← AiTimeline Home

Maharashtra · 1972-1983 · Custodial rape, consent and law reform

Mathura Custodial Rape Case: Law, Justice & Reform Timeline

📅 Last updated: 18 November 2026⏱ 19 dated entries✎ By Nazish Fatima

View as Web Story

In short

Explore the Mathura custodial rape case timeline, the 1978 Supreme Court verdict, 1983 rape-law reforms and changes to India's consent laws today.

Latest Story

On the night of 26 March 1972, a young Adivasi woman known as Mathura was kept back at a police station in eastern Maharashtra after her family was told to go home. She said two policemen raped and molested her there. Three courts reached three different conclusions, and the last, a Supreme Court acquittal in 1978, set off India’s first national campaign against rape. This Mathura rape case timeline follows the case from the police station to the 1983 law it forced and the codes that carry that law today.

Read this first: three common errors

The Supreme Court judgment is dated 15 September 1978, not 1979; it is often misdated because it was reported in 1979, and the open letter came a year later. The case did not end in a conviction: both policemen were acquitted and the case was never reopened. And Mathura’s age was never proved: a doctor estimated 14 to 16, but the courts held it was not shown she was under 16.

💡 Short Answer

The Mathura case concerns a young Adivasi woman who said she was raped by two policemen at the Desai Gunj police station, Maharashtra, on 26 March 1972. The Sessions Court acquitted them in 1974, the Bombay High Court convicted them in 1976, and the Supreme Court acquitted them on 15 September 1978. The protests that followed led to the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1983, which created the offence of custodial rape and a presumption of no consent.

⚡ The Case at a Glance
Incident26 March 1972, Desai Gunj police station
AccusedHead Constable Tukaram, Constable Ganpat
Sessions CourtAcquitted, 1 June 1974
Bombay High CourtConvicted, 12 October 1976
Supreme CourtAcquitted, 15 September 1978
Law it led toCriminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1983
⚡ Quick Answers — AI Overview Ready

Mathura Case: Key Questions

Why did the Supreme Court acquit?
It said the absence of injuries showed the intercourse was “a peaceful affair”, that her account of resisting was false, and that under the law then consent was invalid only if obtained by fear of death or hurt, which the High Court had not found.
What changed in 1983?
Rape by police officers and others with custody of a woman became aggravated rape with a 10-year minimum. Courts had to presume no consent in such cases if the woman said so. Rape trials were held in camera, and naming victims became an offence.
Who started the campaign?
Four law teachers, Upendra Baxi, Lotika Sarkar, Raghunath Kelkar and Vasudha Dhagamwar, wrote an open letter to the Chief Justice in September 1979. Women’s groups such as the Forum Against Rape in Bombay took the protest to the streets in 1980.
Where is that law now?
Since 1 July 2024, in the new codes: aggravated custodial rape is BNS Section 64(2), the presumption of no consent is BSA Section 120, identity protection is BNS Section 72, and in-camera trials are BNSS Section 366.
📚 Key Takeaways

The Case in Ten Points

  • The setting: a police station at night, where she had been brought over her brother’s complaint.
  • The accused: two policemen on duty, Head Constable Tukaram and Constable Ganpat.
  • Trial court: acquittal in 1974, relying heavily on her sexual history.
  • High Court: conviction in 1976, holding that passive submission is not consent.
  • Supreme Court: acquittal on 15 September 1978, citing the absence of injuries.
  • The letter: four law teachers challenged the judgment in September 1979.
  • The streets: protests on 8 March 1980 and new autonomous women’s groups.
  • The law: the 1983 Act created custodial rape and a presumption of no consent.
  • The gaps: sexual-history evidence was not barred until 2002 and 2013.
  • The verdict stands: no one was punished, and the case was never reopened.

Three Courts, Three Verdicts, One New Law

The case in four stages, 1974 to 1983.

The Mathura case in four stages: 1 June 1974, the Sessions Court at Chandrapur acquits both policemen; 12 October 1976, the Bombay High Court at Nagpur convicts Ganpat of rape and Tukaram of outraging modesty; 15 September 1978, the Supreme Court acquits both; 25 December 1983, the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act creates custodial rape and a presumption of no consent.
Acquitted, convicted, acquitted, then a new law

The same facts, read three ways. All three courts accepted that she had sexual intercourse at the police station. They disagreed on what it meant: a lie to save face, a rape by men she could not resist, or a consensual act because she bore no injuries.

A law, not a conviction. The 1983 Act did not reopen the case. Its importance lies in what it changed for everyone who came after.

The Night at Desai Gunj

26 and 27 March 1972, from the prosecution case recorded by the Supreme Court.

