← AiTimeline Home

India · 1947 to 1993 · Princely States, the Constitution and the Supreme Court

Privy Purses in India: History, Abolition and Legacy

📅 Last updated: 20 November 2026⏱ 28 dated entries✎ By Nazish Fatima

View as Web Story

In short

The history of privy purses in India, from princely-state integration and Article 291 to Indira Gandhi's 1971 abolition and the Supreme Court rulings.

Latest Story

When the princely states joined India in 1947-49, their rulers gave up their thrones, armies and treasuries. In return they were promised a fixed, tax-free annual allowance for life and for their heirs. These privy purses in India were then written into the Constitution of 1950. Twenty years later, Indira Gandhi’s government set out to end them. Its first attempt failed twice in 1970, once by a fraction of a vote in the Rajya Sabha and once in the Supreme Court. Its second, the Twenty-sixth Amendment of 1971, succeeded and was upheld by the Supreme Court in 1993. This timeline follows the whole arc, from the 3 June 1947 plan to the 2023 Article 370 judgment that restated the rules. Every date and figure is checked against the judgments themselves.

Read this first: what is often got wrong

The total was about Rs 5.8 crore a year, not Rs 58 crore. The 1993 Supreme Court judgment gives Rs 5.8 crore; a single line in the 1970 judgment prints ‘58 crores’, which is widely repeated. The Nizam of Hyderabad was given Rs 50 lakh a year under his 1950 agreement, not Rs 20 lakh. The White Paper on Indian States came out on 5 July 1948, with a revised edition in 1950. And the Mysore royal family’s challenge was filed in 1992, not 1972; the 1972 petitions came from Kurundwad Junior and Malerkotla.

💡 Short Answer

Privy purses were annual, tax-free payments to the former rulers of India’s princely states, agreed when they merged their states into India in 1947-49 and guaranteed by Article 291 of the Constitution from 1950. They totalled about Rs 5.8 crore a year. Indira Gandhi’s government tried to abolish them in 1970, but the amendment failed in the Rajya Sabha and the Supreme Court struck down the President’s derecognition order on 15 December 1970. The Constitution (Twenty-sixth Amendment) Act abolished them on 28 December 1971, and the Supreme Court upheld it on 4 February 1993.

⚡ Facts at a Glance
OriginMerger agreements, 1948-50
GuaranteeArticle 291, from 26 Jan 1950
Total costAbout Rs 5.8 crore a year
Failed attemptSep 1970: 149-75 in Rajya Sabha
Abolished26th Amendment, 28 Dec 1971
UpheldRaghunathrao Ganpatrao, 4 Feb 1993
⚡ Quick Answers — AI Overview Ready

Privy Purses in India: Key Questions

What was a privy purse?
A fixed, tax-free annual sum paid by the Government of India to a former ruler of a princely state, agreed in the merger settlement of 1947-49 and charged on the Consolidated Fund of India under Article 291.
Who abolished privy purses?
Indira Gandhi’s government, through the Constitution (Twenty-sixth Amendment) Act, 1971. Parliament passed it in December 1971 and it came into force on 28 December 1971.
Why did the 1970 attempt fail?
The amendment got 149 votes to 75 in the Rajya Sabha, one short of two-thirds. The President then derecognised the rulers by order, but the Supreme Court struck that down 9 to 2 on 15 December 1970.
Was abolition upheld?
Yes. In Raghunathrao Ganpatrao v. Union of India, 4 February 1993, a Constitution Bench held the amendment valid in its entirety and ruled privy purses were not part of the basic structure.
📚 Key Takeaways

Privy Purses in Ten Lines

  • The bargain: rulers of more than 550 states surrendered their powers in 1947-49 for a purse, privileges and guaranteed succession.
  • The amounts: fixed state by state under a Rs 10 lakh ceiling; about Rs 5.8 crore a year in all.
  • The extremes: Rs 50 lakh for the Nizam, Rs 26 lakh for Mysore, Rs 192 for the Ruler of Kotodia.
  • The guarantee: Articles 291, 362 and 366(22) of the 1950 Constitution.
  • The turn: a Congress resolution of 25 June 1967 called for abolition.
  • The near miss: on 5 September 1970 the Rajya Sabha vote was 149 to 75, a fraction of a vote short.
  • The shortcut: that night the President derecognised every ruler by executive order.
  • The rebuff: on 15 December 1970 the Supreme Court struck the order down, 9 to 2.
  • The amendment: after the March 1971 landslide, the Twenty-sixth Amendment took effect on 28 December 1971.
  • The last word: the Supreme Court upheld it in 1993 and restated both rulings in 2023.
Privy purses in India by the numbers: more than 550 princely states; a general ceiling of Rs 10 lakh a year, with eleven rulers paid more; a total of about Rs 5.8 crore a year; the Nizam of Hyderabad at Rs 50 lakh a year; the 1970 Rajya Sabha vote of 149 to 75, one vote short of two-thirds; and a 9 to 2 Supreme Court ruling on 15 December 1970.
Privy purses by the numbers

What Were Privy Purses?

Not a pension, and not a salary: the price of a merger, written into the Constitution.

A privy purse was an annual payment by the Government of India to a recognised former ruler of a princely state, or his recognised successor. The term was borrowed from Britain, where the privy purse is the sovereign’s private income. In India it meant the sum a ruler kept for himself and his household once he had handed over his state’s government, revenues and property to the Union.

The amounts were negotiated in the covenants and merger agreements of 1948-50. According to the Supreme Court, they were fixed with regard to each ruler’s income before integration, under a general ceiling of Rs 10 lakh a year; eleven rulers were allowed more. Many agreements named a higher sum for the ruler who signed and a lower one for his successors, so the total was designed to shrink with each generation. The purse came with guaranteed succession according to custom and a list of personal privileges, from the use of titles to exemptions from certain laws.

The 1950 Constitution turned these political promises into constitutional guarantees. Article 291 charged the purses on the Consolidated Fund of India and exempted them from income tax. Article 362 asked Parliament, legislatures and governments to have due regard to the rulers’ personal rights and privileges. Article 363 kept disputes arising from the covenants out of the courts, and Article 366(22) defined a ‘Ruler’ as the person recognised by the President.

