanna dissenting

The order: “By majority: In view of the Presidential order dated 27 June 1975 no person has any locus standi to move any writ petition under Article 226 before a High Court for habeas corpus or any other writ or order or direction to challenge the legality of an order of detention on the ground that the order is not under or in compliance with the Act or is illegal or is vitiated by mala fides factual or legal or is based on extraneous consideration.”

The other holdings: The majority also held that Section 16A(9) of MISA, which let the government keep the grounds of detention from the courts, was constitutionally valid. The High Court judgments were set aside.

The dissent: Justice Khanna held that Article 21 was not the sole repository of the right to life and liberty, and that the courts could still examine whether a detention had the authority of law.

Khanna closed his dissent by quoting Chief Justice Hughes: a dissent is “an appeal to the brooding spirit of the law, to the intelligence of a future day.”
1975-76

The appeals are heard by a five-judge bench Supreme Court

Attorney General Niren De for the governmentShanti Bhushan, V.M. Tarkunde, Soli Sorabjee, Ram Jethmalani, C.K. Daphtary and others for the detainees

What happened: The State and Union governments appealed against the High Court rulings. The appeals were heard together by Chief Justice A.N. Ray and Justices H.R. Khanna, M.H. Beg, Y.V. Chandrachud and P.N. Bhagwati.

The government’s case: Article 21 was the sole source of the right to life and liberty. Once its enforcement was suspended, no court could look into a detention, whatever the ground.

The detainees’ case: The right to liberty existed before the Constitution and in ordinary law; the Presidential Order suspended a remedy, not the rule of law. A court could still ask whether a detention was made under the Act at all, or in bad faith.

The Advocate-General of Gujarat, then under a non-Congress government, generally supported the detainees’ side, according to Khanna’s opinion.

Delhi, Allahabad and Karnataka High Courts reject the bar High Courts

Delhi HC, 31 October 1975Allahabad HC, 12 November 1975Karnataka HC, 26 November 1975

What happened: Three more High Courts held that habeas corpus petitions could be heard despite the Presidential Order. Their judgments are among those the Supreme Court set aside in April 1976.

The common thread: The courts broadly accepted that a detainee could show the order was passed by an officer with no power to pass it, was not under the Act, or was made in bad faith.

Why it matters: Justice Khanna counted nine High Courts that had reached the same conclusion: Delhi, Karnataka, Bombay (Nagpur Bench), Allahabad, Madras, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh, and Punjab and Haryana.

Chief Justice Ray’s opinion records that the Andhra Pradesh, Kerala and Madras High Courts had upheld the government’s preliminary objection in petitions before them, so the picture was not uniform.
1 Sep 1975

The Madhya Pradesh High Court rules in Shivkant Shukla’s petition High Courts

Miscellaneous Petition 597 of 1975Appeal: Criminal Appeal 279 of 1975

What happened: The Madhya Pradesh High Court ruled against the State’s objection that habeas corpus petitions by detainees could not be heard while the Presidential Order was in force. The Additional District Magistrate of Jabalpur, who had signed the detention order, appealed.

Why the name: Because this appeal was listed first, the whole batch came to be known as ADM Jabalpur v. Shivkant Shukla.

Correction: Some accounts give 1 September 1975 as the date the Supreme Court consolidated the appeals. It is in fact the date of the Madhya Pradesh High Court judgment.

Shanti Bhushan appeared for the respondent in this lead appeal in the Supreme Court.

Detainees file habeas corpus petitions High Courts

Article 226Detentions under MISA, Section 3

What happened: Detainees and their families went to High Courts asking for writs of habeas corpus. Many challenged the detention orders as made without authority, without application of mind or in bad faith; some also challenged the Presidential Order itself.

The government’s reply: It raised a preliminary objection: the petitions were, in substance, claims under Article 21, and the right to move a court for that had been suspended.

Habeas corpus, Latin for “you shall have the body,” is the writ that orders a jailer to produce a detainee and justify the detention.
27 Jun 1975

The Presidential Order suspends Articles 14, 21 and 22 Emergency powers

Article 359(1)Extended to Jammu and Kashmir on 29 June 1975

What happened: The President declared that the right of any person, including a foreigner, to move any court to enforce Articles 14, 21 and 22, and all pending proceedings to that end, would stay suspended while both the 1971 and the 1975 proclamations were in force.