The night at Desai Gunj police station, 26 to 27 March 1972: about 9 pm, Mathura, her brother, Ashok and his relatives are brought in over a kidnapping complaint; about 10.30 pm, they are told to leave but the two policemen keep her back; that night, Ganpat is alleged to have raped her and Tukaram to have molested her; the lights go off and a crowd gathers; she tells her family Ganpat raped her; the crowd threatens to burn the station; her statement becomes the FIR; 8 pm on 27 March, a doctor finds no injuries and estimates her age at 14 to 16.
From a complaint to an FIR

Why she was there. She had not been accused of anything. Her brother had complained that the man she wanted to marry and his family had kidnapped her, and the police brought everyone in to record statements.

The crowd. Her relatives waited outside. When the station’s lights went off and the door closed, they began shouting. The crowd that gathered threatened to burn the station, and only then was her complaint written down.

The examination. She was examined about 20 hours later. There were no injuries on her body. That one finding would decide the case in the Supreme Court.

Mathura Case Timeline, Newest First

Tagged by phase: the incident, the trial and High Court, the Supreme Court, the campaign, and the law reform that followed.

The incidentTrial and High CourtSupreme CourtCampaignLaw reform

A Chief Justice calls the verdict an embarrassment Law reform

CJI B.R. Gavai30th Justice Sunanda Bhandare Memorial Lecture

What happened: Chief Justice of India B.R. Gavai described the Supreme Court’s judgment in Tukaram v. State of Maharashtra as a “moment of institutional embarrassment”. His remarks were reported on 13 November 2025.

What he said: He said the legal system had failed to protect the person it was meant to safeguard, and that the judgment wrongly treated the absence of visible resistance as consent. He also called it a turning point, because of the protests and law reform that followed.

Why it matters: It was an unusually direct admission from the head of the judiciary about one of the Court’s own decisions, 47 years after it was delivered.

The remark came in a lecture on how law has shaped gender equality in India.
1 Jul 2024

The new criminal codes take effect Law reform

BNS, BNSS, BSAReplace IPC, CrPC and Evidence Act

What happened: The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita and Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, which received assent on 25 December 2023, came into force and replaced the IPC, the CrPC and the Indian Evidence Act.

What carried over: Rape by a police officer within his police station’s limits, in any station house, or of a woman in police custody is aggravated rape under BNS Section 64(2)(a). Custodial sexual intercourse by a person in authority is Section 68. Disclosure of a victim’s identity is punished under Section 72. The presumption of no consent is now BSA Section 120, and in-camera trials are BNSS Section 366.

Why it matters: Every safeguard that grew out of the Mathura campaign survived the change of codes, under new section numbers.

Offences committed before 1 July 2024 are still tried under the IPC.
2 Apr 2013

Consent is defined in the statute Law reform

Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 2013In force from 3 February 2013

What happened: After the December 2012 Delhi gang rape and the Justice J.S. Verma Committee’s report of 23 January 2013, the government issued an ordinance on 3 February. Parliament replaced it with the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, which received assent on 2 April 2013.

The Mathura answer: Section 375 now defined consent as an “unequivocal voluntary agreement”, and added that a woman who does not physically resist penetration shall not, for that reason alone, be regarded as consenting. That is close to a direct reversal of the reasoning used against Mathura in 1978.

Other changes: The Act widened the definition of rape, created offences such as stalking and voyeurism, and extended the Section 114A presumption to all the aggravated categories in Section 376(2).

The Verma Committee report discussed the Mathura case in its account of how rape law had developed.
14 Nov 2012

POCSO creates a separate law for children Law reform

Protection of Children from Sexual Offences ActAssent 19 June 2012

What happened: The POCSO Act came into force, creating gender-neutral offences against children under 18, with child-friendly procedures for recording evidence and special courts.

The link: Mathura’s age was itself disputed in 1972-74: a doctor put her at 14 to 16, and the courts held it was not proved she was under 16. A separate law for children reflects how much the treatment of young survivors changed.

POCSO also bars disclosure of a child victim’s identity in the media.

Character evidence is removed from the Evidence Act Law reform

Indian Evidence (Amendment) Act, 2002Section 155(4) deleted

What happened: Parliament deleted Section 155(4) of the Indian Evidence Act, which had allowed the defence in a rape case to show that the complainant was “of generally immoral character”.

The Mathura link: Women’s groups had asked for this in 1980. The Sessions Court’s description of Mathura as “habituated to sexual intercourse” was the kind of reasoning they wanted removed, but the 1983 Act had left it out.