The four Articles behind privy purses. Article 291: privy purses charged on the Consolidated Fund of India and exempt from income tax; omitted in 1971. Article 362: due regard to rulers’ personal rights, privileges and dignities; omitted in 1971. Article 363: bar on courts hearing disputes arising from the covenants; retained. Article 366(22): a Ruler is the person recognised by the President; substituted in 1971. Article 363A, inserted in 1971: recognition ends and privy purses are abolished.
The Articles that guaranteed, and then ended, privy purses

The Four Stages, at a Glance

Promise, guarantee, failed shortcut, constitutional abolition.

The privy purse story in four stages. Stage 1, 1947-49: integration and promises, as rulers sign accessions and merger agreements. Stage 2, 26 January 1950: constitutional guarantee under Articles 291, 362 and 366(22). Stage 3, September to December 1970: the amendment fails in the Rajya Sabha, the President derecognises the rulers, and the Supreme Court strikes the order down. Stage 4, 28 December 1971: the Twenty-sixth Amendment abolishes privy purses, upheld by the Supreme Court on 4 February 1993.
From promise to abolition in four stages

The first two stages built the guarantee; the last two dismantled it. The difference between stage three and stage four is the key to the whole story. In 1970 the government tried to end the purses by executive order while the Constitution still promised them, and the Supreme Court said no. In 1971 it changed the Constitution itself, and in 1993 the Court said that was within Parliament’s power.

Privy Purses Timeline, 1947 to 2023

Newest first. Each entry is tagged by type.

IntegrationParliament and politicsExecutive actionSupreme CourtConstitution and law
11 Dec 2023

The Article 370 judgment restates the privy purse rulings Supreme Court

In Re: Article 370 of the ConstitutionFive-judge Constitution Bench

What happened: Deciding the challenge to the 2019 changes in Jammu and Kashmir, the Supreme Court reviewed the two privy purse judgments at length and set out seven principles drawn from them.

What it said: The guarantee came from the text of the Constitution (Articles 291 and 366(22)), not from the merger agreements. While Article 291 stood, it could not be ended by an executive act of derecognition. Once Parliament deleted it by constitutional amendment, both the right and the obligation ended. Privy purses were not a quid pro quo for surrender of sovereignty, and Articles 291 and 366(22) were not part of the basic structure.

The Court used Madhav Rao Scindia to support a wider rule: a procedure laid down for amending the Constitution cannot be bypassed by a roundabout route.
4 Feb 1993

Supreme Court upholds the Twenty-sixth Amendment in full Supreme Court

Raghunathrao Ganpatrao v. Union of IndiaChief Justice L.M. Sharma and four judges

What happened: A Constitution Bench dismissed the challenges to the 1971 amendment and held it “valid in its entirety”. Justice S. Ratnavel Pandian wrote for himself, Chief Justice L.M. Sharma and Justices B.P. Jeevan Reddy and S.P. Bharucha; Justice S. Mohan concurred separately.

Why it matters: The bench held that abolishing privy purses and ending the recognition of rulers did not damage the basic structure of the Constitution. Justice Mohan noted that calling Articles 291 and 366(22) an ‘integral part’ of the Constitution in 1970 did not make them basic features. The judgment ended 21 years of litigation.

The ruling came more than two decades after the amendment, because the challenge was first held back for the Kesavananda Bharati case and then waited for a Constitution Bench.

Mysore’s royal successor joins the challenge Supreme Court

Writ Petition No. 798 of 1992Successor of Jaya Chamaraja Wadiyar

What happened: The successor of Jaya Chamaraja Wadiyar, the last ruling Maharaja of Mysore, filed a writ petition challenging the Twenty-sixth Amendment on the same grounds as the 1972 petition from Kurundwad. It was heard with that case.

The Mysore terms: Mysore’s agreement of 23 January 1950 gave the Maharaja Rs 26 lakh a year, tax-free, from 1 April 1950. A proviso made that sum payable only to him for his lifetime; provision for his successor was to be made separately.

Rs 26 lakh was the highest privy purse still being paid in 1970, according to the Supreme Court.
24 Apr 1973

The challenge is sent back after Kesavananda Bharati Supreme Court

Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala13-judge bench

What happened: The rulers’ 1972 petitions had been listed with the Kesavananda Bharati case. When the 13-judge bench delivered its judgment on 24 April 1973, it upheld the Twenty-fourth Amendment and directed that a Constitution Bench decide the validity of the Twenty-sixth Amendment “in accordance with law”.

Why it matters: Kesavananda created the test the princes would have to meet: Parliament can amend any part of the Constitution, but not its basic structure. Their case would now turn on whether privy purses were part of that structure.

The same judgment that limited Parliament’s amending power gave the government the doctrine it later used to defend abolition.
24 Aug 1972

A former co-ruler of Kurundwad challenges the amendment Supreme Court

Writ Petition No. 351 of 1972Kurundwad Junior, Deccan States

What happened: Raghunathrao Ganpatrao, co-ruler of the small state of Kurundwad Junior, petitioned the Supreme Court for a declaration that the Twenty-fourth, Twenty-fifth and Twenty-sixth Amendments were void and that he was still entitled to his privy purse and privileges. The Nawab of Malerkotla filed a similar petition, No. 352 of 1972.

His privy purse: Kurundwad Junior had signed a merger agreement on 19 February 1948 and handed over its administration on 8 March 1948. His privy purse was Rs 49,720 a year, tax-free, as set by the agreement and amended by a 1956 order.

The case that decided the fate of every former ruler carried the name of one of the smallest.
28 Dec 1971

The Twenty-sixth Amendment abolishes privy purses Constitution and law

Constitution (Twenty-sixth Amendment) Act, 1971Presidential assent: V.V. Giri

What happened: The President gave his assent and the amendment came into force the same day. It omitted Articles 291 and 362, inserted Article 363A and substituted a new clause (22) in Article 366.

What Article 363A did: It provided that every person recognised as a Ruler, or as a Ruler’s successor, before the amendment “shall, on and from such commencement, cease to be recognised”, and that privy purses were abolished and all rights, liabilities and obligations in respect of them extinguished.