What was different: Earlier orders, in 1962 and 1974, had applied only to people detained under particular laws. This one had no such condition, which the Attorney General stressed before the Supreme Court.

Why it matters: This is the order the majority later held barred every habeas corpus petition. Article 19 was already suspended automatically under Article 358.

On 25 September 1975 the last paragraph of the order was deleted, a change also examined in the judgment.
26 Jun 1975

The Emergency is announced; arrests begin Political crisis

Radio broadcast by Indira GandhiPress censorship

What happened: Prime Minister Indira Gandhi announced the Emergency on All India Radio. Opposition leaders, including Jayaprakash Narayan, Morarji Desai, Atal Bihari Vajpayee and L.K. Advani, had been arrested overnight. Press censorship followed.

Why it matters: Most detainees were held under MISA, which allowed preventive detention without trial and which was amended during the Emergency to make detentions harder to challenge.

The Shah Commission later examined the detentions of the Emergency in detail.
25 Jun 1975

A second Emergency is proclaimed, for “internal disturbance” Emergency powers

President Fakhruddin Ali AhmedArticle 352

What happened: Late at night the President, on the Prime Minister’s advice, proclaimed that a grave emergency existed because India’s security was threatened by internal disturbance.

Two Emergencies at once: The external Emergency proclaimed on 3 December 1971, during the war with Pakistan, was still in force. The Presidential Order of 27 June referred to both.

Why it matters: The Forty-fourth Amendment later removed “internal disturbance” as a ground.

The Union Cabinet approved the proclamation only the next morning, after it had been issued.
24 Jun 1975

A conditional stay of the Allahabad judgment Supreme Court

Justice V.R. Krishna Iyer, vacation judgeSupreme Court

What happened: Hearing Indira Gandhi’s appeal, Justice Krishna Iyer granted a conditional stay: she could remain Prime Minister and attend Parliament but could not vote or draw a salary as a member until the appeal was decided.

Why it matters: The Emergency was proclaimed the following night.

Her appeal was later decided in November 1975, after Parliament had changed the election law.
12 Jun 1975

The Allahabad High Court sets aside Indira Gandhi’s election Political crisis

Justice Jagmohanlal SinhaRaj Narain v. Indira Nehru Gandhi

What happened: The High Court found Indira Gandhi guilty of corrupt practices in her 1971 election from Rae Bareli and declared the election void.

Why it matters: The judgment, and the protests that followed, are the immediate background to the proclamation of 25 June.

The petition had been filed by Raj Narain, her defeated opponent in Rae Bareli.

MISA is enacted and an external Emergency proclaimed Emergency powers

MISA published 2 July 1971Emergency proclaimed 3 December 1971

What happened: Parliament enacted the Maintenance of Internal Security Act, 1971, allowing preventive detention. In December, during the war with Pakistan, an Emergency was proclaimed on the ground of external aggression.

Earlier suspensions: On 16 November 1974 a Presidential Order suspended the right to move courts under Articles 14, 21 and 22, but only for people detained under Section 3(1)(c) of MISA.

Why it matters: MISA was the law under which most Emergency detainees were held, and the 1971 Emergency was still in force when the 1975 one was proclaimed.

MISA was later amended during the Emergency itself, including by Act 14 of 1976, to add Section 16A(9).

From Proclamation to Judgment

Ten months, step by step.

How the ADM Jabalpur case reached the Supreme Court: 12 June 1975 Allahabad High Court voids Indira Gandhi’s election; 25 June 1975 Emergency proclaimed for internal disturbance; 27 June 1975 Presidential Order suspends Articles 14, 21 and 22; June-July 1975 detainees file habeas corpus petitions; 1 September 1975 Madhya Pradesh High Court rules in Shivkant Shukla’s petition; October-November 1975 Delhi, Allahabad and Karnataka High Courts rule; 28 April 1976 Supreme Court rules 4-1.
From proclamation to judgment

The Bench and the Majority

Five judges, five separate opinions.

