← AiTimeline Home

Lok Sabha · 1993 · Supreme Court 1998 & 2024 · Articles 105 & 194

JMM Bribery Case: A Timeline of India’s Political Controversy

📅 Last updated: 15 November 2026⏱ 33 dated entries✎ By Nazish Fatima

View as Web Story

In short

Explore the JMM bribery case timeline: the 1993 no-confidence vote, the 1998 Supreme Court immunity ruling and its landmark reversal in Sita Soren, 2024.

Latest Story

On 28 July 1993 P.V. Narasimha Rao’s minority government survived a no-confidence motion by 14 votes. Three years later the CBI alleged that some of those votes had been bought, including the four votes of the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha. The JMM bribery case produced the first conviction of a former Prime Minister, an acquittal on appeal, and a 3:2 Supreme Court ruling in 1998 that MPs who took bribes and voted as paid could not be prosecuted. That ruling stood until 4 March 2024, when seven judges, hearing an appeal by Shibu Soren’s daughter-in-law, unanimously overturned it. This page follows the case from 1991 to November 2026.

How to read this page

Three different things happened in this case and they are easy to confuse. The allegations were made in CBI complaints and chargesheets from 1996; they were never finally proved against the MPs. The 1998 judgment was a ruling on constitutional immunity, not a finding that bribes were or were not paid. The 2002 acquittal of Rao and Buta Singh was a decision on the evidence. The 2024 judgment changed the law on immunity but did not reopen the 1993 case or decide anyone’s guilt. Where common accounts get a fact wrong, we say so in the entry and in the editorial note.

💡 Short Answer

The JMM bribery case concerns allegations that four Jharkhand Mukti Morcha MPs were paid to vote against a no-confidence motion that the Rao government survived on 28 July 1993, by 265 votes to 251. In 1998 the Supreme Court held 3:2 that bribe-taking MPs who voted were immune under Article 105(2). On 4 March 2024 a seven-judge bench unanimously overruled that, in Sita Soren v. Union of India.

⚡ The Case at a Glance
The vote28 July 1993: 251 for, 265 against
The JMM MPsShibu Soren, Suraj Mandal, Simon Marandi, Shailendra Mahto
Alleged paymentRs 2.8 crore to the JMM MPs (charge)
1998 ruling3:2 for immunity, 17 April 1998
Rao and Buta SinghConvicted 2000, acquitted 15 March 2002
Overruled7-0, Sita Soren, 4 March 2024
⚡ Quick Answers — AI Overview Ready

JMM Bribery Case: Key Questions

What was the JMM bribery case about?
Allegations that four JMM MPs and members of Ajit Singh’s Janata Dal group were paid to vote against the July 1993 no-confidence motion, which P.V. Narasimha Rao’s minority government survived by 14 votes. The CBI charged the MPs and the alleged bribe-givers, including Rao, from 1996.
What did the 1998 judgment hold?
By 3:2, that MPs who allegedly took bribes and then voted in the House were immune from prosecution under Article 105(2). Ajit Singh, who abstained, and the alleged bribe-givers were not immune. The JMM MPs were discharged in 1999 as a result.
What happened to Narasimha Rao?
As an alleged bribe-giver he had no immunity. A Special CBI Court convicted him and Buta Singh on 29 September 2000 and sentenced them to three years. The Delhi High Court acquitted both on 15 March 2002, finding the approver’s evidence unreliable.
What changed in 2024?
In Sita Soren v. Union of India, seven judges unanimously held that no MP or MLA can claim immunity under Articles 105(2) or 194(2) for taking a bribe, and that the offence is complete when the bribe is accepted, whether or not the vote is cast.
📚 Key Takeaways

The JMM Bribery Case in Ten Points

  • The vote: on 28 July 1993 the Rao government survived a no-confidence motion, 265 votes to 251.
  • The allegation: a February 1996 complaint said MPs had been paid to vote with the government.
  • The accused: four JMM MPs, the Ajit Singh group, and alleged bribe-givers including Rao and Buta Singh.
  • The approver: JMM MP Shailendra Mahto was pardoned in April 1997 and testified for the prosecution.
  • The 1998 ruling: 3:2, bribe-taking MPs who voted were immune under Article 105(2).
  • The exceptions: Ajit Singh, who abstained, and the bribe-givers had no immunity.
  • The trial: Rao and Buta Singh were convicted in September 2000 and sentenced to three years.
  • The appeal: the Delhi High Court acquitted both on 15 March 2002.
  • The new case: JMM MLA Sita Soren was accused of taking a bribe in the 2012 Rajya Sabha poll.
  • The reversal: on 4 March 2024 seven judges held there is no immunity for bribery at all.