Because the ruler’s status was ended by the Constitution itself, no executive order was needed this time, and none could be struck down.
9 Dec 1971

Rajya Sabha passes the abolition bill Parliament and politics

Constitution (Twenty-sixth Amendment) Bill, 1971Moved by Prime Minister Indira Gandhi

What happened: Fifteen months after defeating the 1970 bill, the Rajya Sabha passed the new one with the required two-thirds majority. The vote is reported as 167 for and 7 against.

What had changed: The Congress that Indira Gandhi led had won a large majority in the Lok Sabha in March 1971, and support for abolition in the upper house had firmed up.

The 1970 bill had failed in the same house by a fraction of a single vote.
2 Dec 1971

Lok Sabha passes the bill by a wide margin Parliament and politics

Constitution (Twenty-sixth Amendment) Bill, 1971Reported vote: 381 to 6

What happened: The Lok Sabha passed the bill after debate, with a reported 381 votes for and 6 against.

The argument: The government’s case was the one it had made in 1970: that rulership, with privy purses and special privileges “unrelated to any current functions and social purposes”, was incompatible with an egalitarian social order.

The vote came a day before war with Pakistan broke out on 3 December 1971.
5 Nov 1971

The Twenty-fourth Amendment restores Parliament’s amending power Constitution and law

Constitution (Twenty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1971Ratified by the legislatures of 11 States

What happened: After ratification by 11 State legislatures, the President assented to the Twenty-fourth Amendment. It declared that Parliament could amend any provision of the Constitution under Article 368, overriding the 1967 Golak Nath ruling.

Why it matters here: It cleared the legal ground for the Twenty-sixth Amendment. The new number for the privy purse bill is the reason the 1970 ‘Twenty-fourth Amendment Bill’ and the 1971 Twenty-fourth Amendment Act are different laws.

The former rulers later challenged the Twenty-fourth and Twenty-fifth Amendments alongside the Twenty-sixth.

Indira Gandhi wins a landslide Parliament and politics

Fifth Lok Sabha electionFought on ‘Garibi Hatao’

What happened: Indira Gandhi called an early general election after the setbacks of 1970. Her Congress won a two-thirds majority in the Lok Sabha.

Why it matters: The abolition of privy purses was part of a broader programme, alongside bank nationalisation, that the government presented as a move towards social and economic equality. The result gave it the numbers to amend the Constitution.

Several former rulers had fought the election against her, including Vijaya Raje Scindia of Gwalior, mother of the 1970 petitioner.
15 Dec 1970

Supreme Court strikes down the derecognition order, 9 to 2 Supreme Court

Madhav Rao Jivaji Rao Scindia v. Union of India11-judge bench; Chief Justice M. Hidayatullah

What happened: The Court held the President’s orders of 6 September 1970 “illegal, ultra vires and inoperative”. The majority judgment was written by Justice J.C. Shah for seven judges; Chief Justice Hidayatullah and Justice K.S. Hegde wrote concurring opinions. Justices G.K. Mitter and A.N. Ray dissented.

The reasoning: The power to recognise a Ruler under Article 366(22) could not be used for the collateral purpose of abolishing the whole order of Rulers while Article 291 still guaranteed their privy purses. The rulers were declared entitled to their purses and privileges, and payments were restored.

A.N. Ray, one of the two dissenters, was appointed Chief Justice in 1973 over three more senior judges.
11 Sep 1970

The Maharaja of Gwalior goes to the Supreme Court Executive action

Writ petition under Article 32Madhav Rao Jivaji Rao Scindia

What happened: Madhav Rao Scindia, recognised by the President as Ruler of Gwalior in 1961, asked the Court to declare the order of 6 September 1970 “unconstitutional, ultra vires and void” and to hold that he remained entitled to his privy purse and privileges. Other rulers filed similar petitions.

The government’s defence: It argued that recognition was a matter of State policy, that the covenants gave no enforceable rights, and that Article 363 barred the courts from hearing disputes arising out of them.

The 11-judge bench matched the size of the one that had decided Golak Nath in 1967.
7 Sep 1970

The government defends the order in Parliament Executive action

Statement laid in the Rajya SabhaFinance Minister

What happened: The day after the orders, the Finance Minister laid a statement before the Rajya Sabha. It claimed that the President’s power to withdraw recognition of the Rulers was unquestionable and that orders had been issued in pursuance of that decision.

The difficulty: The government had just failed to amend the Constitution. Doing by executive order what Parliament had refused to do invited the charge that the power was being used for a collateral purpose.

That charge, collateral purpose, was the ground on which the Supreme Court struck the order down three months later.
6 Sep 1970

The President derecognises every former ruler Executive action

Orders under Article 366(22)President V.V. Giri

What happened: Hours after the Rajya Sabha vote, the President signed, in Hyderabad, an instrument withdrawing the recognition of all the Rulers. Separate orders dated 6 September were served on each one and published in the Gazette.

The intended effect: If no one was recognised as a Ruler, the government reasoned, no privy purse was payable under Article 291 and the privileges would lapse with it.

The Supreme Court described the order served on the Ruler of Gwalior as ‘laconic’: a few lines ending a recognition guaranteed by the Constitution.
5 Sep 1970

Rajya Sabha defeats the first abolition bill Parliament and politics

Constitution (Twenty-fourth Amendment) Bill, 1970149 for, 75 against

What happened: The bill received 149 votes for and 75 against. Under Article 368 an amendment needs two-thirds of members present and voting, which meant 150. It was declared lost.

Why it matters: The margin was a fraction of a single vote. The failure sent the government to the executive route the same night.

Had one member who voted against stayed away, the bill would have passed.
2 Sep 1970

Lok Sabha passes the 1970 bill Parliament and politics

Constitution (Twenty-fourth Amendment) Bill, 1970332 for, 154 against

What happened: The Lok Sabha voted 332 to 154 for the bill, clearing the two-thirds threshold of members present and voting.

What the bill did: It had three clauses and a short Statement of Objects and Reasons, and would have removed Articles 291 and 362 and the recognition of Rulers under Article 366(22).