The five judges in ADM Jabalpur: Chief Justice A.N. Ray, majority, retired January 1977; Justice M.H. Beg, majority, Chief Justice from 29 January 1977; Justice Y.V. Chandrachud, majority, Chief Justice 1978-1985; Justice P.N. Bhagwati, majority, Chief Justice 1985-1986; Justice H.R. Khanna, dissent, superseded and resigned in 1977.
Four for the government, one against

What the majority held. Article 21 was treated as the sole repository of the right to life and personal liberty. With its enforcement suspended, there was no separate “rule of law” right a detainee could fall back on. The order also upheld Section 16A(9) of MISA, which allowed the government to withhold the grounds of detention from the courts.

In their own words. Justice Beg wrote that the State’s care for detainees, who he said were “well housed, well fed, and well treated,” was “almost maternal.” Justice Chandrachud, answering counsel’s fears that detainees might be mistreated or shot, said he had “a diamond-bright, diamond-hard hope that such things will never come to pass.”

The later careers. Three of the four majority judges, Beg, Chandrachud and Bhagwati, went on to become Chief Justice of India. Bhagwati was widely reported in 2011 to have said the majority view was wrong.

JudgePositionAfterwards
A.N. Ray (CJI)MajorityRetired January 1977
M.H. BegMajorityChief Justice from 29 January 1977
Y.V. ChandrachudMajorityChief Justice 1978 to 1985
P.N. BhagwatiMajorityChief Justice 1985 to 1986
H.R. KhannaDissentSuperseded; resigned 1977

Justice Khanna’s Dissent

“Not the gift of the Constitution.”

Rights before the Constitution. “Sanctity of life and liberty was not something new when the Constitution was drafted,” Khanna wrote. The principle that no one shall be deprived of life and liberty without the authority of law “was not the gift of the Constitution. It was a necessary corollary of the concept relating to the sanctity of life and liberty; it existed and was in force before the coming into force of the Constitution.”

A remedy is not a right. He could not accept that, once enforcement of Article 21 was suspended, “there would be no remedy against deprivation of a person’s life or liberty by the State even though such deprivation is without the authority of law or even in flagrant violation of the provisions of law.”

Courts still had a job. On his view, a court could at least ask whether a detention order had been made under the Act by an authorised officer. That was the minimum the High Courts had insisted on.

An appeal to the future. He ended with Chief Justice Hughes’ line that a dissent is “an appeal to the brooding spirit of the law, to the intelligence of a future day.” Forty-one years later, the Supreme Court said his view “must be accepted, and accepted in reverence for the strength of its thoughts and the courage of its convictions.”

ADM Jabalpur in 1976 and the law now. Habeas corpus in an Emergency: barred under the 27 June 1975 order then; always available now, since Article 21 cannot be suspended. Source of life and liberty: Article 21 alone then; inherent, existing before the Constitution, now. Article 359: could suspend Article 21 then; excludes Articles 20 and 21 since 20 June 1979. Section 16A(9) secrecy: upheld then. Status: majority ruling in 1976; expressly overruled 24 August 2017.
1976 versus now

The Aftermath: Supersession, Revocation, Amendment

What happened to the judges, the Emergency and the Constitution.

After ADM Jabalpur: January 1977 Justice Khanna superseded, M.H. Beg Chief Justice from 29 January; 21 March 1977 Emergency revoked; 25 January 1978 Maneka Gandhi widens Article 21; 30 April 1979 Forty-fourth Amendment receives assent; 20 June 1979 Articles 20 and 21 put beyond suspension; 11 January 2007 I.R. Coelho calls ADM Jabalpur impliedly overruled; 24 August 2017 Puttaswamy expressly overrules it.
Forty-one years to undo

The price of the dissent. When Chief Justice Ray retired in January 1977, the government appointed Justice Beg over Justice Khanna. Khanna resigned. The episode became one of the arguments, years later, for taking appointments out of the executive’s hands.

Parliament’s answer. The Janata government’s Forty-fourth Amendment did not try to reverse the judgment by declaring it wrong. It changed the text the judgment relied on: from 20 June 1979, Article 359 no longer allows a Presidential Order to suspend the enforcement of Articles 20 and 21. It also made a future Emergency harder to proclaim and keep.

The courts’ answer. From Maneka Gandhi in 1978 onwards, the Supreme Court read Article 21 broadly, as a guarantee of fair, just and reasonable procedure. By 2007 it described ADM Jabalpur’s reading as impliedly overruled.

2017: “Must Be and Is Accordingly Overruled”

Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India, 24 August 2017.

