← AiTimeline Home

India · 1949 to 2026 · Article 13 vs Article 368

Golaknath Case 1967: Parliament’s Power to Amend the Constitution

📅 Last updated: 20 November 2026⏱ 25 dated entries✎ By Nazish Fatima

View as Web Story

In short

Explore the 1967 Golaknath case, its 6-5 Supreme Court verdict, the 24th Amendment and how Kesavananda Bharati established the Basic Structure doctrine.

Latest Story

Can Parliament amend the Constitution to take away a Fundamental Right? For 16 years the Supreme Court said yes. Then, on 27 February 1967, in I.C. Golaknath v. State of Punjab, an 11-judge Bench said no, by a single vote. The Golaknath case began as a Punjab family’s fight over 418 standard acres of surplus land and ended as the first ruling that Parliament’s amending power had limits. It held that a constitutional amendment is ‘law’ under Article 13(2) and so cannot abridge Part III, yet used prospective overruling to leave every earlier amendment standing. Parliament reversed it with the Twenty-fourth Amendment in 1971, and in 1973 Kesavananda Bharati replaced it with the basic structure doctrine. This timeline follows that argument from the drafting of Articles 13 and 368 to today, checked against the judgments and the amendment Acts.

Read this first: what is often got wrong

The petitioners lost. The petitions were dismissed and the Punjab and Mysore land laws stayed in force. Prospective overruling was the view of five judges, led by Chief Justice Subba Rao; Justice Hidayatullah, the sixth vote, reached the same result through long acquiescence and Article 31A. The Twenty-fourth Amendment Bill was introduced on 28 July 1971, not 22 July. The Twenty-fifth Amendment received assent on 20 April 1972, five and a half months after the Twenty-fourth, not on the same day. Golaknath did not create the basic structure doctrine; its majority expressly left that question open.

💡 Short Answer

In I.C. Golaknath v. State of Punjab (27 February 1967), the Supreme Court held 6-5 that Parliament cannot use its amending power under Article 368 to take away or abridge Fundamental Rights, because an amendment is ‘law’ under Article 13(2). Applying prospective overruling, it left earlier amendments valid and dismissed the petitions. Parliament reversed the ruling with the Twenty-fourth Amendment (1971). In Kesavananda Bharati (1973) a 13-judge Bench overruled Golaknath: Parliament may amend Fundamental Rights, but not the Constitution’s basic structure. That remains the law as of November 2026.

⚡ Facts at a Glance
Decided27 February 1967, AIR 1967 SC 1643
Bench11 judges, led by CJ K. Subba Rao
Majority6-5 (5 + Hidayatullah concurring)
Land in issue418 standard acres, Jullundur, Punjab
Reversed by24th Amendment, assent 5 Nov 1971
Overruled byKesavananda Bharati, 24 Apr 1973 (7-6)
⚡ Quick Answers — AI Overview Ready

The Golaknath Case: Key Questions

What did Golaknath hold?
That Parliament cannot amend the Constitution to take away or abridge Fundamental Rights, because a constitutional amendment is ‘law’ within Article 13(2). The vote of the 11-judge Bench was 6-5.
Were earlier amendments struck down?
No. Using prospective overruling, the majority left the First, Fourth and Seventeenth Amendments valid and applied the new rule only to future amendments. The petitions were dismissed.
How did Parliament respond?
With the Twenty-fourth Amendment of 1971, which excluded amendments from Article 13 and declared that Parliament may amend any provision of the Constitution under Article 368.
Is Golaknath still law?
No. Kesavananda Bharati overruled it in 1973. Parliament may amend Fundamental Rights, but not in a way that damages or destroys the Constitution’s basic structure.
📚 Key Takeaways

The Golaknath Case in Ten Lines

  • The silence: Articles 13(2) and 368 never said whether an amendment counts as ‘law’.
  • Round one: Shankari Prasad (1951) said it does not, so Fundamental Rights could be amended.
  • Round two: Sajjan Singh (1964) agreed, but two judges voiced doubts.
  • The dispute: a Punjab family lost 418 standard acres as surplus under a 1953 land law.
  • The shield: the Seventeenth Amendment (1964) had put that law in the Ninth Schedule.
  • The verdict: on 27 February 1967, 6-5, amendments became ‘law’ that could not abridge rights.
  • The twist: prospective overruling kept every earlier amendment, and the family lost.
  • The reply: the Twenty-fourth Amendment (1971) restored Parliament’s power in so many words.
  • The settlement: Kesavananda Bharati (1973) overruled Golaknath but created the basic structure limit.
  • Today: Parliament can amend rights, but not the Constitution’s essential features.
The Golaknath case in figures: 11 judges, the vote 6-5; 418 standard acres declared surplus; 44 State Acts added to the Ninth Schedule by the Seventeenth Amendment; 16 years from Shankari Prasad to Golaknath; 6 years and 2 months as the law; Kesavananda overruled it 7-6 with 13 judges.
The Golaknath case by the numbers

The Case: A Punjab Family, a Land Law and the Ninth Schedule

How a surplus-land order became a question about the Constitution itself.

From land order to constitutional case. 1953: Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act; Henry Golak Nath dies on 30 July. 22 January 1962: Financial Commissioner declares 418 standard acres and 9 1/4 units surplus. 20 June 1964: Seventeenth Amendment puts the Punjab Act in the Ninth Schedule. 30 October 1964: Sajjan Singh upholds that amendment. 1966: Writ Petitions 153, 202 and 205 filed. 27 February 1967: judgment, 6-5, petitions dismissed.
From a land order to an 11-judge Bench

The Golak Nath family held more than 500 acres of farmland in the Jullundur area of Punjab. The Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act, 1953 capped the land an owner could keep for personal cultivation and let the State declare the rest surplus for resettling tenants. Henry Golak Nath died on 30 July 1953. On 22 January 1962, in revision proceedings, the Financial Commissioner held that 418 standard acres and 9¼ units in the hands of his son, daughter and granddaughters were surplus.