From a Confidence Vote to a Constitutional Reversal

The whole case on one page, 1991 to 2026.

The JMM bribery case, 1991 to 2026: June 1991 Rao forms a minority government; 28 July 1993 no-confidence motion defeated 251 to 265; February 1996 complaint to the CBI; 30 October 1996 Rao chargesheeted; April 1997 Shailendra Mahto turns approver; 17 April 1998 Supreme Court rules 3:2 that bribe-taking MPs who voted are immune; June 1999 JMM MPs discharged; 29 September 2000 Rao and Buta Singh convicted; 15 March 2002 both acquitted; 30 March 2012 Rajya Sabha poll in Jharkhand countermanded; 4 March 2024 seven judges overrule the 1998 ruling; August 2025 Shibu Soren dies.
Thirty years from a vote in the Lok Sabha to the end of bribery immunity.

The JMM bribery case is really two cases, separated by almost twenty years and joined by one family. The first began with a vote in the Lok Sabha in 1993 and ended, for the MPs accused of taking money, with a Supreme Court ruling in 1998 that they could not be prosecuted at all. The second began with a Rajya Sabha poll in Jharkhand in 2012, when Shibu Soren’s daughter-in-law Sita Soren claimed the protection her father-in-law had received, and ended with the Supreme Court withdrawing it.

In between, the prosecution of the alleged bribe-givers ran its own course. P.V. Narasimha Rao, who had no immunity because he was accused of paying rather than taking, was convicted in 2000 and acquitted in 2002. No one in the 1993 case was finally convicted of anything.

The 1993 Vote

A minority government, a three-day debate and a margin of 14.

The Congress had won the most seats in 1991 but not a majority, and Rao governed with the help of smaller parties and breakaway groups. The no-confidence motion moved on 26 July 1993 was the most serious threat it faced. When the House divided on 28 July, 251 members voted for the motion and 265 against. The four JMM MPs and members of Ajit Singh’s Janata Dal group were among those who voted with the government; Ajit Singh himself abstained.

Nothing about the vote was challenged at the time. The allegation that some of those votes had been paid for surfaced only in 1996, after the Rao government had lost power.

The no-confidence motion of 28 July 1993: 251 members voted for the motion and 265 against, a margin of 14. Those voting against included the four JMM MPs Shibu Soren, Suraj Mandal, Simon Marandi and Shailendra Mahto, and members of the Janata Dal (Ajit) group. Ajit Singh abstained.
The division that later became the centre of the bribery case.

The Investigation, 1996-1997

From a complaint to four chargesheets and an approver.

The case started with a complaint by Ravindra Kumar of the Rashtriya Mukti Morcha, dated 1 February 1996 and filed with the CBI on 28 February. It alleged that more than Rs 3 crore had been paid to MPs, of which Rs 1.10 crore went to JMM MP Suraj Mandal. The CBI registered four cases against the JMM MPs. In May 1996 the Delhi High Court ordered a wider case covering the alleged payers.

The first chargesheet, in October 1996, named Rao himself. Two supplementary chargesheets followed, and in April 1997 one of the four MPs, Shailendra Mahto, was pardoned in return for his testimony. The charges alleged that the JMM MPs had “demanded and accepted” Rs 2.8 crore.

The investigation step by step: 1 February 1996 complaint by Ravindra Kumar of the Rashtriya Mukti Morcha, filed with the CBI 28 February; four CBI cases registered against the JMM MPs; 24 May 1996 Delhi High Court orders a wider case, registered 11 June; 30 October 1996 first chargesheet names Rao, Satish Sharma, Buta Singh and the four JMM MPs; 9 December 1996 supplementary chargesheet names V. Rajeshwar Rao, N.M. Revanna, Ramalinga Reddy and M. Thimmegowda; 22 January 1997 second supplementary chargesheet names Bhajan Lal and the Ajit Singh group; 8 April 1997 Shailendra Mahto pardoned as approver; 6 May 1997 order to frame charges; 25 September 1997 charges framed.
How the CBI built its case.