What followed: The 2013 amendment went further, barring evidence of a woman’s character or past sexual experience on the question of consent.

This demand took about 22 years to reach the statute book.
16 Jan 1996

State of Punjab v. Gurmit Singh Law reform

(1996) 2 SCC 384Justices A.S. Anand and Saghir Ahmad

What happened: Reversing an acquittal in a rape case from Ludhiana, the Supreme Court criticised the trial court for casting stigma on the complainant and said a survivor’s evidence does not need corroboration in every case.

In-camera trials: The Court said the requirement in Section 327(2) of the CrPC, added in 1983, that rape trials be held in camera should be followed as a rule, and that courts should avoid disclosing the victim’s name.

Why it matters: It showed the 1983 procedural safeguards being enforced from the bench, in language very different from the 1978 judgment.

The judgment withheld the survivor’s name, as the 1983 amendments intended.
25 Dec 1983

The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1983 Law reform

Act 43 of 1983Amends IPC, CrPC and Evidence Act

Custodial rape: Section 376(2) created aggravated rape, including rape by a police officer within his station’s limits or of a woman in his custody, and rape by public servants, jail and remand-home staff and hospital staff. New Sections 376B to 376D made sexual intercourse by such persons with a woman in their custody an offence even where it did not amount to rape.

Presumption: New Section 114A of the Evidence Act said that in prosecutions under Section 376(2), once intercourse is proved and the woman says in court she did not consent, the court shall presume she did not.

Privacy and sentence: Section 327(2) of the CrPC required rape trials to be held in camera, and Section 228A of the IPC made it an offence to disclose a victim’s identity. A minimum of 10 years was set for aggravated rape and seven years in other cases, with limited power for courts to go lower.

The demand to shift the burden of proof in all rape cases was accepted only for the aggravated categories.

A Joint Committee reports on the Bill Campaign

Joint Committee of ParliamentAfter public consultation

What happened: The Criminal Law (Amendment) Bill, 1980 had been sent to a Joint Committee of both Houses. It sought public opinion and reported in November 1982.

The dispute: Women’s groups objected to a clause that would have made publishing anything about a rape trial a non-bailable offence, since their campaign had relied on press coverage. The committee kept the restriction but made the offence bailable, according to Flavia Agnes’s review.

By the time the Act passed, Agnes wrote, the campaign had “virtually died down”.

The government introduces a Bill Campaign

Criminal Law (Amendment) Bill, 1980After the Law Commission’s 84th Report

What happened: The government asked the Law Commission to examine the law on rape. Its 84th Report, in 1980, accepted both of the campaign’s main demands: a presumption of no consent and a bar on using a woman’s sexual history. The Bill was introduced in Parliament in August 1980.

What it left out: The Bill did not include the Commission’s proposals to regulate police powers, such as a ban on arresting women at night, and it dropped the sexual-history bar. It accepted the presumption only for custodial and other aggravated cases.

The Law Commission had also proposed making a police officer’s refusal to register a rape complaint an offence.
8 Mar 1980

Women’s Day protests in several cities Campaign

Delhi, Bombay, Hyderabad, NagpurDemand for a rehearing

What happened: On International Women’s Day, women’s groups held demonstrations in several cities, demanding that the Mathura case be reheard and that the rape law be changed.

The outcome in court: The case was not reopened. Accounts of the campaign record that the courts found campaigners had no legal standing in a criminal appeal to which they were not parties.

Why it matters: The protests made rape, previously treated as a private shame, a subject of public political debate, which Agnes called the campaign’s principal gain.

The New York Times reported on the campaign in April 1980.

The Forum Against Rape is formed in Bombay Campaign

Later Forum Against Oppression of WomenAutonomous women’s group

What happened: Women in Bombay who had read the open letter formed the Forum Against Rape. Accounts date its start to January 1980 or to a public meeting on 23 February 1980. It later renamed itself the Forum Against Oppression of Women.

Elsewhere: Groups formed in other cities around the same time, including Saheli in Delhi.

The Forum’s widening name reflected a shift from one case to violence against women in general.

Four law teachers write an open letter Campaign

Upendra Baxi, Lotika Sarkar, Raghunath Kelkar, Vasudha DhagamwarTo CJI Y.V. Chandrachud

What happened: After the judgment appeared in the law reports, four law teachers, three from Delhi University and Vasudha Dhagamwar from Pune, wrote to Chief Justice Y.V. Chandrachud. The letter is commonly dated 16 September 1979.

What it argued: “Consent involves submission, but the converse is not necessarily true,” they wrote. They asked whether the Court had considered the power of two policemen over a young woman held at a police station, and asked for the case to be reheard by a larger bench.