An ordinary challenge would have argued that the Act violated the rights to equality, property and occupation under Articles 14, 19(1)(f) and 19(1)(g). But in 1964 the Seventeenth Amendment had added the Punjab Act, along with 43 other State land laws, to the Ninth Schedule, which made it immune to such challenges. The only way through was to argue that Parliament never had the power to make the Seventeenth Amendment. That meant asking the Court to overrule Shankari Prasad and Sajjan Singh, both of which said Parliament could amend Fundamental Rights.

The family filed Writ Petition 153 of 1966 under Article 32. Two further petitions challenged the Mysore Land Reforms Act, 1962. The Court constituted a Special Bench of 11 judges, heard the State governments and more than 20 interveners, and delivered judgment on 27 February 1967.

What the Golaknath Judgment Actually Decided

Six votes for the restriction, five against, and two different routes within the six.

How the 11 judges divided. Majority, Subba Rao opinion: Chief Justice K. Subba Rao, J.C. Shah, S.M. Sikri, J.M. Shelat, C.A. Vaidialingam. Concurring: M. Hidayatullah. Dissent: K.N. Wanchoo, Vishishtha Bhargava and G.K. Mitter jointly; R.S. Bachawat; V. Ramaswami.
The 6-5 split
Constitutional questionGolaknath ruling
Can Parliament amend Fundamental Rights?Not so as to take away or abridge them
Is an amendment ‘law’ under Article 13(2)?Yes (all six in the majority)
Does Article 368 give the power or only the procedure?Only the procedure (Subba Rao’s five); Hidayatullah held the power sui generis
Were Shankari Prasad and Sajjan Singh right?No; overruled on whether an amendment is ‘law’
Were earlier amendments invalidated?No; prospective overruling (five) or long acquiescence (Hidayatullah)
Were the Punjab and Mysore laws struck down?No; the petitions were dismissed
Can the basic structure be changed?Left open expressly; the majority found it unnecessary to decide

Chief Justice Subba Rao described Fundamental Rights as ‘primordial rights necessary for the development of human personality’, given ‘a transcendental position’ and kept beyond the reach of Parliament. He read the heading of Article 368, ‘Procedure for amendment of the Constitution’, literally: the Article set out how to amend, not the power to do so, which he traced to Parliament’s residuary legislative power. An amendment was therefore a law like any other, and Article 13(2) applied to it. In an obiter remark, his opinion suggested that if Fundamental Rights ever had to be abridged, Parliament could use its residuary power to convene a constituent assembly.

Justice Hidayatullah got to the same holding by a different path. He rejected the idea that Article 368 was a self-contained code, held that ‘the State’ in Article 13(2) bound Parliament even when amending, and warned that the protection of Fundamental Rights was needed ‘so that we may not walk in fear of democracy itself’. The five dissenters held that Article 368 carried both power and procedure, and that an amendment is a constituent act, not ‘law’.

Inside the Golaknath majority. Subba Rao and four others: an amendment is law under Article 13(2); Article 368 gives only the procedure, the power comes from Article 248; old amendments saved by prospective overruling; Seventeenth Amendment left intact. Hidayatullah: an amendment is law under Article 13(2); the amending power is sui generis; old amendments saved by long acquiescence; the Seventeenth Amendment’s addition of 44 Acts to the Ninth Schedule invalid; land laws stand under Article 31A.
Same result, different reasoning

Prospective Overruling: How the Court Changed the Rule Without Undoing the Past

A device from American case law, used in India for the first time.

Prospective overruling in Golaknath. Before 27 February 1967: the First (1951), Fourth (1955) and Seventeenth (1964) Amendments, and land reforms made under them, remain valid. After 27 February 1967: Parliament has no power to amend Part III so as to take away or abridge Fundamental Rights. Hidayatullah reached the same result through long acquiescence; the five dissenters rejected the doctrine.
Old amendments kept, future ones barred

Subba Rao’s opinion accepted that the First, Fourth and Seventeenth Amendments had abridged Fundamental Rights. Striking them down would have unravelled 16 years of zamindari abolition and land reform. Citing the ‘chaotic situation that may be brought about by the sudden withdrawal at this stage of the amendments’, he applied the doctrine of prospective overruling, which he drew from decisions such as Great Northern Railway v. Sunburst Oil (1932). The Court declared that its decision would not affect the validity of the Seventeenth Amendment or other amendments already made, and that ‘in future Parliament will have no power to amend Part III’ so as to take away or abridge Fundamental Rights.

Two limits were attached: the doctrine could be used only in constitutional matters, and only by the Supreme Court. The dissenters rejected it altogether, holding to the traditional view that a court declares what the law has always been. Hidayatullah did not adopt it either; he held the old amendments safe because they had been accepted for so long. Kesavananda later made the point moot by overruling Golaknath, but the Supreme Court has used prospective overruling in other cases since.

Golaknath Case Timeline, 1949 to 2026

Newest first. Each entry is tagged by type.

Constitution-makingAmendmentSupreme CourtThe Golaknath caseBasic structure era

Where the law stands now Basic structure era

Golaknath overruled in 1973Basic structure is the test

The rule today: Parliament can amend any part of the Constitution under Article 368, Fundamental Rights included. An amendment is not ‘law’ under Article 13, so it is not void merely because it takes away or abridges a right. But it cannot damage or destroy the basic structure of the Constitution, and courts decide what that structure contains.