The 1998 Ruling: Who Was Protected

P.V. Narasimha Rao v. State (CBI/SPE), 17 April 1998.

The accused MPs argued that Article 105(2), which says no MP is liable to proceedings in any court “in respect of” any vote given in Parliament, protected them. The majority agreed. Justice S.P. Bharucha, writing for himself and Justice S. Rajendra Babu, with Justice G.N. Ray agreeing, held that because the alleged bribe was connected to the vote, the bribe-takers who voted were immune. “The charges against them must fail.”

The result was a set of distinctions that critics found hard to defend. An MP who took money and voted as paid was protected. Ajit Singh, accused of taking money but who abstained, was not. Nor were the people accused of paying. Justices S.C. Agrawal and A.S. Anand dissented: privilege, they said, protects what an MP does in the House, not a corrupt bargain made outside it.

Who the 1998 judgment protected. Bribe-takers who voted against the motion (Shibu Soren, Suraj Mandal, Simon Marandi and others): immune under Article 105(2), discharged in 1999. Alleged bribe-taker who abstained (Ajit Singh): not immune, tried and acquitted in 2000. Alleged bribe-givers (P.V. Narasimha Rao, Buta Singh, Satish Sharma and others): not immune, tried; Rao and Buta Singh convicted in 2000 and acquitted in 2002. Approver (Shailendra Mahto): pardoned in 1997. Majority: Justices Bharucha, Rajendra Babu and G.N. Ray. Minority: Justices S.C. Agrawal and A.S. Anand.
The 3:2 ruling divided the accused into protected and unprotected.

Timeline: The JMM Bribery Case, 1991-2026

Newest first. Colour shows the strand: the 1993 vote, the investigation and trial, the Supreme Court, the Sita Soren case, or the aftermath.

Where things stand Aftermath

Status as of 15 November 2026Supreme Court and Special CBI Court, Ranchi

Settled: The constitutional question is closed. Since 4 March 2024, MPs and MLAs cannot use Articles 105(2) or 194(2) to escape prosecution for taking a bribe linked to a vote or speech in the House. The 1998 majority view no longer stands.

Not reopened: The 1993 prosecution is over. The JMM MPs were discharged in 1999, P.V. Narasimha Rao and Buta Singh were acquitted on appeal in 2002, and most of the main figures, including Rao, Buta Singh, Ajit Singh and Shibu Soren, have since died. The 2024 ruling did not revive any of those charges.

Still running: The 2012 Rajya Sabha case against Sita Soren, which produced the 2024 judgment, is back before the Special CBI Court in Ranchi. We found no reported verdict in it.

The 1998 ruling protected the bribe-takers in the very case it decided. The 2024 ruling that reversed it arrived after the most prominent of them had died.

Shibu Soren dies Aftermath

4 August 2025Aged 81

What happened: JMM founder Shibu Soren, one of the four MPs at the centre of the 1993 allegations, died after a long illness. He was the father-in-law of Sita Soren, whose own case ended the immunity that had shielded him.

His case: He was discharged in the JMM bribery case in 1999 because of the 1998 immunity ruling. ThePrint, reporting his death, noted that his own family’s litigation undid the ruling that had protected him.

Shibu Soren was a three-time Chief Minister of Jharkhand and a Union minister; his son Hemant Soren is the present Chief Minister.

Sita Soren loses Jamtara Aftermath

23 November 2024Jharkhand Assembly election

What happened: Contesting the Jamtara assembly seat for the BJP, Sita Soren lost to Congress’s Irfan Ansari by 43,676 votes, according to Election Commission results. The JMM-led alliance won the state.

Context: It was her second defeat of 2024 after leaving the JMM in March, days after the Supreme Court ruling in her case.

She had represented Jama, a different seat, as a JMM MLA for three terms from 2009.