Why it matters: It was the first public challenge to the judgment and became the founding document of the anti-rape campaign.

The letter came almost a year after the judgment was delivered, which is one reason it is often misdated to 1979.
15 Sep 1978

The Supreme Court acquits both policemen Supreme Court

Tukaram v. State of MaharashtraJustices Koshal, Jaswant Singh and Kailasam

What happened: A three-judge bench allowed the appeal. Justice A.D. Koshal, writing for the Court, set aside both convictions and sentences.

The reasoning on Ganpat: The Court said the absence of injuries showed the intercourse was “a peaceful affair” and that her account of resistance was false. Under the law then, consent was vitiated only by fear of “death or hurt”, and the High Court had made no such finding. Because she had been taken from among her relatives at the entrance, it said, she could not have been so overawed that she would not resist.

The reasoning on Tukaram: Her first report had named Tukaram for acts she later attributed to Ganpat, so the Court would not rely on her account against him.

The judgment is reported as (1979) 2 SCC 143, AIR 1979 SC 185 and 1979 SCR (1) 810, which is why it is often called the 1979 judgment.

The policemen appeal Supreme Court

Criminal Appeal No. 64 of 1977By special leave

What happened: Tukaram and Ganpat obtained special leave to appeal against the High Court’s judgment. They were represented by M.N. Phadke; the State by H.R. Khanna.

Their argument: There was no direct evidence about the nature of her consent, they argued, and the circumstances did not show she was under any fear or compulsion that would turn her submission into rape.

The appeal took about two years to be decided, from 1977 to September 1978.
12 Oct 1976

The Bombay High Court convicts both men Trial and High Court

Nagpur BenchCriminal Appeal No. 193 of 1974

What happened: The High Court reversed the acquittal. It convicted Ganpat of rape under Section 376 IPC and sentenced him to five years’ rigorous imprisonment. It convicted Tukaram of outraging her modesty under Section 354 and sentenced him to one year.

The reasoning: Both men were strangers to her, she was alone at the police station at night, and a complaint by her own brother was pending there. “Mere passive or helpless surrender of the body and its resignation to the other’s lust induced by threats or fear”, it said, could not be equated with consent.

On Tukaram: The court did not believe he had tried to rape her, but accepted that he had molested her.

The High Court agreed with the trial judge that her age below 16 was not proved.
1 Jun 1974

The Sessions Court acquits Trial and High Court

Sessions Judge, ChandrapurCharge: Section 376 read with Section 34

What happened: The Sessions Judge acquitted both men. He found that she had sexual intercourse at the police station, probably with Ganpat, but held that rape was not proved.

The reasoning: He called her “a shocking liar”, described her as “habituated to sexual intercourse”, and suggested she invented the rape to appear virtuous before her lover. He said there was “a world of difference between sexual intercourse and rape”.

Why it matters: The use of her sexual history to judge consent was central to the later campaign.

The judge also found no satisfactory evidence that she was under 16.
27 Mar 1972

The medical examination The incident

About 20 hours laterDr Kamal Shastrakar

What happened: She was examined at about 8 pm the next day. The doctor found no injury on her body and estimated her age at between 14 and 16.

The forensic evidence: No semen was found in the samples taken from her body, but it was found on her clothes and on the pyjama taken from Ganpat. The High Court later put the negative samples down to the delay and the likelihood she had bathed.

Why it mattered: The absence of injuries became the Supreme Court’s main reason for treating the intercourse as consensual.

Her brother had been asked to bring proof of her birth date; her age was never established in court.
26 Mar 1972

A crowd gathers outside the police station The incident

Night of 26 MarchFirst information report

What happened: Her relatives grew suspicious when the station’s lights went out and its door was closed from inside. Their shouts drew a crowd. When she came out, she told them Ganpat had made her undress and raped her.

The complaint: A doctor told them to report to the police. The crowd grew restive and threatened to beat Ganpat and burn the station down. Head Constable Baburao, brought from his home, calmed it and recorded her statement as the first information report.

In her first report she named Tukaram for some of the acts; at trial she attributed them to Ganpat, which the Supreme Court later held against her.
26 Mar 1972

Kept back at Desai Gunj police station The incident

Head Constable Tukaram, Constable GanpatAbout 10.30 pm

Why she was there: Her brother Gama had complained that she had been kidnapped by Ashok, the man she wanted to marry, and his relatives. All of them were brought to the station at about 9 pm.

What happened: After statements were recorded, they were told to leave. As they did, the two policemen told her to stay and her companions to go. The prosecution case was that Ganpat took her to a latrine, then to the back verandah, and raped her there, and that Tukaram then molested her but was too drunk to rape her.