The 2023 Article 370 judgment summarised this episode in one sentence: the bill passed the Lok Sabha but “the requisite majority was not attained in the Rajya Sabha”.
14 May 1970

The first abolition bill is introduced Parliament and politics

Constitution (Twenty-fourth Amendment) Bill, 1970Lok Sabha

What happened: The government introduced a bill to end privy purses and privileges. Its Statement of Objects and Reasons said the concept of rulership with privy purses and special privileges was “incompatible with an egalitarian social order”.

Background: Talks between the Home Ministry and representatives of the rulers after 1967 had not produced an agreed settlement.

This bill was never enacted, so its number was later reused: the Twenty-fourth Amendment Act of 1971 is about Parliament’s amending power, not privy purses.
25 Jun 1967

Congress resolves to abolish privy purses Parliament and politics

All India Congress CommitteeAfter the 1967 elections

What happened: The All India Congress Committee passed a resolution calling for the abolition of privy purses and privileges. The Union Home Ministry then held a series of talks with the rulers.

Why it matters: The Supreme Court in 1993 recorded that the 1970 bill was introduced “to implement the decision of the All India Congress Committee”. Several rulers had joined opposition parties, notably the Swatantra Party, in the 1967 elections.

The resolution came 18 years after Sardar Patel told the Constituent Assembly that the guarantees were a fair price for integration.

Nehru asks the rulers for a voluntary contribution Parliament and politics

Letter from the Prime MinisterRulers receiving Rs 1 lakh or more

What happened: Jawaharlal Nehru told the Lok Sabha in November 1953 that he had written personally to rulers about their privy purses. His appeal was for a voluntary contribution from the larger purses towards development schemes, not a legal cut.

The result: There was no general agreement to reduce the payments, which remained fixed by the covenants and guaranteed by Article 291.

The guaranteed purses were already set to shrink: many agreements fixed a higher sum for the ruler of 1947-49 and a lower one for his successors.
26 Jan 1950

The Constitution guarantees the privy purses Constitution and law

Articles 291, 362, 363 and 366(22)Republic Day

What happened: The Constitution came into force. Article 291 charged guaranteed privy purses on the Consolidated Fund of India and exempted them from income tax. Article 362 required governments and legislatures to have due regard to the guarantees on personal rights, privileges and dignities. Article 363 kept disputes arising from the covenants out of the courts. Article 366(22) defined a ‘Ruler’ as the person recognised by the President.

Why it matters: The guarantee now rested on the Constitution itself. That was why, in 1970, the executive could not undo it, and why, in 1971, only a constitutional amendment could.

The power of recognition in Article 366(22) was the lever the government tried to pull in 1970.

The last big agreements: Mysore and Hyderabad Integration

Mysore: 23 January 1950Hyderabad: 25 January 1950

What happened: Days before the Constitution took effect, the Government of India signed agreements with the two largest states left territorially untouched by integration. The Maharaja of Mysore was to receive Rs 26 lakh a year from 1 April 1950; the Nizam of Hyderabad, Rs 50 lakh a year, both free of all taxes.

The successor clauses: Both sums were personal. Mysore’s was payable to the then Maharaja for his lifetime only, and for the Nizam’s successors provision was to be made later by the Government of India.

The Nizam’s Rs 50 lakh was five times the general ceiling of Rs 10 lakh.
12 Oct 1949

Patel defends the guarantees in the Constituent Assembly Constitution and law

Draft Constitution debatesSardar Vallabhbhai Patel

What happened: Patel moved and defended the provisions on privy purses and rulers’ privileges. He argued that the guarantees were part of the settlement under which the rulers had given up their states, and the Assembly adopted them.

The numbers he could cite: V.P. Menon recorded that the rulers had handed over cash balances of about Rs 77 crore, and that “the price paid as Privy Purses was not too high for integration”. Both later Supreme Court judgments quoted him.

Both the 1970 and 1993 benches cited Patel’s speech; in 1993 the rulers relied on it, and the Court still held the guarantees could be removed.
5 Jul 1948

The White Paper on Indian States is published Integration

Ministry of StatesRevised edition: March 1950

What happened: The Ministry of States published a White Paper surveying its first year: the accessions, the mergers and the terms given to rulers. A revised and expanded edition followed in 1950.

What it covered: The transfer of governing authority, privy purses, succession, personal privileges, and the line between state property and the rulers’ private property.

The Ministry issued a separate memorandum on rulers’ privileges in 1949, listing 34 items, from exemptions under Indian laws to the State paying for the marriages of a ruler’s brothers and sisters.
1948-49

Merger agreements fix the privy purses Integration

Covenants and merger agreementsCeiling: Rs 10 lakh

What happened: Ruler after ruler signed agreements surrendering all governing powers. Some states merged into neighbouring provinces, some were grouped into unions such as Saurashtra, Rajasthan and Travancore-Cochin, and a few were run directly by the Centre. In return each ruler got a fixed, tax-free privy purse, guaranteed succession and personal privileges.

How purses were set: They were fixed with regard to each state’s revenue before integration, with a general ceiling of Rs 10 lakh a year; eleven rulers received more. The 1993 judgment put the total at about Rs 5.8 crore a year.

By 1970 the range ran from Rs 26 lakh a year for Mysore down to Rs 192 a year for the Ruler of Kotodia, according to the Supreme Court.
15 Aug 1947

Independence: most rulers accede to India Integration

Instruments of AccessionDefence, external affairs, communications

What happened: As British paramountcy lapsed, most rulers of states contiguous with India had signed Instruments of Accession. Accession transferred only three subjects; the rulers kept their internal authority for now.

The scale: The states covered about 48 per cent of the area of the Indian Dominion and 28 per cent of its population. Counts vary, but there were more than 550 of them.

Hyderabad, Junagadh and Jammu and Kashmir had not acceded by 15 August; each followed a separate and contested path.
25 Jul 1947

Mountbatten addresses the Chamber of Princes Integration

Lord MountbattenNew Delhi

What happened: The Viceroy urged the rulers to accede to India or Pakistan on defence, external affairs and communications, telling them that independence was not a practical option.

Why it matters: His speech set the framework for the Instruments of Accession signed over the next three weeks.

The Chamber of Princes, inaugurated in 1921 as a consultative body of rulers, did not survive independence.
5 Jul 1947

The States Department is created Integration

Sardar Vallabhbhai PatelV.P. Menon, Secretary

What happened: The States Department was set up under Patel, with V.P. Menon as its senior official, to handle relations with the princely states. It later became the Ministry of States.