What survives of Golaknath: Its central holding does not. Its concerns do: that Fundamental Rights need protection from the ordinary politics of a two-thirds majority, and that a court can change a constitutional rule without unsettling the past. Prospective overruling, first used in India in this case, is still part of the Supreme Court’s toolkit.

The Golaknath judgment was the law for six years and two months, from 27 February 1967 to 24 April 1973.
16 Oct 2015

NJAC ruling: an amendment ratified by the States still falls Basic structure era

Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of IndiaFive judges, 4-1

What happened: The Court struck down the Constitution (Ninety-ninth Amendment) Act, 2014 and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014, holding that the new commission undermined the independence of the judiciary, a basic feature.

Why it matters here: It shows how far the argument has moved since 1967. Golaknath asked whether a right in Part III could be touched at all. The NJAC case did not involve Part III; it tested an amendment to the judges’ appointment process against an unwritten structural principle.

Justice J. Chelameswar dissented, holding that the commission was a valid choice for Parliament to make.
11 Jan 2007

I.R. Coelho: no blanket shield for the Ninth Schedule Basic structure era

Nine judges, headed by Chief Justice Y.K. SabharwalUnanimous

What happened: The Court held that laws added to the Ninth Schedule on or after 24 April 1973 can be tested against Fundamental Rights, and struck down if their effect damages the basic structure.

The Golaknath link: The Ninth Schedule, created in 1951 and enlarged in 1964, was the device at the centre of the Golaknath dispute. Coelho settled what protection it still gives: full for laws added before Kesavananda, conditional after.

The Punjab and Mysore land laws challenged in Golaknath were added in 1964, so they fall on the protected side of the 1973 line.
31 Jul 1980

Minerva Mills: limited amending power is itself basic Supreme Court

Minerva Mills Ltd. v. Union of IndiaFive judges, Chief Justice Y.V. Chandrachud; reasons for the order of 9 May 1980

What fell: Section 55 of the Forty-second Amendment, which had added clauses (4) and (5) to Article 368 to bar courts from questioning amendments and to declare Parliament’s amending power unlimited.

Why it matters: Parliament’s last attempt to restore the pre-1967 position, with no limits at all, failed. The Court held that a limited amending power and judicial review are themselves part of the basic structure.

Chief Justice Chandrachud wrote that Parliament cannot, under Article 368, expand its amending power so as to acquire the right to repeal or abrogate the Constitution.
18 Dec 1976

Forty-second Amendment tries to end the argument Amendment

Constitution (Forty-second Amendment) Act, 1976Passed during the Emergency

What it did: Among many other changes, it inserted clause (4) into Article 368, saying no amendment ‘shall be called in question in any court on any ground’, and clause (5), declaring that there is ‘no limitation whatever’ on Parliament’s constituent power.

Why it mattered: It was a direct answer to both Golaknath and Kesavananda. Had it survived, the question of limits on the amending power would have been closed by the amending power itself.

The Forty-fourth Amendment of 1978 reversed many Emergency-era changes but left these two clauses, which the Court struck down in 1980.
24 Apr 1973

Kesavananda Bharati overrules Golaknath Supreme Court

Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala13 judges, Chief Justice S.M. Sikri; 7-6

What happened: The largest Bench in the Court’s history held that Parliament can amend any provision of the Constitution, including Fundamental Rights, but cannot alter its basic structure. It upheld the Twenty-fourth Amendment and so overruled Golaknath’s holding that an amendment is ‘law’ under Article 13(2).

Why it matters: The Court rejected both extremes: Golaknath’s absolute bar on touching Part III and the government’s claim of unlimited power. It also upheld the Twenty-ninth Amendment and struck down the part of Article 31C that barred courts from asking whether a law actually gave effect to the Directive Principles.

Chief Justice Sikri had been one of the five judges in Subba Rao’s Golaknath majority; in 1973 he led the Bench that replaced it.
9 Jun 1972

Twenty-ninth Amendment protects Kerala’s land laws Amendment

Constitution (Twenty-ninth Amendment) Act, 1972Ninth Schedule enlarged

What it did: It placed the Kerala Land Reforms (Amendment) Acts of 1969 and 1971 in the Ninth Schedule, shielding them from challenge on the ground that they violated Fundamental Rights.

Why it mattered: It used exactly the device Golaknath had restricted. With the Twenty-fourth Amendment in place, the government could argue that Golaknath no longer stood in the way, and Kesavananda Bharati’s petition became the vehicle for testing that claim.

Kesavananda Bharati, head of the Edneer Mutt in Kasaragod, had filed his petition in 1970 against Kerala’s land reform laws.
20 Apr 1972

Twenty-fifth Amendment adds Article 31C Amendment

Constitution (Twenty-fifth Amendment) Act, 1971Passed 1 and 8 December 1971; assent 20 April 1972

What it did: It replaced ‘compensation’ in Article 31(2) with ‘amount’, and inserted Article 31C, protecting laws giving effect to Article 39(b) and (c) from challenge under Articles 14, 19 and 31. A declaration in such a law that it gave effect to those principles could not be questioned in court.

Why it mattered: Together with the Twenty-fourth, it was Parliament’s attempt to put property-related economic policy beyond the reach of the Golaknath approach. Kesavananda later struck down the declaration clause.