Who she was: An orphaned Adivasi labourer who lived with her brother, described by the doctor as 14 to 16 years old. The station, spelt Desai Gunj in the judgment, is in today’s Desaiganj in Gadchiroli district, then part of Chandrapur district.

The judgment refers to her only as Mathura; she has never been publicly identified further.

Court by Court: How Each Read the Evidence

Same facts, opposite conclusions.

How three courts decided the Mathura case: Sessions Court, Chandrapur, 1 June 1974, held intercourse proved but not rape, called her a shocking liar and habituated to sexual intercourse, acquitted both; Bombay High Court, Nagpur, 12 October 1976, held passive submission under fear is not consent, convicted Ganpat of rape with 5 years and Tukaram of outraging modesty with 1 year; Supreme Court, 15 September 1978, held no injuries meant a peaceful affair and no fear of death or hurt was found, acquitted both.
Three courts, one set of facts
CourtDateOn consentGanpatTukaram
Sessions Court, Chandrapur1 Jun 1974Intercourse proved, rape not provedAcquittedAcquitted
Bombay High Court, Nagpur12 Oct 1976Passive submission under fear is not consentSection 376: 5 years RISection 354: 1 year RI
Supreme Court15 Sep 1978No injuries; no fear of death or hurt foundAcquittedAcquitted

The age question. Had she been proved to be under 16, the question of consent would not have arisen, because intercourse with a girl under 16 was rape under the fifth clause of Section 375. Her brother was asked to bring her birth record, but all three courts treated her age below 16 as unproved.

The first report. In her first statement she attributed some acts to Tukaram that she later attributed to Ganpat. The Supreme Court used that change to reject her evidence against Tukaram entirely.

The consent question in the Mathura case: the Supreme Court said no injuries meant a peaceful affair, that she did not resist or call her relatives, that only fear of death or hurt vitiates consent, and that she had changed her account of Tukaram; critics answered that a woman held by police may not be able to resist, that injuries are not proof of non-consent, that submission is not consent, and that her sexual history was irrelevant.
Two readings of the same night
The Court

“A peaceful affair”

No injuries were found, so the Court concluded there was no resistance, and that her account of a struggle was false.

The critics

Injuries are not the test

A woman alone with two policemen at night may not fight back. The absence of injuries does not show she agreed.

The Court

Fear of death or hurt

Under the third clause of Section 375, only consent obtained by fear of death or hurt was invalid, and no such fear was found.

The critics

Submission is not consent

“Consent involves submission, but the converse is not necessarily true,” the four law teachers wrote. The High Court had said the same.

The Court

She did not call for help

Taken from among her relatives at the entrance, she could have resisted and called to them, the Court reasoned.

The critics

Power was the point

Her brother’s complaint was pending at that very station. The men were police officers. The letter asked why that power counted for nothing.

What the 1983 Act Changed

Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1983 (Act 43 of 1983), assent 25 December 1983.

What the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1983 changed: aggravated rape under Section 376(2) IPC, including rape by police officers, public servants, jail, remand home and hospital staff, with a 10-year minimum; Sections 376B to 376D, sexual intercourse with a woman in custody made an offence; Section 114A Evidence Act, presumption of no consent in aggravated rape cases; Section 327(2) CrPC, in-camera trials; Section 228A IPC, offence to disclose a victim's identity. Left out: a general shift of the burden of proof and a bar on sexual-history evidence.
Five changes, two demands left out
Before 1983After the 1983 Act
No separate offence of custodial rapeAggravated rape by police, public servants and custodial staff, Section 376(2) IPC
Consent proved by the prosecution in every caseCourt presumes no consent in aggravated cases if she says so, Section 114A Evidence Act
Rape trials in open court unless a judge ordered otherwiseRape trials held in camera, Section 327(2) CrPC
No specific bar on naming the victimDisclosing a victim’s identity punishable, Section 228A IPC
No minimum sentence for rape10 years for aggravated rape, 7 years otherwise

What campaigners won. The presumption of no consent in custodial cases answered the central problem of the Mathura trial: a woman’s word against two policemen, with the burden entirely on her side.

What they did not. The presumption did not extend to all rape cases, and the bar on using a woman’s sexual history was dropped. Flavia Agnes later found that courts often went below the new minimum sentences, citing “adequate and special reasons”.

From the IPC to the BNS

How the Mathura-era safeguards moved through later reforms.