Why it matters: Patel and Menon negotiated the accessions and then the mergers. The privy purse was one of the main inducements they offered.

Menon later told the story in The Story of the Integration of the Indian States (1956).
3 Jun 1947

The partition plan leaves the princes’ future open Integration

3 June PlanLapse of paramountcy

What happened: The British government announced that British India would be divided into two Dominions. The princely states were not part of either; with the end of paramountcy, their rulers would have to decide their own future.

Why it matters: It turned more than 550 rulers into negotiating parties, and made the terms offered to them, including privy purses, a matter of high politics.

Paramountcy was the British Crown’s supremacy over the princely states; it could not be transferred to either new Dominion.

1970: Why the First Attempt Failed

Ten weeks, two defeats: one in Parliament, one in court.

The 1970 votes. Lok Sabha, 2 September 1970: 332 for, 154 against, passed. Rajya Sabha, 5 September 1970: 149 for, 75 against; two-thirds of 224 members voting was 149.33, so 150 votes were needed and the bill was lost. Supreme Court, 15 December 1970: the derecognition order struck down by 9 judges to 2.
The three votes of 1970

The Constitution (Twenty-fourth Amendment) Bill was introduced in the Lok Sabha on 14 May 1970 to remove Articles 291 and 362 and the recognition of Rulers. The Lok Sabha passed it on 2 September, by 332 votes to 154. Three days later the Rajya Sabha voted 149 to 75. An amendment needs two-thirds of the members present and voting; with 224 voting, that was 150. The bill failed by a fraction of a single vote.

The government did not wait. The same night, the President signed in Hyderabad an instrument withdrawing the recognition of every ruler, and orders dated 6 September were served on each of them. If nobody was recognised as a Ruler, the reasoning went, nobody was owed a privy purse under Article 291.

The Maharaja of Gwalior, Madhav Rao Scindia, petitioned the Supreme Court on 11 September, followed by other rulers. On 15 December 1970 an 11-judge bench held the orders illegal by 9 to 2. Justice J.C. Shah, writing for seven judges, said the recognition power in Article 366(22) could not be used to abolish the order of Rulers while Article 291 stood; Chief Justice M. Hidayatullah and Justice K.S. Hegde concurred separately, and Justices G.K. Mitter and A.N. Ray dissented. The majority also held that Article 363 was only a limited bar and did not stop the Court from asking whether an executive order was unauthorised. The purses were restored.

“The concept of rulership, with privy purses and special privileges unrelated to any current functions and social purposes, is incompatible with an egalitarian social order.”

Statement of Objects and Reasons, Constitution (Twenty-fourth Amendment) Bill, 1970

How the Twenty-sixth Amendment Abolished Privy Purses

This time the change was made to the Constitution itself.

How the Twenty-sixth Amendment worked, 28 December 1971. Article 291 omitted: no constitutional guarantee of privy purses. Article 362 omitted: no duty to respect rulers’ privileges. Article 363A inserted: recognition of all rulers and successors ends, and privy purses are abolished with all related rights, liabilities and obligations extinguished. Article 366(22) substituted: Ruler now refers only to persons recognised before the amendment. Passed by the Lok Sabha on 2 December 1971 and the Rajya Sabha on 9 December 1971.
The Twenty-sixth Amendment, clause by clause

Indira Gandhi dissolved the Lok Sabha early and won a two-thirds majority in March 1971. The Twenty-fourth Amendment Act, which restored Parliament’s power to amend any part of the Constitution after the Golak Nath ruling, received assent on 5 November 1971. The privy purse bill followed under the next number, the Twenty-sixth. The Lok Sabha passed it on 2 December 1971 and the Rajya Sabha on 9 December, by reported votes of 381 to 6 and 167 to 7. It came into force with the President’s assent on 28 December 1971.

The new Article 363A did the work. Anyone recognised as a Ruler or successor before the amendment “shall, on and from such commencement, cease to be recognised”, and privy purses were “abolished and all rights, liabilities and obligations in respect of privy purse are extinguished”. Because the change was in the Constitution, there was no executive order left for a court to strike down.

ProvisionBefore 28 Dec 1971After the 26th Amendment
Article 291Privy purses charged on the Consolidated Fund, exempt from income taxOmitted
Article 362Due regard to rulers’ personal rights, privileges and dignitiesOmitted
Article 363ADid not existRecognition ends; privy purses abolished
Article 366(22)Ruler = person recognised by the PresidentRuler = person recognised before the amendment
Article 363Bar on court disputes over covenantsRetained

How Much Did Former Rulers Receive?

From Rs 50 lakh a year to Rs 192: negotiated one state at a time.

Annual privy purses recorded in the Supreme Court judgments. Nizam of Hyderabad: Rs 50 lakh, agreement of 25 January 1950, for the then ruler. Maharaja of Mysore: Rs 26 lakh from 1 April 1950, for the then Maharaja’s lifetime; the highest still paid in 1970. Bhopal: Rs 11 lakh for the then Nawab, Rs 9 lakh for successors. General ceiling: Rs 10 lakh. Kurundwad Junior: Rs 49,720. Kotodia: Rs 192, the lowest in 1970. Total: about Rs 5.8 crore a year.
Privy purses recorded in the judgments
StateAnnual privy purseTerms recorded by the Supreme Court
HyderabadRs 50,00,000Agreement of 25 Jan 1950; successors’ purse to be fixed later
MysoreRs 26,00,000Agreement of 23 Jan 1950; for the then Maharaja’s lifetime only
BhopalRs 11,00,000Then ruler; each successor Rs 9 lakh
General ceilingRs 10,00,000Exceeded by eleven rulers
Kurundwad JuniorRs 49,720Merger agreement of 19 Feb 1948, amended 1956
KotodiaRs 192The lowest privy purse in 1970

The figures above are examples taken from the judgments, not a complete list. The Supreme Court’s 1993 judgment put the total at about Rs 5.8 crore a year, liable to fall as successor rates took over. A single sentence in one of the 1970 opinions gives ‘Rs. 58 crores’; that figure is ten times the 1993 one and appears to be a misprint, but it is often repeated. Against the cost, V.P. Menon set what the rulers had handed over, including cash balances of about Rs 77 crore. In his view the purses were “not too high” a price for integration.