Why a privacy case. To hold that privacy is part of life and liberty, the nine-judge bench had to deal with a judgment that said those rights existed only as the Constitution granted them and could be wholly suspended.

What it said. “Life and personal liberty are inalienable to human existence,” the lead opinion said. “Neither life nor liberty are bounties conferred by the state nor does the Constitution create these rights.” It called the four majority opinions “seriously flawed” and held: “ADM Jabalpur must be and is accordingly overruled.”

The family footnote. The opinion was written by Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, whose father, Justice Y.V. Chandrachud, had been in the 1976 majority. Justice Kaul, concurring, spoke of burying the majority opinion “ten fathom deep, with no chance of resurrection.”

Who Was Who

Dissenting judge

H.R. Khanna

Senior-most judge in 1977; superseded and resigned. Later Law Commission chairman and 1982 presidential candidate. Died 2008.

Chief Justice, 1973-77

A.N. Ray

Presided over the bench and wrote the leading majority opinion.

Majority judge

M.H. Beg

Wrote the “almost maternal” passage. Appointed Chief Justice over Khanna in January 1977.

Majority judges

Y.V. Chandrachud and P.N. Bhagwati

Both later Chief Justice. Both sat on the 1978 Maneka Gandhi bench that widened Article 21.

Attorney General

Niren De

Argued that Article 21 was the sole repository of the right to life and liberty.

Counsel for detainees

Shanti Bhushan

Appeared in the lead appeal; as Law Minister, introduced the Forty-fourth Amendment bill in December 1977.

2017 lead opinion

D.Y. Chandrachud

Wrote that ADM Jabalpur “must be and is accordingly overruled”. Later Chief Justice, 2022-24.

2017 concurrence

Sanjay Kishan Kaul

Called the case “an aberration in the constitutional jurisprudence of our country”.

Did You Know?

  • A New York Times tribute: days after the judgment, a New York Times editorial said that if India found its way back to freedom, someone would surely erect a monument to Justice Khanna.
  • Two Emergencies at once: the 1971 external Emergency was still in force in June 1975; the Presidential Order referred to both.
  • The name: the Additional District Magistrate of Jabalpur was simply the officer who signed Shivkant Shukla’s detention order.
  • Counsel turned minister: Shanti Bhushan argued for the detainees and then, as Law Minister, introduced the amendment that undid the case’s effect.
  • A judicial family: Khanna’s nephew, Sanjiv Khanna, was Chief Justice of India from November 2024 to May 2025.
  • Kesavananda link: Khanna’s opinion in the 1973 Kesavananda Bharati case is usually counted as decisive for the basic structure doctrine.

Explore More Timelines

People Also Ask

What is the ADM Jabalpur case?
ADM Jabalpur v. Shivkant Shukla is a 1976 Supreme Court judgment, often called the Habeas Corpus case. During the Emergency a five-judge bench held by 4 to 1 that, because of the Presidential Order of 27 June 1975, detainees could not go to a High Court to challenge their detention, even on grounds of illegality or bad faith.
Why is ADM Jabalpur called the Habeas Corpus case?
Because the question was whether detainees could seek writs of habeas corpus, which order the authorities to produce a detained person and justify the detention, while the right to enforce Article 21 was suspended. The majority said they could not.
Who dissented in ADM Jabalpur?
Justice H.R. Khanna was the only dissenting judge. He held that Article 21 was not the sole repository of the right to life and personal liberty, and that courts could still examine whether a detention had the authority of law.
Is ADM Jabalpur still good law?
No. In 2007 the I.R. Coelho bench said its restrictive reading stood impliedly overruled, and on 24 August 2017 the nine-judge bench in the Puttaswamy privacy case expressly overruled it. The Forty-fourth Amendment also stops Articles 20 and 21 from being suspended in any future Emergency.
Which case overruled ADM Jabalpur?
Justice K.S. Puttaswamy (Retd.) v. Union of India, decided on 24 August 2017. Justice D.Y. Chandrachud’s opinion, for four of the nine judges, said: “ADM Jabalpur must be and is accordingly overruled.” Justice Sanjay Kishan Kaul agreed with overruling it.
What happened to Justice Khanna after his dissent?
In January 1977 the government passed over him for Chief Justice of India, although he was the senior-most judge, and appointed Justice M.H. Beg. Khanna resigned. He later chaired the Law Commission and ran for President in 1982.