How the safeguards from the Mathura campaign moved through Indian law: 1983, Section 376(2) IPC, Section 114A Evidence Act, Section 327(2) CrPC, Section 228A IPC; 2002, Section 155(4) Evidence Act on immoral character deleted; 2013, consent defined as unequivocal voluntary agreement and lack of physical resistance not to be read as consent; 1 July 2024, BNS Section 64(2), BSA Section 120, BNSS Section 366 and BNS Section 72.
The same safeguards, new section numbers
Safeguard1983 provisionFrom 1 July 2024
Aggravated rape by policeSection 376(2) IPCBNS Section 64(2)(a)
Custodial sexual intercourseSections 376B-376D IPCBNS Section 68
Presumption of no consentSection 114A Evidence ActBSA Section 120
In-camera trialSection 327(2) CrPCBNSS Section 366
Victim’s identitySection 228A IPCBNS Section 72

The 2013 turn. After the 2012 Delhi gang rape, Parliament defined consent in the statute for the first time. Its explanation that a lack of physical resistance is not, by itself, consent reads almost as a reply to the 1978 judgment.

Law and practice. Statutory safeguards do not guarantee their use. Delays, police reluctance to register complaints and hostile questioning in court remain the subject of debate, as later cases on AiTimeline show.

By the Numbers

The Mathura case in numbers: 2 policemen accused; 3 courts, 3 different results; 6 years from the incident to the Supreme Court acquittal; 20 hours before the medical examination; 0 injuries recorded; 4 law teachers who wrote the open letter; 10-year minimum sentence for custodial rape from 1983; 52 years from the incident to the new codes in 2024.
Key figures

Who Was Who

Survivor

Mathura

An orphaned Adivasi labourer, estimated by a doctor to be 14 to 16 in 1972. She has never been identified beyond the name used in the judgment.

Accused

Tukaram and Ganpat

Head constable and constable at the Desai Gunj police station. Convicted by the High Court, acquitted by the Supreme Court.

Supreme Court

Justice A.D. Koshal

Wrote the 1978 judgment for a bench with Justices Jaswant Singh and P.S. Kailasam.

Open letter

Baxi, Sarkar, Kelkar, Dhagamwar

Four law teachers whose September 1979 letter to the Chief Justice began the campaign.

Chief Justice

Y.V. Chandrachud

Chief Justice of India from 1978 to 1985, to whom the letter was addressed.

Campaign

Forum Against Rape

Formed in Bombay in early 1980; later the Forum Against Oppression of Women.

Did You Know?

  • Not a suspect: she was at the police station only because her brother had filed a complaint about her relationship.
  • A year apart: the open letter of September 1979 came almost a year after the judgment of September 1978.
  • Three opposite findings: acquitted, convicted, acquitted, all on the same evidence.
  • The crowd’s role: the FIR was written only after a crowd threatened to burn the station.
  • Forty-one years later: the 2013 definition of consent said lack of physical resistance is not, alone, consent.
  • Forty-seven years on: a sitting Chief Justice called the verdict a “moment of institutional embarrassment” in 2025.

Explore More Timelines

People Also Ask

What is the Mathura rape case?
The Mathura rape case is the 1972 case of a young Adivasi woman, known as Mathura, who alleged she was raped by two policemen inside the Desai Gunj police station in Maharashtra on 26 March 1972. The Sessions Court acquitted them in 1974, the Bombay High Court convicted them in 1976, and the Supreme Court acquitted them on 15 September 1978. The outcry led to the Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1983.
Why is the Mathura case important?
Because the Supreme Court's acquittal, which treated the absence of injuries as evidence of consent, triggered India's first national campaign against rape. That campaign led Parliament to create the offence of custodial rape, a presumption of no consent in aggravated rape cases, in-camera trials and a ban on revealing victims' identities, all in 1983.
What did the Supreme Court decide in Tukaram v. State of Maharashtra?
It acquitted both policemen. The Court said there were no injuries, so the intercourse was a peaceful affair, and that her account of resisting and shouting was false. Under the law then, consent was invalid only if obtained by fear of death or hurt, and the High Court had made no such finding.
What law changed after the Mathura case?
The Criminal Law (Amendment) Act, 1983 (Act 43 of 1983). It added aggravated rape, including rape by police officers and others with custody of a woman, to Section 376 IPC; inserted Section 114A in the Evidence Act; required in-camera rape trials under Section 327(2) CrPC; and made disclosing a victim's identity an offence under Section 228A IPC.
Who wrote the open letter on the Mathura case?
Four law teachers: Upendra Baxi, Lotika Sarkar and Raghunath Kelkar of Delhi University, and Vasudha Dhagamwar of Pune. They wrote to Chief Justice Y.V. Chandrachud in September 1979, commonly dated 16 September, arguing that submission is not consent and asking for a rehearing by a larger bench.
Were the policemen in the Mathura case ever punished?
No. The High Court convicted constable Ganpat of rape, with five years' rigorous imprisonment, and head constable Tukaram of outraging modesty, with one year. The Supreme Court set aside both convictions and sentences in 1978. The case was not reopened, and the later changes in the law did not apply to it.