The Two Judgments That Decided It

Why the rulers won in 1970 and lost in 1993, without any contradiction.

The two Supreme Court judgments compared. Madhav Rao Scindia v. Union of India, 15 December 1970: 11 judges, 9 to 2, challenge to an executive order derecognising rulers; held the order illegal because Article 291 still guaranteed privy purses; rulers won. Raghunathrao Ganpatrao v. Union of India, 4 February 1993: 5 judges, unanimous, challenge to the Twenty-sixth Amendment; held the amendment valid because privy purses were not part of the basic structure; rulers lost.
1970 vs 1993: the two judgments
Madhav Rao Scindia (1970)Raghunathrao Ganpatrao (1993)
Date15 December 19704 February 1993
Bench11 judges, CJI M. Hidayatullah5 judges, CJI L.M. Sharma
What was challengedPresident’s order of 6 Sep 1970Twenty-sixth Amendment, 1971
ResultOrder struck down, 9 to 2Amendment upheld, unanimously
ReasonExecutive cannot override Article 291Not part of the basic structure
Who wonThe rulersThe Union

The two rulings fit together. In 1970 the Court enforced the Constitution as it stood; in 1993 it accepted that Parliament had validly changed it. Between them came Kesavananda Bharati (24 April 1973), which allowed any amendment that left the Constitution’s basic structure intact. The 1993 bench held that privy purses and rulers’ privileges were not part of that structure. Justice S. Mohan added that calling Articles 291 and 366(22) an ‘integral part’ of the Constitution in 1970 had not made them basic features.

The 1993 bench also rejected the rulers’ central claim, that the purses were a quid pro quo for surrendering sovereignty. It treated integration as a complex political process, driven as much by democratic movements inside the states as by bargaining with their rulers. On 11 December 2023, in the Article 370 judgment, the Supreme Court summed up the law: the guarantee came from the Constitution, not the agreements; the executive could not end it while Article 291 stood; and a constitutional amendment could.

Why Did India Abolish Privy Purses?

A promise made in 1947 against the idea of equal citizenship.

The Government vs the Former Rulers

The government’s case
Indira Gandhi’s Congress, 1967-71
  • Hereditary rulership has no place in a democratic republic.
  • Privileges unrelated to any public function are incompatible with an egalitarian social order.
  • Public money should not fund an inherited status.
  • Parliament can amend any part of the Constitution.
vs
The rulers’ case
Former princes, 1970-93
  • The purses were the agreed price for surrendering their states.
  • The Constitution itself guaranteed them.
  • The executive cannot cancel a constitutional guarantee.
  • Breaking a solemn promise damages the basic structure.

The courts separated the two halves of the argument. The rulers’ third point won in 1970: the executive could not cancel what the Constitution guaranteed. Their fourth lost in 1993: removing the guarantee by amendment did not damage the basic structure. The political case was settled at the ballot box in March 1971, when abolition was part of the programme on which Indira Gandhi won a two-thirds majority.

What Changed After Abolition?

The end of a constitutional status, not of families or their private property.

From 28 December 1971 no one in India was recognised by the Constitution as a Ruler, and no privy purse was payable. The privileges listed in the 1949 Ministry of States memorandum, 34 items in all, lost their constitutional backing with Article 362.

The amendment did not confiscate private property. What belonged to the state and what remained the ruler’s personal property had been settled in the merger agreements, and families kept palaces, estates, trusts and businesses as private owners, subject to ordinary law, including taxation and succession. Former royals continue to use their titles socially and ceremonially, and many entered politics as elected representatives, but the titles carry no legal status.

Key People

Minister of States

Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel

Deputy Prime Minister who led the integration of the princely states and defended the privy purse guarantees in the Constituent Assembly on 12 October 1949.

Negotiator

V.P. Menon

Secretary of the States Ministry who drafted and negotiated the accessions and mergers, and argued the purses were a low price for integration.

Prime Minister

Jawaharlal Nehru

Appealed in 1953 to rulers with larger purses for voluntary contributions towards development; the guarantees stayed in place.

Prime Minister

Indira Gandhi

Led the 1970 attempt and, after the March 1971 election, the Twenty-sixth Amendment, which she moved in the Rajya Sabha in December 1971.

President

V.V. Giri

Signed the derecognition order on the night of 5-6 September 1970 and gave assent to the Twenty-sixth Amendment on 28 December 1971.

Petitioner, 1970

Madhav Rao Scindia

Maharaja of Gwalior, recognised as Ruler in 1961, whose petition led to the 15 December 1970 ruling.

Petitioner, 1972

Raghunathrao Ganpatrao

Co-ruler of Kurundwad Junior, with a purse of Rs 49,720, whose challenge to the Twenty-sixth Amendment was decided in 1993.

Judges

J.C. Shah and S. Ratnavel Pandian

Authors of the main judgments: Shah for the 1970 majority, Pandian for the 1993 Constitution Bench.

Facts at a Glance

DetailInformation
SubjectPrivy purses in India
OriginIntegration of princely states, 1947-50
Main negotiatorsSardar Vallabhbhai Patel and V.P. Menon
Constitutional guaranteeArticles 291, 362 and 366(22)
Approximate totalAbout Rs 5.8 crore a year (1993 judgment)
Congress resolution25 June 1967
Failed amendmentRajya Sabha, 5 September 1970 (149-75)
Derecognition order6 September 1970
Order struck down15 December 1970 (9-2)
Abolition lawConstitution (Twenty-sixth Amendment) Act, 1971
In force28 December 1971
Key provisionArticle 363A
Amendment upheld4 February 1993

Legacy: From Negotiated Monarchy to Republican Equality

The privy purse was the price of a peaceful merger: hundreds of states with their own armies and treasuries became part of one Union largely by agreement, and their rulers kept an income and a title. Two decades later the republic’s politics had changed, and Parliament removed the hereditary privileges by amending the Constitution.