The Bill was introduced on the same day as the Twenty-fourth Amendment Bill, 28 July 1971, but received assent five and a half months later.
5 Nov 1971

Twenty-fourth Amendment reverses Golaknath Amendment

Constitution (Twenty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1971Lok Sabha 4 August, Rajya Sabha 11 August; assent 5 November 1971

What it did: It added clause (4) to Article 13, saying nothing in that Article applies to an amendment made under Article 368. It retitled Article 368 ‘Power of Parliament to amend the Constitution and procedure therefor’, declared that Parliament may amend any provision ‘by way of addition, variation or repeal’ in exercise of its constituent power, and made the President’s assent to an amendment Bill compulsory.

Why it mattered: It answered each part of Golaknath in turn: the majority view that Article 368 gave only a procedure, that an amendment is ‘law’, and that Part III was beyond reach. It was ratified by more than half the State Legislatures.

The Statement of Objects and Reasons named the case: the Supreme Court ‘in the well-known Golak Nath’s case reversed, by a narrow majority, its own earlier decisions’.
28 Jul 1971

Law Minister H.R. Gokhale introduces the Twenty-fourth Amendment Bill Amendment

Bill No. 105 of 1971Lok Sabha

What happened: Months after winning a two-thirds majority in the March 1971 general election, the government introduced the Bill to restore Parliament’s power to amend Fundamental Rights. The Twenty-fifth Amendment Bill was introduced the same day.

The background: By 1971 the Court had also struck down bank nationalisation (R.C. Cooper, 1970) and the derecognition of the princes (Madhav Rao Scindia, 1970). Golaknath was now part of a wider conflict between the government and the Court over property and economic reform.

Some accounts date the Bill’s introduction to 22 July 1971; the parliamentary record gives 28 July.
21 Mar 1970

Kesavananda Bharati files the petition that will reopen Golaknath The Golaknath case

W.P. 135 of 1970Challenge to Kerala land reform laws

What happened: The head of the Edneer Mutt challenged Kerala’s land reform legislation under Article 32. As Parliament passed the Twenty-fourth, Twenty-fifth and Twenty-ninth Amendments, the petition grew into a challenge to all three.

Why a 13-judge Bench: Testing those amendments meant reconsidering Golaknath, an 11-judge ruling. Only a larger Bench could overrule it, so the Court assembled 13 judges.

Nani Palkhivala argued for the petitioners over five months of hearings from October 1972 to March 1973.
11 Apr 1967

Chief Justice Subba Rao resigns to run for President The Golaknath case

Six weeks after the judgmentPresidential election, 6 May 1967

What happened: Koka Subba Rao, who had led the majority, left office on 11 April 1967 to contest the presidential election as the opposition parties’ consensus candidate. On 6 May he lost to Zakir Husain, who received 471,244 electoral votes to his 363,971.

Why it mattered: His departure fed the political reading of the judgment. To the government’s supporters, Golaknath looked less like legal interpretation and more like a stand against Parliament; to its defenders, it was an act of judicial courage. K.N. Wanchoo, who had led the dissent, succeeded him as Chief Justice.

Subba Rao had served as Chief Justice for less than a year, from 30 June 1966.
27 Feb 1967

Golaknath decided: Fundamental Rights beyond the amending power The Golaknath case

I.C. Golaknath v. State of Punjab, AIR 1967 SC 1643, (1967) 2 SCR 76211 judges, 6-5

The majority: Chief Justice Subba Rao, writing for himself and Justices J.C. Shah, S.M. Sikri, J.M. Shelat and C.A. Vaidialingam, held that Parliament cannot amend Part III so as to take away or abridge Fundamental Rights. An amendment is ‘law’ under Article 13(2), so an amendment that abridges a right is void. Justice M. Hidayatullah agreed on both points in a separate opinion, making six.

Where the power comes from: Subba Rao’s five held that Article 368 set out only the procedure for amendment; the power itself came from Parliament’s residuary legislative power under Article 248 and Entry 97 of List I. Hidayatullah disagreed, calling the amending power sui generis.

The result: The petitions were dismissed. The Punjab and Mysore land laws stayed in force, and so did the Seventeenth Amendment that protected them.

Shankari Prasad (1951) and Sajjan Singh (1964) were expressly overruled on the question of whether an amendment is ‘law’.
27 Feb 1967

Prospective overruling: the past preserved, the future barred Supreme Court

Doctrine borrowed from United States case lawApplied by Subba Rao’s five

What the Court did: Having found that earlier amendments abridged Fundamental Rights, Subba Rao’s opinion declined to strike them down. It declared that the decision would not affect the validity of the Seventeenth Amendment or other amendments already made, and that ‘in future Parliament will have no power to amend Part III’ so as to take away or abridge Fundamental Rights.

Hidayatullah’s different route: Hidayatullah did not rest on prospective overruling. He held that the First and Fourth Amendments, among others, could not now be challenged because of long acquiescence, and that the two land laws were valid under Article 31A and the President’s assent. He would have held invalid the part of the Seventeenth Amendment that added 44 State Acts to the Ninth Schedule.

The dissenting judges rejected prospective overruling, holding that courts declare what the law always was.
27 Feb 1967

Five judges dissent: Article 368 can reach any part Supreme Court

Justices K.N. Wanchoo, Vishishtha Bhargava and G.K. Mitter (jointly); R.S. Bachawat; V. RamaswamiMinority

The dissent: Article 368 contains both the power and the procedure to amend every part of the Constitution, including Part III. An amendment is a constituent act, not ‘law’ for the purposes of Article 13(2). Shankari Prasad and Sajjan Singh were correctly decided and should stand.

Why it matters: The dissent became the law four years later, when Parliament wrote its central points into the Twenty-fourth Amendment, and Kesavananda upheld that amendment in 1973.

A one-judge swing would have reversed the outcome: six judges for the restriction, five against.