Frequently Asked Questions

Based on the Supreme Court judgment, Flavia Agnes’s review in the Economic and Political Weekly, and later statutes.

When did the Mathura incident happen?
On the night of 26 March 1972, at the Desai Gunj police station, now in Desaiganj in Gadchiroli district of Maharashtra. The area was then part of Chandrapur district, which is why the Sessions Court at Chandrapur heard the case.
Who were the accused in the Mathura case?
Head Constable Tukaram and Constable Ganpat, both attached to the Desai Gunj police station. The prosecution said Ganpat raped her and Tukaram molested her and tried to rape her but was too drunk to do so.
Why was Mathura at the police station?
Her brother Gama had complained that she had been kidnapped by Ashok, the man she wanted to marry, and his relatives. All of them were brought to the station at about 9 pm for statements. When they were told to leave, the two policemen kept her back.
How old was Mathura?
Her age was never established. The doctor who examined her estimated it at 14 to 16. The Sessions Court and High Court both held there was no satisfactory evidence she was under 16, the age below which intercourse was rape regardless of consent under the law then.
What did the Sessions Court decide in 1974?
On 1 June 1974 the Sessions Judge at Chandrapur acquitted both men. He accepted that she had sexual intercourse at the station but held that rape was not proved, called her a shocking liar and described her as habituated to sexual intercourse.
What did the Bombay High Court decide?
On 12 October 1976 the Nagpur Bench reversed the acquittal. It convicted Ganpat of rape under Section 376 IPC, with five years' rigorous imprisonment, and Tukaram under Section 354, with one year. It held that passive submission induced by fear is not consent.
What is the difference between consent and passive submission?
The High Court held that a woman who gives in because she is helpless or afraid has not consented, she has only submitted. The Supreme Court rejected that view on the facts. The four law teachers replied that consent involves submission but submission does not always mean consent.
Which judges decided the Mathura appeal?
Justices A.D. Koshal, Jaswant Singh and P.S. Kailasam. Justice Koshal wrote the judgment of the Court.
When was the Mathura judgment delivered?
On 15 September 1978. It was reported in 1979 as (1979) 2 SCC 143, AIR 1979 SC 185 and 1979 SCR (1) 810, so it is often wrongly called a 1979 judgment.
Why did the Supreme Court say there was no rape?
It held that no injuries were found, so the intercourse was a peaceful affair; that her account of shouting was false; and that she had been taken from among her relatives at the station entrance, so she could not have been too overawed to resist. It also said the High Court had not found fear of death or hurt.
Why was Tukaram acquitted?
In her first report she accused Tukaram of taking her to the latrine and shining a torch on her, acts she attributed to Ganpat at trial. The Supreme Court said that if she could change her account at will, it could not rely on what she said about Tukaram.
What was Section 375 IPC in 1972?
It defined rape as intercourse against a woman's will, without her consent, with consent obtained by fear of death or hurt, with consent obtained by impersonating her husband, or with a girl under 16 with or without consent. Marital rape of a wife over 15 was excepted.
What was wrong with the Mathura judgment, according to critics?
Critics said it treated the absence of injuries as proof of consent, ignored the power two policemen held over a young woman at a police station at night, read consent narrowly as freedom from fear of death or hurt, and was influenced by her relationship and sexual history.
Who was the Chief Justice when the open letter was written?
Y.V. Chandrachud, who was Chief Justice of India from February 1978 to July 1985. The letter asked him to have the case reheard by a larger bench or the full court.
Was there a review of the Mathura judgment?
No. Women's groups demanded a rehearing and protested on International Women's Day, 8 March 1980, but the judgment was never reopened. Accounts of the campaign record that the courts found the campaigners had no legal standing in the case.
What was the Forum Against Rape?
A women's group formed in Bombay in early 1980 in response to the open letter. Accounts date it to January 1980 or a public meeting on 23 February 1980. It later became the Forum Against Oppression of Women.
What did the Law Commission recommend after Mathura?
Its 84th Report in 1980 supported a presumption of no consent, a bar on evidence of a woman's sexual history, and rules on police conduct, such as no arrest of women at night and making refusal to register a rape complaint an offence. The government's Bill dropped several of these.
What is custodial rape?
Rape committed by a person who has a woman in custody or under his authority, such as a police officer, a public servant, or jail, remand home or hospital staff. The 1983 Act made it an aggravated offence with a minimum sentence of 10 years.
What is Section 114A of the Evidence Act?