High Court quashes the case against the candidate Sita Soren case

21 August 2024Jharkhand High Court, W.P.(Cr.) 279 of 2023

What happened: Justice Rajesh Kumar quashed the criminal proceedings against Raj Kumar Agarwal, the independent Rajya Sabha candidate accused of paying bribes in 2012, because an income-tax appellate order had deleted the Rs 1.5 crore addition on which much of the money trail rested. The court said the chance of conviction was “very bleak”.

The trial: The order records that charges were framed in the Special CBI Court on 14 February 2014 and that, by CBI’s account, 85 of 114 prosecution witnesses had been examined. The proceedings against the other accused, including Sita Soren, were not quashed.

The order relates only to Agarwal. It does not mention the Supreme Court’s March 2024 judgment.

Defeat in Dumka Aftermath

4 June 2024Lok Sabha election

What happened: Fielded by the BJP in Dumka, the seat her father-in-law had held for decades, Sita Soren lost to the JMM’s Nalin Soren by 22,527 votes.

Why it matters: The litigant whose appeal ended legislative immunity for bribery had by then switched parties. The case itself continued regardless of her political affiliation.

The BJP dropped its sitting Dumka MP, Sunil Soren, to field her.

Sita Soren joins the BJP Aftermath

March 2024Days after the judgment

What happened: Days after the Supreme Court decided the reference in her case, Sita Soren, the widow of Shibu Soren’s elder son Durga Soren, resigned from the JMM and joined the BJP ahead of the Lok Sabha election.

Why it matters: The case is still against her personally. Changing parties has no legal effect on a prosecution under the Prevention of Corruption Act.

ThePrint described her as “Guruji ki bahu”, Guruji being the name by which Shibu Soren was known.
4 Mar 2024

Seven judges overrule the 1998 judgment Supreme Court

4 March 2024Sita Soren v. Union of India, 2024 INSC 161

The bench: Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud wrote for a unanimous bench with Justices A.S. Bopanna, M.M. Sundresh, P.S. Narasimha, J.B. Pardiwala, Sanjay Kumar and Manoj Misra. “We disagree with and overrule the judgment of the majority on this aspect,” the Court said of P.V. Narasimha Rao.

The holding: A legislator cannot claim immunity under Articles 105 or 194 from prosecution for bribery in connection with a vote or speech. Such a claim fails the Court’s two-fold test: privilege must be tied to the collective functioning of the House and necessary to a legislator’s essential duties. Taking a bribe is neither.

When the offence is complete: “The offence of bribery is complete at the point in time when the legislator accepts the bribe.” It does not matter whether the vote is later cast as agreed, or cast at all. The Court called the 1998 outcome “paradoxical”: an MP who took money and delivered was protected, while one who took money and did not was not.

What it did not decide: The Court expressly did not rule on whether Sita Soren committed the offence. It held that voting in a Rajya Sabha election is covered by Article 194(2), but that the privilege does not extend to bribery.

The House and the courts have parallel powers: the House can discipline a member for bribery, and a criminal court can try them.

Bharat Ratna for Narasimha Rao Aftermath

9 February 2024Announced by the Union government

What happened: The government announced the Bharat Ratna, India’s highest civilian honour, for P.V. Narasimha Rao, chiefly for the 1991 economic reforms.

The connection: Rao was the only Prime Minister to be convicted in a criminal case, in the JMM bribery case in 2000, before his acquittal in 2002. Less than a month after the award, the Supreme Court overruled the judgment that bears his name.

P.V. Narasimha Rao v. State takes its title from Rao because he was the first appellant; the immunity it granted never applied to him, as he was accused as a bribe-giver.

Seven-judge bench reserves judgment Supreme Court

5 October 2023Constitution Bench hearing

What happened: After hearing arguments, the seven-judge bench headed by Chief Justice Chandrachud reserved its verdict. The Union government, through the Attorney General and Solicitor General, argued that bribery was never protected by privilege.

The live issue: The Attorney General also argued that Rajya Sabha elections fall outside Article 194(2) altogether. The Court later rejected that point while still ruling against immunity for bribery.

Counsel for Sita Soren argued that the 1998 judgment should stand.