Three writ petitions reach an 11-judge Special Bench The Golaknath case

Writ Petitions 153, 202 and 205 of 1966Under Article 32

Who came to court: Writ Petition 153 was filed by the son, daughter and granddaughters of Henry Golak Nath against the State of Punjab and its Financial Commissioner. The other two challenged the Mysore Land Reforms Act, 1962, as amended in 1965. Because both laws were in the Ninth Schedule, the petitioners had to attack the Seventeenth Amendment, and with it the rulings in Shankari Prasad and Sajjan Singh.

The questions: Whether a constitutional amendment is ‘law’ under Article 13(2); whether Article 368 confers the power to amend or only lays down the procedure; and whether Fundamental Rights can be taken away or abridged at all. The Court formed a Special Bench of 11 judges because only a larger Bench could reconsider the earlier five-judge decisions.

More than 20 interveners joined the hearing, including several State governments.
30 Oct 1964

Sajjan Singh upholds the Seventeenth Amendment, with two doubters Supreme Court

Sajjan Singh v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1965 SC 845Five judges, Chief Justice P.B. Gajendragadkar

The holding: The majority followed Shankari Prasad: Article 368 allows Parliament to amend Fundamental Rights, and an amendment is not ‘law’ under Article 13(2). The Seventeenth Amendment was valid.

The doubts: Justices M. Hidayatullah and J.R. Mudholkar agreed with the result but questioned whether Fundamental Rights could be the plaything of a special majority. Mudholkar asked whether changing a ‘basic feature’ of the Constitution would be an amendment at all, the idea that Kesavananda later took up.

Often dated 1965 from its law report; the judgment was delivered on 30 October 1964.
20 Jun 1964

Seventeenth Amendment shields the Punjab and Mysore laws Amendment

Constitution (Seventeenth Amendment) Act, 1964Ninth Schedule enlarged by 44 Acts

What it did: It widened the meaning of ‘estate’ in Article 31A to cover ryotwari and other agricultural land, and added 44 State land laws to the Ninth Schedule, including the Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act, 1953 and the Mysore Land Reforms Act, 1962.

Why it mattered: It is the amendment the Golaknath petitioners attacked. If it was valid, their challenge to the Punjab Act on Fundamental Rights grounds could not succeed. To win, they had to persuade the Court that Parliament had no power to make it.

A new proviso to Article 31A required market-value compensation when the State acquired land within the ceiling that an owner cultivated personally.
22 Jan 1962

418 standard acres declared surplus The Golaknath case

Financial Commissioner, PunjabJullundur Division

What happened: In revision against an order of the Additional Commissioner, Jullundur Division, the Financial Commissioner held that 418 standard acres and 9¼ units in the hands of the Golak Nath family were surplus under the Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act, 1953, read with Section 10-B.

Why it mattered: Surplus land could be used to resettle tenants. The family argued that the Act violated Articles 14, 19(1)(f) and 19(1)(g), which protected equality, property and occupation at the time.

Henry Golak Nath, whose family’s holdings were in issue, had died on 30 July 1953. The order came more than eight years after the Act.
27 Apr 1955

Fourth Amendment widens Article 31A Amendment

Constitution (Fourth Amendment) Act, 1955Property rights

What it did: It made the adequacy of compensation for acquired property non-justiciable, extended Article 31A to further categories of law and added more Acts to the Ninth Schedule.

Why it mattered: Each round of land and property litigation drew a constitutional amendment in reply. Hidayatullah’s opinion in Golaknath counted it among the amendments that could no longer be challenged because of long acquiescence.

It was the second of what became a long series of amendments to the right to property, which was finally removed from Part III in 1978.

Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act The Golaknath case

Punjab Act X of 1953Ceilings and tenant protection

What it did: The Act limited how much land an owner could reserve for personal cultivation, protected tenants from eviction and allowed land above the permissible limit to be declared surplus for resettling tenants.

The family: The Golak Nath family held more than 500 acres of farmland in the Jullundur area. The law left them a fraction for personal cultivation and the rest could be declared surplus, which set the long dispute in motion.

The same year, on 30 July 1953, Henry Golak Nath died.
5 Oct 1951

Shankari Prasad: an amendment is not ‘law’ Supreme Court

Sri Sankari Prasad Singh Deo v. Union of India, AIR 1951 SC 458Five judges, Chief Justice H.J. Kania; unanimous

The holding: The First Amendment was valid. ‘Law’ in Article 13(2) means ordinary legislation, not an amendment made in exercise of constituent power under Article 368. Parliament could therefore amend Fundamental Rights.

Why it matters: This was the interpretation Golaknath overturned 16 years later, and which the Twenty-fourth Amendment then wrote into the text.

The challenge came from zamindars in Bihar, Uttar Pradesh and Madhya Pradesh whose estates were being abolished.
18 Jun 1951

First Amendment creates the Ninth Schedule Amendment

Constitution (First Amendment) Act, 1951Articles 31A and 31B added

What it did: It inserted Article 31A, protecting laws for the acquisition of estates, and Article 31B with the Ninth Schedule, protecting the Acts listed in it from challenge on the ground of inconsistency with Fundamental Rights. It also rewrote Article 19(2) on restrictions on speech.

Why it mattered: The Ninth Schedule began with 13 Acts, mostly zamindari abolition laws. It became the instrument at the heart of Golaknath, Kesavananda and I.R. Coelho.

The amendment was passed by the Provisional Parliament, which was also the Constituent Assembly sitting in a legislative role.
26 Jan 1950

Constitution in force: Fundamental Rights, Directive Principles and property Constitution-making

Part III and Part IVArticles 19(1)(f) and 31

What it set up: Part III guaranteed enforceable Fundamental Rights, including the right to acquire, hold and dispose of property under Article 19(1)(f) and protection against deprivation of property without authority of law under Article 31. Part IV listed Directive Principles, including fair distribution of material resources, which courts could not enforce.