Inserted in 1983, it said that in prosecutions for aggravated rape under Section 376(2), if intercourse is proved and the woman says in court that she did not consent, the court shall presume she did not consent. The accused can try to rebut it.
Did Section 114A apply to all rape cases?
No. It applied only to the aggravated categories in Section 376(2), such as custodial rape and gang rape. The campaign's demand to shift the burden in every rape case was not accepted.
What is Section 228A IPC?
Added in 1983, it made it an offence to print or publish the name or any matter that could identify the victim of rape and certain other offences, subject to exceptions. The equivalent today is Section 72 of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita.
What did Section 327(2) CrPC require?
Added in 1983, it required inquiries and trials of rape to be held in camera, so the public could not attend. In State of Punjab v. Gurmit Singh (1996) the Supreme Court said courts should follow it as a rule. The equivalent is now Section 366 of the BNSS.
What minimum sentence did the 1983 Act set?
Ten years for aggravated rape, including custodial rape, gang rape and rape of pregnant women or girls under 12, and seven years in other cases. Courts could go lower for adequate and special reasons, which Flavia Agnes found they often did.
Did the 1983 Act end the use of a woman's sexual history?
No. That demand was left out. Section 155(4) of the Evidence Act, which let the defence show a rape complainant was of generally immoral character, was deleted only in 2002, and the 2013 amendment barred such evidence on consent.
How did the 2013 amendment relate to Mathura?
It defined consent as an unequivocal voluntary agreement and said a woman who does not physically resist shall not, for that reason alone, be regarded as consenting. That directly addresses the reasoning used against Mathura.
What is BNS Section 64(2)?
The section of the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 that lists aggravated rape. Clause (a) covers a police officer who commits rape within his police station's limits, in any station house, or on a woman in police custody.
What is BSA Section 120?
The section of the Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam, 2023 that carries over Section 114A. In prosecutions under BNS Section 64(2), if intercourse is proved and the woman says she did not consent, the court shall presume absence of consent.
When did the new criminal laws come into force?
On 1 July 2024. The Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita and Bharatiya Sakshya Adhiniyam received assent on 25 December 2023 and replaced the IPC, CrPC and Indian Evidence Act.
What did CJI B.R. Gavai say about the Mathura case?
In a lecture reported on 13 November 2025, he called the 1978 judgment a moment of institutional embarrassment, saying the legal system failed the person it was meant to protect but that the judgment also became a turning point.
Was Mathura an Adivasi?
Yes, she is described as a tribal or Adivasi woman in accounts of the case, including Flavia Agnes's review and The Indian Express. The judgment itself says only that she was an orphan who worked as a labourer and lived with her brother.
Was the Mathura case the only reason for the 1983 law?
No. It was the main trigger, but the campaign also took up other cases of rape by police and men in authority, and the law went through the Law Commission and a Joint Committee of Parliament. The final Act reflected political compromises.
What does the Mathura case teach about rape trials?
That procedure and evidence rules can decide outcomes as much as the definition of the crime. Most of the reforms that followed concerned who must prove consent, what evidence is allowed, and how the survivor is treated in court.
Where can I read the Mathura judgment?
The full text of Tukaram and Another v. State of Maharashtra, dated 15 September 1978, is on Indian Kanoon and in the Supreme Court Cases and AIR reports listed in our sources.

⚠️ Editorial Note: What We Checked

We checked the brief we started from against the 1978 judgment and Flavia Agnes’s 1992 review. The medical examination was on 27 March 1972, about 20 hours after the incident, not at an unspecified date in March or April. The relatives grew suspicious when the station’s lights went off and its door was shut, and the FIR was recorded after a crowd threatened to burn the station. The Forum Against Rape cannot be dated to a specific day in January 1980; sources give January or a public meeting on 23 February, so we say early 1980. The 1983 presumption applied to all the aggravated categories in Section 376(2), including gang rape, not only custodial cases. We have not used one academic chapter cited in the brief because we could not verify its title. The open letter is commonly dated 16 September 1979; one report gives 6 September. Mathura’s age is not presented as established. This article describes court judgments and laws and is not legal advice.

Related Reading on AiTimeline

Antulay Cement Scandal: Why Maharashtra CM A.R. Antulay Resigned in 1982 Shah Bano Case: A Timeline of India’s Landmark Maintenance Law
New article
→
Next Article