Five judges refer the question to seven Supreme Court

20 September 2023Five-judge Constitution Bench

What happened: A five-judge bench recorded prima facie doubts about the correctness of the 1998 majority view and referred the question to a seven-judge bench, the only size of bench able to overrule a five-judge decision.

Why it matters: This was the first time since 1998 that the Court formally reopened the immunity question.

The referral came nine years after Sita Soren first reached the Supreme Court.

Three judges point to the 1998 precedent Supreme Court

7 March 2019Bench headed by CJI Ranjan Gogoi

What happened: A three-judge bench found that the precise question had already been decided in the 1998 P.V. Narasimha Rao judgment, and called it a matter of “substantial public importance”.

The result: Because only a larger bench could reconsider a five-judge ruling, the bench referred the matter to a five-judge Constitution Bench.

The appeal was registered as Criminal Appeal No. 451 of 2019.

Sita Soren’s appeal sent to a larger bench Supreme Court

23 September 2014Two-judge bench, Supreme Court

What happened: A two-judge bench hearing Sita Soren’s appeal against the High Court ruling found the issue “substantial and of general public importance” and placed it before a bench of three judges.

Custody: She had surrendered in the trial court in February 2014 and spent about seven months in jail. The Jharkhand High Court granted her bail in September 2014.

Her special leave petition was filed in March 2014.

Jharkhand High Court refuses to quash Sita Soren case

17 February 2014W.P. (Crl.) 128 of 2013

What happened: The Jharkhand High Court declined to quash the chargesheet against Sita Soren. Applying the 1998 judgment, it held that she was not protected because she had not voted for the alleged bribe-giver.

The irony: Under the 1998 rule, a legislator who took money and voted as paid was immune; one who took money and voted the other way was not. That was the gap the Supreme Court later called paradoxical.

Charges in the trial were framed in the Special CBI Court on 14 February 2014, three days before the High Court ruling.
2012-13

CBI takes over the Rajya Sabha case Sita Soren case

April 2012 to June 2013RC 02(S)/2012-AHD-R

What happened: On 5 April 2012 the Jharkhand High Court transferred the investigation to the CBI, which registered its case on 19 April 2012. The charges were under Sections 7 and 13 of the Prevention of Corruption Act and Sections 120B and 171E of the IPC. The Special Judge took cognisance on 7 June 2013.

The accused: Those charged included Sita Soren, candidate Raj Kumar Agarwal, her father-in-law Badnaran Majhi and others.

The Election Commission had first complained about the poll, prompting the investigation.
30 Mar 2012

A Rajya Sabha poll is countermanded Sita Soren case

30 March 2012Two Rajya Sabha seats from Jharkhand

What happened: Hours before polling, income-tax officials and police seized Rs 2.15 crore from a vehicle on the NH-33 ring road near Namkum, Ranchi. Sita Soren, a JMM MLA, was later accused of accepting money to vote for the independent candidate Raj Kumar Agarwal.

How she voted: In the open ballot she did not vote for him. She voted for her own party’s candidate, Sanjiv Kumar. The Election Commission countermanded the poll and a fresh election was held, in which she again voted for her party’s candidate.

Rajya Sabha polls use an open ballot: party MLAs show their marked ballot to their party’s agent.

Narasimha Rao dies Aftermath

23 December 2004New Delhi

What happened: P.V. Narasimha Rao died at 83, less than three years after the Delhi High Court acquitted him in the JMM bribery case.

His record: He remained the only Prime Minister ever convicted in a criminal case, though that conviction did not survive appeal. Buta Singh died on 2 January 2021 and Ajit Singh on 6 May 2021.

Rao also faced two other criminal cases from the 1990s, the St Kitts forgery case and the Lakhubhai Pathak cheating case, and was cleared in both.
15 Mar 2002

Delhi High Court acquits Rao and Buta Singh Investigation & trial

15 March 2002Justice R.S. Sodhi, Crl. A. 638 and 621 of 2000

The order: “I allow Crl.A. 638 of 2000 and Crl.A. 621 of 2000, set aside the judgment of conviction and sentence of the Special Judge dated 29.9.2000 and 12.10.2000 and acquit the appellants of all charges.”