The tension: Land reform depended on taking land from large owners; property rights protected those owners. Every amendment and judgment in this timeline is part of the argument over which should prevail.

The right to property was removed from Part III by the Forty-fourth Amendment in 1978 and now sits in Article 300A.
26 Nov 1949

Articles 13 and 368 adopted Constitution-making

Constituent AssemblyThe text Golaknath turned on

The two provisions: Article 13(2) says the State shall not make any law that takes away or abridges the rights conferred by Part III, and that any law in contravention is void. Article 368, headed ‘Procedure for amendment of the Constitution’, required a Bill passed by a majority of each House’s total membership and two-thirds of members present and voting.

The unanswered question: Neither Article said whether an amendment under Article 368 was a ‘law’ under Article 13(2). For 18 years that silence decided whether Fundamental Rights could be amended.

Subba Rao relied on the heading of Article 368, which mentioned only procedure; the Twenty-fourth Amendment changed it to ‘Power of Parliament to amend the Constitution and procedure therefor’.

Parliament Responds: The 1971 Amendments

Each ruling drew an amendment; each amendment drew a ruling.

Court and Parliament, 1951 to 1980. 1951: First Amendment, upheld in Shankari Prasad. 1964: Seventeenth Amendment, upheld in Sajjan Singh. 1967: Golaknath bars amendments that abridge Fundamental Rights. 1971: Twenty-fourth Amendment restores the power. 1973: Kesavananda upholds it, adds the basic structure limit. 1976: Forty-second Amendment claims unlimited power. 1980: Minerva Mills strikes that down.
Five rounds between the Court and Parliament

Golaknath did not stop land reform; it stopped Parliament from removing the next obstacle by amendment. That mattered more after 1969, when the Court struck down bank nationalisation in R.C. Cooper and the derecognition of the princes in Madhav Rao Scindia, both in 1970. After winning a two-thirds majority in March 1971, the government moved quickly. Law Minister H.R. Gokhale introduced the Twenty-fourth Amendment Bill on 28 July 1971; its Statement of Objects and Reasons said Golaknath had reversed the earlier rulings ‘by a narrow majority’ and that Parliament had to be able to amend Fundamental Rights.

The Act, which received assent on 5 November 1971, answered each element of the judgment. A new Article 13(4) said nothing in Article 13 applies to an amendment under Article 368. Article 368 was retitled to speak of Parliament’s ‘power’, not just procedure, and its new clause (1) confirmed that Parliament could amend any provision ‘by way of addition, variation or repeal’. The President was required to assent to amendment Bills. The Twenty-fifth Amendment (assent 20 April 1972) added Article 31C, and the Twenty-ninth (9 June 1972) put Kerala’s land laws in the Ninth Schedule. All three came before the 13-judge Bench in Kesavananda Bharati.

Golaknath vs Kesavananda Bharati: What Changed?

From protecting a list of rights to protecting the Constitution’s identity.

Golaknath 1967 versus Kesavananda Bharati 1973. Bench: 11 judges versus 13. Majority: 6-5 versus 7-6. Is an amendment law under Article 13(2)? Yes versus no. Can Parliament amend Fundamental Rights? Not to abridge them versus yes. The limit: Part III untouchable versus the basic structure. Status: overruled versus governing law.
Golaknath vs Kesavananda Bharati
IssueGolaknath (1967)Kesavananda Bharati (1973)
Bench11 judges, CJ K. Subba Rao13 judges, CJ S.M. Sikri
Majority6-57-6
Is an amendment ‘law’ under Article 13(2)?YesNo (24th Amendment upheld)
Power over Fundamental RightsCannot take away or abridge themCan amend them
The limitPart III as a wholeThe basic structure
Earlier amendmentsSaved by prospective overruling24th and 29th upheld; part of 31C struck down
Status in 2026OverruledGoverning law

The two judgments are often presented as opposites, but they share more than it seems. Both held that the amending power has limits that courts enforce. Golaknath located the limit in the text, Article 13(2), and drew it around the whole of Part III; that was simple but rigid, and Parliament removed it with a single amendment. Kesavananda located the limit in the Constitution’s structure, where no amendment could reach it, but left judges to decide case by case what that structure contains. Some Fundamental Rights, such as equality and the core of personal liberty, have since been treated as part of it; the right to property, the subject of Golaknath itself, was removed from Part III in 1978.

Key People and Institutions

NameRole
Henry Golak NathPunjab landowner (died 30 July 1953) whose son, daughter and granddaughters filed Writ Petition 153 of 1966
Chief Justice K. Subba RaoLed the 11-judge Bench and wrote the majority opinion; resigned on 11 April 1967 to run for President
Justice M. HidayatullahSixth majority vote, in a separate opinion; had voiced doubts in Sajjan Singh
Justice K.N. WanchooLed the dissent; succeeded Subba Rao as Chief Justice
Justice J.R. MudholkarIn Sajjan Singh (1964), asked whether changing a ‘basic feature’ was amendment at all
Justice S.M. SikriIn the Golaknath majority; as Chief Justice, led the Kesavananda Bench that overruled it
H.R. GokhaleLaw Minister who introduced the Twenty-fourth and Twenty-fifth Amendment Bills on 28 July 1971
Nani A. PalkhivalaLead counsel for the petitioners in Kesavananda Bharati
Parliament of IndiaPassed the First, Fourth, Seventeenth, Twenty-fourth, Twenty-fifth, Twenty-ninth and Forty-second Amendments

Conclusion: From Golaknath to Basic Structure

Golaknath was a narrow judgment in two senses: it was decided by one vote, and it gave the petitioners nothing. Yet it changed the terms of Indian constitutional law. It was the first time the Supreme Court said that a two-thirds majority in Parliament was not enough to remove a Fundamental Right, and it found a way to say so without undoing the land reforms of the previous 16 years.