Frequently Asked Questions

Based on the 1976, 2007 and 2017 judgments and the Forty-fourth Amendment.

When was the ADM Jabalpur judgment delivered?
On 28 April 1976, about ten months into the Emergency. The citations are AIR 1976 SC 1207, (1976) 2 SCC 521 and 1976 SCR 172.
Who were the five judges in ADM Jabalpur?
Chief Justice A.N. Ray and Justices H.R. Khanna, M.H. Beg, Y.V. Chandrachud and P.N. Bhagwati. Ray, Beg, Chandrachud and Bhagwati formed the majority; Khanna dissented. Each judge wrote a separate opinion.
What exactly did the majority order say?
That in view of the Presidential Order of 27 June 1975 no person had locus standi to move a writ petition under Article 226 for habeas corpus or any other writ to challenge a detention order on the ground that it was not under the Act, was illegal, was made in bad faith or rested on extraneous considerations.
Who was Shivkant Shukla?
He was the respondent in the lead appeal: a person detained under MISA whose habeas corpus petition succeeded in the Madhya Pradesh High Court on 1 September 1975. The Additional District Magistrate of Jabalpur, who issued the detention order, appealed, and the case took its name from that appeal.
What was the Presidential Order of 27 June 1975?
An order under Article 359(1) declaring that the right of any person, including a foreigner, to move any court to enforce Articles 14, 21 and 22, and all pending proceedings for that, would remain suspended while the 1971 and 1975 Emergency proclamations were both in force.
What is Article 359?
It lets the President, during an Emergency, suspend the right to move courts to enforce specified fundamental rights. Since the Forty-fourth Amendment took effect on 20 June 1979, Articles 20 and 21 cannot be included in such an order.
What is Article 21?
Article 21 says no person shall be deprived of life or personal liberty except according to procedure established by law. Since Maneka Gandhi in 1978, that procedure must be fair, just and reasonable.
What was MISA?
The Maintenance of Internal Security Act, 1971, a preventive detention law. Most Emergency detainees were held under it. It was amended during the Emergency, including Section 16A(9), which let the government keep the grounds of detention from the courts.
What did the majority say about Section 16A(9) of MISA?
It held the provision constitutionally valid, treating it as a rule of evidence. In practice this meant a court could not even see the material on which a person was detained.
What was the government’s main argument?
Attorney General Niren De argued that Article 21 was the sole repository of the right to life and personal liberty. Once its enforcement was suspended, there was no other right a detainee could rely on, so no court could inquire into a detention.
What did the detainees argue?
That the right to liberty existed before the Constitution and in ordinary law, that the order suspended only a remedy, and that a court could still check whether a detention was made under the Act, by an authorised officer, and in good faith.
Who argued for the detainees?
Khanna’s opinion lists Shanti Bhushan, V.M. Tarkunde, Ram Jethmalani, Soli Sorabjee, A.B. Dewan, C.K. Daphtary, N.M. Ghatate, Daniel Latifi and others. Shanti Bhushan later became Law Minister in the Janata government.
How many High Courts ruled for the detainees?
Justice Khanna counted nine that held the Presidential Order was not an absolute bar: Delhi, Karnataka, Bombay (Nagpur Bench), Allahabad, Madras, Rajasthan, Madhya Pradesh, Andhra Pradesh, and Punjab and Haryana. Chief Justice Ray’s opinion notes some courts had upheld the bar in particular petitions.
What did Justice Khanna say in his dissent?
That sanctity of life and liberty “was not something new when the Constitution was drafted,” that the principle that no one shall be deprived of life and liberty without the authority of law “was not the gift of the Constitution,” and that Article 21 could not be the sole repository of that right.
What is the “brooding spirit of the law” quote?
Khanna ended his dissent quoting US Chief Justice Charles Evans Hughes: a dissent in a court of last resort is “an appeal to the brooding spirit of the law, to the intelligence of a future day” when a later decision may correct the error. The 2017 judgment did exactly that.
What did Justice Beg say about detainees?
In his majority opinion he wrote that the care and concern bestowed by State authorities on detainees, who he said were well housed, well fed and well treated, was “almost maternal.” The line is often quoted as an example of how far the majority deferred to the government.
What did Justice Chandrachud (senior) write?