The legal journey left two rules that still matter. The executive cannot bypass a guarantee that stands in the Constitution, as the Court held in 1970. Parliament can remove such a guarantee by a valid amendment, provided the basic structure is intact, as it held in 1993. The Supreme Court leaned on both in 2023.

Explore More Timelines

People Also Ask

What were privy purses in India?
Annual, tax-free payments that the Government of India made to the former rulers of princely states, or their recognised successors, under the agreements by which they gave up their states in 1947-49. Article 291 of the Constitution guaranteed them and charged them on the Consolidated Fund of India until 1971.
When were privy purses abolished?
By the Constitution (Twenty-sixth Amendment) Act, 1971, which received presidential assent and came into force on 28 December 1971. It omitted Articles 291 and 362 and inserted Article 363A, which ended the recognition of rulers and extinguished all rights and obligations relating to privy purses.
Who abolished privy purses?
The government of Prime Minister Indira Gandhi. Its first attempt failed in September 1970, when a constitutional amendment fell short in the Rajya Sabha and the Supreme Court struck down the President's derecognition order. After winning the March 1971 election, it passed the Twenty-sixth Amendment in December 1971.
Why did the 1970 attempt fail?
Twice. On 5 September 1970 the amendment bill got 149 votes to 75 in the Rajya Sabha, short of the two-thirds needed. The President then derecognised all rulers by order on 6 September, but on 15 December 1970 the Supreme Court held, 9 to 2, that the order was illegal while Article 291 remained in the Constitution.
How much were the privy purses?
They varied widely. The 1993 Supreme Court judgment put the total at about Rs 5.8 crore a year. The Nizam of Hyderabad was given Rs 50 lakh a year and the Maharaja of Mysore Rs 26 lakh; the general ceiling was Rs 10 lakh, and the smallest purse in 1970 was Rs 192 a year.
Was the abolition of privy purses upheld by the courts?
Yes. In Raghunathrao Ganpatrao v. Union of India, decided on 4 February 1993, a five-judge Constitution Bench held the Twenty-sixth Amendment valid in its entirety, ruling that privy purses and the recognition of rulers were not part of the basic structure of the Constitution.

Frequently Asked Questions

Based on the Supreme Court judgments of 1970, 1993 and 2023 and the text of the Twenty-sixth Amendment.