Its specific rule lasted six years. Parliament wrote the dissent into the Constitution in 1971, and Kesavananda Bharati accepted that amendment in 1973 while setting a different and more durable limit. The result is neither the unlimited power Parliament claimed nor the absolute protection Golaknath offered, but a system in which the Constitution can change without ceasing to be itself.

Explore More Timelines

People Also Ask

What is the Golaknath case?
I.C. Golaknath v. State of Punjab is the Supreme Court judgment of 27 February 1967 in which an 11-judge Bench held, by 6-5, that Parliament cannot amend the Constitution so as to take away or abridge Fundamental Rights, and that a constitutional amendment is 'law' under Article 13(2). It was overruled by Kesavananda Bharati in 1973.
What was the main issue in the Golaknath case?
Whether Parliament's power under Article 368 extends to Fundamental Rights. That depended on whether an amendment is 'law' within Article 13(2), which voids any law that takes away or abridges a Part III right, and on whether Article 368 gives the power to amend or only the procedure.
Why is the Golaknath case important?
It was the first time the Supreme Court held that Parliament's amending power had limits. It introduced prospective overruling in India, provoked the Twenty-fourth Amendment of 1971, and set up the confrontation that produced the basic structure doctrine in Kesavananda Bharati.
Was the Golaknath judgment overruled?
Yes. In Kesavananda Bharati v. State of Kerala on 24 April 1973, a 13-judge Bench upheld the Twenty-fourth Amendment and held that Parliament can amend Fundamental Rights. It replaced Golaknath's absolute bar with a narrower limit: no amendment can damage the basic structure of the Constitution.
Who won the Golaknath case?
In a practical sense, the State. The petitions were dismissed and the Punjab and Mysore land laws stayed in force, because the majority applied prospective overruling and left existing amendments untouched. The petitioners won the constitutional argument for the future, not relief for themselves.
What is prospective overruling?
A court announces that an earlier rule was wrong but applies the new rule only to the future, leaving past actions taken under the old rule valid. Chief Justice Subba Rao borrowed it from American case law in Golaknath so that the First, Fourth and Seventeenth Amendments would survive.

Frequently Asked Questions

Based on the 1967 judgment, the amendment Acts and later Supreme Court rulings.