Justice Y.V. Chandrachud acknowledged counsel’s fears that the executive might mistreat or even shoot detainees, and said he had a “diamond-bright, diamond-hard hope that such things will never come to pass.”
Did any majority judge later regret the judgment?
Justice P.N. Bhagwati was widely reported to have said in 2011 that the majority view was wrong and that he regretted joining it. No other majority judge publicly withdrew his view.
Why was Justice Khanna superseded?
The government never gave an official reason. Appointing Justice M.H. Beg over him in January 1977, about nine months after the dissent, broke the seniority convention and was widely seen as retaliation. Khanna resigned.
When did the Emergency end?
The internal Emergency was revoked on 21 March 1977, as the Congress lost the general election. Morarji Desai was sworn in as Prime Minister three days later, on 24 March 1977.
What did the Forty-fourth Amendment change?
It barred suspension of Articles 20 and 21 under Article 359, replaced “internal disturbance” with “armed rebellion” as a ground for Emergency, required written Cabinet advice, and required approval by each House within one month by a special majority and renewal every six months.
When did the Forty-fourth Amendment come into force?
It received assent on 30 April 1979. Its sections commenced on different dates; the Article 359 change took effect on 20 June 1979 under notification G.S.R. 383(E) of 19 June 1979.
What did I.R. Coelho say about ADM Jabalpur?
On 11 January 2007 the nine-judge bench said that the decision’s restrictive reading of the right to life and liberty “stood impliedly overruled by various subsequent decisions.” It did not expressly overrule the case.
Why did the Puttaswamy bench overrule ADM Jabalpur?
Because a privacy right could not be recognised as part of life and liberty while a judgment saying those rights depended entirely on the Constitution, and could be wholly suspended, remained law. The Court held life and liberty were inalienable and existed before the Constitution.
Who wrote the opinion overruling ADM Jabalpur?
Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, for himself, Chief Justice J.S. Khehar, Justice R.K. Agrawal and Justice S. Abdul Nazeer. He is the son of Justice Y.V. Chandrachud, who was part of the 1976 majority.
What did Justice Kaul say about ADM Jabalpur?
He agreed with “expressly overruling the ADM Jabalpur case which was an aberration in the constitutional jurisprudence of our country” and with “burying the majority opinion ten fathom deep, with no chance of resurrection.”
Could ADM Jabalpur happen again?
Not in the same form. Articles 20 and 21 can no longer be suspended under Article 359, and the 2017 judgment holds that life and liberty do not depend on the Constitution’s grant. Preventive detention laws still exist, but detentions remain open to habeas corpus.
What other case did the Puttaswamy bench overrule with ADM Jabalpur?
Union of India v. Bhanudas Krishna Gawde, a 1977 decision that had followed ADM Jabalpur on detentions during the Emergency.
How is ADM Jabalpur connected to the Kesavananda Bharati case?
Justice Khanna’s opinion in Kesavananda Bharati (1973) is usually counted as decisive in establishing the basic structure doctrine. In ADM Jabalpur the detainees’ counsel relied on Kesavananda, and the 2017 Court cited it to call life and liberty primordial rights.
Why does ADM Jabalpur still matter?
It is the clearest example in Indian law of a court accepting that liberty can be switched off by executive order. Judges and lawyers cite it, and Khanna’s dissent, whenever detention, Emergency powers or judicial independence are debated.

⚠️ Editorial Note: What We Checked

We checked the brief we started from against the text of the 1976 judgment, the 2007 I.R. Coelho judgment and the 2017 Puttaswamy judgment on Indian Kanoon, and the Forty-fourth Amendment Act. 1 September 1975 is the Madhya Pradesh High Court’s judgment date, not a Supreme Court consolidation date. The Emergency was revoked on 21 March 1977, before the Janata government took office on 24 March. The Article 359 change took effect on 20 June 1979, after assent on 30 April 1979. Hearing dates in the Supreme Court are not given in the judgment, so we describe the hearing only as taking place in 1975-76. Bhagwati’s 2011 remarks are reported, not recorded in any judgment. This article is a historical account and not legal advice.

Related Reading on AiTimeline

Fodder Scam: A Timeline of India’s Notorious Corruption Case Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram: Haryana Defections Explained
New article
→
Next Article