Which Article of the Constitution dealt with privy purses?
Article 291. It provided that sums guaranteed as privy purses under a ruler's covenant or agreement would be charged on and paid out of the Consolidated Fund of India and be exempt from all taxes on income. Article 362 protected rulers' personal rights and privileges, and Article 366(22) defined who was a Ruler.
What is Article 363A?
The provision inserted by the Twenty-sixth Amendment in 1971. It says that anyone recognised as a Ruler, or a Ruler's successor, before the amendment ceases to be recognised as such, and that privy purses are abolished and all rights, liabilities and obligations in respect of them are extinguished.
What did the Twenty-sixth Amendment change?
Four things: it omitted Article 291 on privy purses, omitted Article 362 on rulers' rights and privileges, inserted Article 363A ending recognition and abolishing privy purses, and substituted a new clause (22) in Article 366 so that 'Ruler' referred only to persons recognised before the amendment.
When did Parliament pass the Twenty-sixth Amendment?
The Lok Sabha passed it on 2 December 1971 and the Rajya Sabha on 9 December 1971, by reported votes of 381 to 6 and 167 to 7. President V.V. Giri gave his assent on 28 December 1971, the day it took effect.
What was the Twenty-fourth Amendment Bill of 1970?
The government's first attempt to abolish privy purses, introduced in the Lok Sabha on 14 May 1970. The Lok Sabha passed it 332 to 154 on 2 September 1970, but the Rajya Sabha vote on 5 September was 149 to 75, short of two-thirds. It is a different measure from the Twenty-fourth Amendment Act of 1971.
By how much did the 1970 bill fail in the Rajya Sabha?
By a fraction of a single vote. With 224 members voting, two-thirds was 149.33, so 150 votes were needed. The bill got 149. Had one of the 75 members who voted against it abstained, it would have passed.
What did the President's order of 6 September 1970 do?
It withdrew the recognition of every former ruler under Article 366(22). The President signed the instrument in Hyderabad on the night the Rajya Sabha rejected the bill, and separate orders dated 6 September were served on each ruler. Without recognised rulers, the government argued, no privy purse was payable.
What was the Madhav Rao Scindia case?
Madhav Rao Jivaji Rao Scindia v. Union of India, the challenge by the Maharaja of Gwalior and other rulers to the 1970 derecognition order. On 15 December 1970 an 11-judge bench struck the order down, 9 to 2, holding that the recognition power could not be used to abolish the rulers while Article 291 stood.
Who were the judges in the 1970 privy purses case?
Chief Justice M. Hidayatullah and Justices J.C. Shah, S.M. Sikri, J.M. Shelat, V. Bhargava, G.K. Mitter, C.A. Vaidialingam, K.S. Hegde, A.N. Grover, A.N. Ray and I.D. Dua. Shah wrote the main majority judgment; Hidayatullah and Hegde concurred separately; Mitter and Ray dissented.
Why did the Supreme Court strike down the 1970 order?
Because the President's power under Article 366(22) to recognise a Ruler could not be used for the collateral purpose of ending the whole order of Rulers. As long as Article 291 guaranteed privy purses, only a constitutional amendment could remove them. The rulers were declared still entitled to their purses and privileges.
What was the Raghunathrao Ganpatrao case?
The challenge to the Twenty-sixth Amendment, led by Raghunathrao Ganpatrao, former co-ruler of Kurundwad Junior, whose petition was filed on 24 August 1972. A Constitution Bench headed by Chief Justice L.M. Sharma dismissed it on 4 February 1993, upholding the abolition.
Why did the 1993 challenge take so long?
The 1972 petitions were tagged with the Kesavananda Bharati case. On 24 April 1973 that 13-judge bench sent the question of the Twenty-sixth Amendment back to a Constitution Bench to decide 'in accordance with law'. The final hearing and judgment came in 1993.
Were privy purses part of the basic structure of the Constitution?
No. The 1993 Constitution Bench held that Articles 291 and 362 were not basic features, and that removing them did not change the identity of the Constitution. The 2023 Article 370 judgment restated that Articles 291 and 366(22) were not part of the basic structure.
Were privy purses compensation for the surrender of the states?
The rulers argued they were. The Supreme Court in 1993 rejected the idea that privy purses were a quid pro quo for surrendering sovereignty, describing integration as a complex political process. The 2023 Article 370 judgment repeated that conclusion.
What did the 2023 Article 370 judgment say about privy purses?
On 11 December 2023 the Supreme Court summarised the two privy purse rulings: the guarantee came from the Constitution, not the agreements; executive derecognition could not end it while Article 291 stood; a constitutional amendment could; and the guarantee was not a basic feature. It used Madhav Rao Scindia to hold that amendment procedures cannot be bypassed.
Who negotiated the privy purse agreements?
The States Department, created on 5 July 1947 under Sardar Vallabhbhai Patel, with V.P. Menon as its senior official. It later became the Ministry of States. Patel and Menon secured the accessions of 1947 and then the merger agreements of 1948-49, in which privy purses were a central term.
How were privy purse amounts decided?
They were negotiated state by state, with regard to each state's revenue before integration, under a general ceiling of Rs 10 lakh a year. Eleven rulers were allowed more. Many agreements fixed a higher sum for the ruler at the time and a lower one for his successors.
How much did the Nizam of Hyderabad get?
Under his agreement of 25 January 1950, the Nizam was to receive Rs 50 lakh a year as his privy purse, free of all taxes. The agreement left provision for his successors to be made later by the Government of India.
How much did the Maharaja of Mysore get?
Rs 26 lakh a year, tax-free, from 1 April 1950, under the agreement of 23 January 1950. A proviso made that sum payable only to the then Maharaja for his lifetime. In 1970 it was the highest privy purse still being paid.
What was the smallest privy purse?
According to the Supreme Court's 1970 judgment, the lowest was Rs 192 a year, paid to the Ruler of Kotodia. Kurundwad Junior, whose co-ruler later led the 1993 challenge, received Rs 49,720 a year.
What was the total cost of privy purses?
The Supreme Court's 1993 judgment said the total came to about Rs 5.8 crore a year, a figure liable to fall with each generation as successor rates applied. One opinion in the 1970 judgment prints the total as 'Rs. 58 crores', which appears to be a misprint.
What privileges did the rulers have apart from money?
A 1949 Ministry of States memorandum listed 34 privileges, including exemptions from some Indian laws, use of titles, immunity from some court processes, protection of private property from requisition, and the State meeting marriage expenses for a ruler's brothers and sisters. Article 362 asked governments to have due regard to them.
Did Nehru try to reduce privy purses?
He tried persuasion, not law. In 1953 Jawaharlal Nehru wrote to rulers receiving larger purses, asking for a voluntary contribution towards development schemes. There was no general agreement to reduce the guaranteed payments.
Why did Indira Gandhi want to abolish privy purses?
The government said rulership with privy purses and special privileges unrelated to any public function was incompatible with an egalitarian social order. The move followed a 1967 Congress resolution and formed part of her programme alongside bank nationalisation and the 1971 'Garibi Hatao' campaign.
What did the former rulers argue?
That privy purses were part of the solemn agreements under which they gave up their states, that the Constitution had guaranteed them, that the executive could not ignore that guarantee, and that abolition was a breach of faith that damaged the Constitution's basic structure. The first argument won in 1970; the last lost in 1993.
Did the abolition take away royal palaces and property?
No. Article 363A ended privy purses and official recognition, not private property. The line between state property and rulers' private property had been drawn in the merger agreements of 1948-50. Many families kept palaces and estates as private owners under ordinary law.
Can former royal families still use their titles?
Socially, yes, but the titles have no legal status. Since 28 December 1971 no one is recognised by the Constitution as a Ruler, and the Constitution does not confer any title on former rulers or their descendants.
How many princely states were there in 1947?
Counts vary between about 550 and 565 depending on how small estates are treated. The 1993 Supreme Court judgment used a figure of about 554. Together they covered about 48 per cent of the area of the Indian Dominion and 28 per cent of its population.
What was the White Paper on Indian States?
A Ministry of States report published on 5 July 1948, surveying the accessions, mergers and terms given to rulers in the Ministry's first year. A revised and expanded edition was issued in 1950.
What did Sardar Patel say about privy purses?
Speaking in the Constituent Assembly on 12 October 1949, Patel defended the guarantees as part of the bargain under which the rulers had given up their states and their powers. V.P. Menon later argued that the purses were a small price compared with what the rulers had surrendered, including cash balances of about Rs 77 crore.
What role did Article 363 play?
Article 363 barred courts from hearing disputes arising out of the pre-Constitution covenants and agreements. In 1970 the government relied on it, but the majority held it was a limited bar: a claim that an executive order was unauthorised, as the derecognition order was alleged to be, did not fall within it.
Is the privy purse decision still relevant?
Yes. It is a standard illustration of two constitutional rules: the executive cannot override a guarantee that stands in the Constitution, and Parliament can remove that guarantee by a valid amendment that leaves the basic structure intact. The Supreme Court relied on it again in the 2023 Article 370 case.

⚠️ Editorial Note: What We Checked

We checked the brief we started from against the Supreme Court’s judgments in Madhav Rao Jivaji Rao Scindia v. Union of India (15 December 1970), Raghunathrao Ganpatrao v. Union of India (4 February 1993) and In Re: Article 370 (11 December 2023), and the text of the Twenty-sixth Amendment. The total of privy purses is given as about Rs 5.8 crore a year (1993), not Rs 58 crore. The Nizam’s purse was Rs 50 lakh, not Rs 20 lakh. The White Paper on Indian States was first published on 5 July 1948. The 1972 challenges came from Kurundwad Junior and Malerkotla; Mysore’s petition was filed in 1992. We could not confirm from a primary record the date the 1971 bill was introduced, or a reported 10-15% figure for Nehru’s 1953-54 appeal, so neither is stated. The 1971 vote counts are as reported, not taken from the parliamentary debates. This article is a historical account and not legal advice.

Related Reading on AiTimeline

Aaya Ram, Gaya Ram: Haryana Defections Explained Rohingya Genocide Ruling: A Timeline of Justice and Displacement
New article
→
Next Article