When was the Golaknath case decided?
On 27 February 1967. It is reported as AIR 1967 SC 1643 and (1967) 2 SCR 762.
How many judges heard the Golaknath case?
Eleven. It was led by Chief Justice K. Subba Rao and was formed because only a larger Bench could reconsider the five-judge rulings in Shankari Prasad and Sajjan Singh.
What was the majority in Golaknath?
Six to five. Chief Justice Subba Rao wrote for himself and Justices J.C. Shah, S.M. Sikri, J.M. Shelat and C.A. Vaidialingam. Justice M. Hidayatullah concurred separately on the main holdings, making the sixth vote.
Which judges dissented in Golaknath?
Justices K.N. Wanchoo, Vishishtha Bhargava and G.K. Mitter in a joint opinion, and Justices R.S. Bachawat and V. Ramaswami separately. All five held that Article 368 allows Parliament to amend any part of the Constitution, including Part III.
Who were the petitioners in Golaknath?
In Writ Petition 153 of 1966, the son, daughter and granddaughters of Henry Golak Nath, a Punjab landowner who died on 30 July 1953. Two connected petitions challenged the Mysore Land Reforms Act, 1962.
What land was involved in the Golaknath case?
By an order of 22 January 1962, Punjab's Financial Commissioner declared 418 standard acres and 9 1/4 units in the family's hands surplus under the Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act, 1953. The family held more than 500 acres in the Jullundur area.
Which law was challenged in Golaknath?
The Punjab Security of Land Tenures Act, 1953 and the Mysore Land Reforms Act, 1962, as amended in 1965. Because both were in the Ninth Schedule, the petitioners also challenged the Seventeenth Amendment, which had put them there.
What did the Golaknath judgment say about Article 13(2)?
That a constitutional amendment is 'law' within Article 13(2). Since that clause voids any law that takes away or abridges Fundamental Rights, an amendment doing so would also be void.
What did Golaknath say about Article 368?
Subba Rao's five judges held that Article 368 contained only the procedure for amendment, and that the power came from Parliament's residuary legislative power under Article 248 and Entry 97 of List I. Hidayatullah disagreed on this point, calling the power sui generis.
Did Golaknath strike down any constitutional amendment?
No. Applying prospective overruling, the majority declared that its decision would not affect the Seventeenth Amendment or other amendments already made. Parliament was barred only from abridging Fundamental Rights in future amendments.
Did Justice Hidayatullah agree with prospective overruling?
He reached the same practical result by another route. He held that the earlier amendments could not be challenged after long acquiescence and that the land laws were valid under Article 31A and the President's assent, though he would have struck down the Seventeenth Amendment's addition of 44 Acts to the Ninth Schedule.
What did Shankari Prasad decide?
On 5 October 1951, a unanimous five-judge Bench upheld the First Amendment and held that 'law' in Article 13(2) means ordinary legislation, not an amendment under Article 368. Golaknath overruled this view; the Twenty-fourth Amendment restored it.
What did Sajjan Singh decide?
On 30 October 1964, a five-judge Bench led by Chief Justice P.B. Gajendragadkar upheld the Seventeenth Amendment, following Shankari Prasad. Justices Hidayatullah and Mudholkar agreed with the result but doubted that Fundamental Rights could be amended without limit.
What was the Seventeenth Amendment?
The Constitution (Seventeenth Amendment) Act, 1964 widened the definition of 'estate' in Article 31A and added 44 State land laws to the Ninth Schedule, including the Punjab and Mysore Acts challenged in Golaknath.
What is the Ninth Schedule?
A list created by the First Amendment in 1951. Under Article 31B, Acts placed in it cannot be held void for violating Fundamental Rights. Since I.R. Coelho (2007), laws added on or after 24 April 1973 can still be tested against the basic structure.
How did Parliament respond to Golaknath?
With the Constitution (Twenty-fourth Amendment) Act, 1971. It declared that Article 13 does not apply to amendments, confirmed that Article 368 gives Parliament the power to amend any provision, and made the President's assent to amendment Bills compulsory.
When was the Twenty-fourth Amendment passed?
The Bill was introduced in the Lok Sabha on 28 July 1971 by Law Minister H.R. Gokhale, passed by the Lok Sabha on 4 August and the Rajya Sabha on 11 August, and received President V.V. Giri's assent on 5 November 1971.
What did the Twenty-fifth Amendment do?
It replaced 'compensation' in Article 31(2) with 'amount' and added Article 31C to protect laws implementing Article 39(b) and (c). It was passed in December 1971 and received assent on 20 April 1972, not in November 1971 as is sometimes stated.
Why did the Golaknath case take place under Article 32?
Article 32 lets a person go directly to the Supreme Court to enforce Fundamental Rights. The family argued that the Punjab Act violated Articles 14, 19(1)(f) and 19(1)(g), so they petitioned the Supreme Court directly.
What happened to Chief Justice Subba Rao after Golaknath?
He resigned on 11 April 1967 to contest the presidential election as the opposition's consensus candidate, and lost to Zakir Husain on 6 May 1967. Justice K.N. Wanchoo, who led the dissent, succeeded him.
How did Kesavananda Bharati change Golaknath?
It overruled Golaknath's holding that an amendment is 'law' under Article 13(2) and upheld the Twenty-fourth Amendment. Parliament could again amend Fundamental Rights, but no amendment could alter the Constitution's basic structure.
What was the vote in Kesavananda Bharati?
Seven to six, on a 13-judge Bench led by Chief Justice S.M. Sikri, on 24 April 1973. Sikri had been part of the Golaknath majority six years earlier.
Is the Golaknath judgment still good law?
Not on its main point. Since 1973 Parliament may amend Fundamental Rights, subject to the basic structure. Golaknath remains important history and the first Indian use of prospective overruling.
Did Golaknath create the basic structure doctrine?
No. The doctrine came from Kesavananda Bharati in 1973. Golaknath's majority expressly left open whether the amending power could change the Constitution's fundamental structure, an idea Justice Mudholkar had raised in Sajjan Singh.
What did the Forty-second Amendment do to Article 368?
Enacted on 18 December 1976, it added clause (4), barring courts from questioning any amendment, and clause (5), declaring no limit on Parliament's constituent power. Minerva Mills struck both down in 1980.
What did Minerva Mills decide?
On 31 July 1980, giving reasons for its order of 9 May, a five-judge Bench led by Chief Justice Y.V. Chandrachud held that a limited amending power and judicial review are part of the basic structure, and struck down Article 368(4) and (5).
Is the right to property still a Fundamental Right?
No. The Forty-fourth Amendment of 1978 deleted Article 19(1)(f) and Article 31 from Part III and created Article 300A, a constitutional right that property can be taken only by authority of law.
What is the difference between Golaknath and Kesavananda?
Golaknath (11 judges, 6-5) barred any amendment that abridged Fundamental Rights. Kesavananda (13 judges, 7-6) allowed amendments to Fundamental Rights but barred those that damage the basic structure. Golaknath protected a list of rights; Kesavananda protects the Constitution's essential features.
What was the 'Golaknath' spelling?
The judgment's cause title spells it Golaknath, while the opinions and the Twenty-fourth Amendment's statement of reasons use Golak Nath. Both refer to the same family and case.
Has the NJAC case anything to do with Golaknath?
Indirectly. In 2015 the Court struck down the Ninety-ninth Amendment using the basic structure doctrine, the limit that replaced Golaknath's. It shows how the question has shifted from protecting Part III to protecting structural principles such as judicial independence.

⚠️ Editorial Note: What We Checked

We checked the brief we started from against the full text of the 1967 judgment and its headnote, the Twenty-fourth Amendment Act and its Statement of Objects and Reasons, and the judgments in Shankari Prasad, Sajjan Singh, Kesavananda Bharati and Minerva Mills. The Twenty-fourth Amendment Bill was introduced on 28 July 1971, not 22 July. The Twenty-fifth Amendment received assent on 20 April 1972, not 5 November 1971. Prospective overruling was applied by Chief Justice Subba Rao’s five-judge opinion; Justice Hidayatullah relied on long acquiescence and Article 31A, and would have held invalid the Seventeenth Amendment’s addition of 44 Acts to the Ninth Schedule. The petitioners were Henry Golak Nath’s son, daughter and granddaughters; he had died in 1953. The precise surplus area in the 1962 order was 418 standard acres and 9¼ units. This article explains constitutional history; it is not legal advice.

Related Reading on AiTimeline

ADM Jabalpur Case: Habeas Corpus, Emergency, and Rights in India Tariff Walls and Trade Bridges: The Hidden Forces Reshaping Global Trade
New article
→
Next Article