Why: The case against them rested on approver Shailendra Mahto, whose statements the defence showed to be inconsistent. The High Court found his evidence unreliable without independent corroboration.

The others: The same order dismissed the Rashtriya Mukti Morcha’s revision petition challenging the acquittal of Satish Sharma, V. Rajeshwar Rao, H.M. Revanna, Ramalinga Reddy, M. Veerappa Moily, D.K. Audikesavulu, M. Thimme Gowda, Bhajan Lal and Ajit Singh.

The acquittal was on the evidence. It did not touch the 1998 constitutional ruling, which still applied to the MPs.
12 Oct 2000

Three years’ rigorous imprisonment Investigation & trial

12 October 2000Special Judge, CBI, Delhi

What happened: The Special Judge sentenced Rao and Buta Singh to three years’ rigorous imprisonment and a fine under the conspiracy and corruption charges, the sentences to run concurrently.

The appeal: Buta Singh’s appeal was admitted by the Delhi High Court on 18 October 2000. Rao appealed too.

Rao was the first former Prime Minister sentenced to prison by an Indian court.
29 Sep 2000

Rao and Buta Singh convicted Investigation & trial

29 September 2000Special CBI Court, Delhi

What happened: Special Judge Ajit Bharihoke convicted P.V. Narasimha Rao and Buta Singh of criminal conspiracy and abetment of bribery under the Prevention of Corruption Act. “Rao, Buta convicted in JMM bribery case,” The Tribune reported.

Acquitted: The court acquitted the other accused tried with them, including Satish Sharma, Bhajan Lal and Ajit Singh. Reporting at the time said the approver’s evidence was corroborated against Rao and Buta Singh only.

It was the first criminal conviction of a former Prime Minister in India.

The JMM MPs are discharged Investigation & trial

4 June 1999Special Judge, Delhi

What happened: Following the Supreme Court ruling, the trial court dropped the conspiracy and corruption charges against the JMM MPs and others protected by the immunity. A separate perjury charge under Section 193 IPC against Suraj Mandal, Shibu Soren and Simon Marandi was sent to another court.

What it meant: The discharge followed from the constitutional ruling. It was not a finding that no money had changed hands.

Shailendra Mahto, the fourth MP, had already turned approver and testified for the prosecution.

Review petition dismissed Supreme Court

16 December 1998Supreme Court

What happened: A CBI review petition against the April 1998 judgment, filed on 12 November 1998, was dismissed on 16 December 1998. Special leave petitions in the case were disposed of in May 1999.

Effect: The 3:2 ruling became binding precedent, and it stayed that way for more than 25 years.

A larger bench was the only route left to reconsider it.
17 Apr 1998

The Supreme Court’s 3:2 immunity ruling Supreme Court

17 April 1998P.V. Narasimha Rao v. State (CBI/SPE), (1998) 4 SCC 626

The majority: Justice S.P. Bharucha, for himself and Justice S. Rajendra Babu, with Justice G.N. Ray agreeing, held that MPs who allegedly took bribes and then voted against the motion were protected by Article 105(2). “The charges against them must fail.”

The exceptions: Ajit Singh, who abstained, was not protected: “not having cast a vote on the no-confidence motion, [he] derives no immunity from Article 105(2).” The alleged bribe-givers, including Rao, were not protected either.

The dissent: Justice S.C. Agrawal, for himself and Justice A.S. Anand, held that there is no immunity for bribe-takers or bribe-givers, that an MP is a public servant under the Prevention of Corruption Act, and that prosecutors should seek the Speaker’s or Chairman’s permission before filing a chargesheet.

Justice Anand, one of the two dissenters, became Chief Justice of India later that year.

Referred to a Constitution Bench Supreme Court

9 December 1997Supreme Court

What happened: The accused challenged the charges in the Supreme Court. A three-judge bench sent two questions to a five-judge Constitution Bench: whether Article 105 gives MPs immunity from prosecution for bribery linked to their votes, and whether an MP is a “public servant” under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988.

Why it mattered: If either answer favoured the MPs, the prosecution of the bribe-takers would collapse.

The Delhi High Court had already dismissed their revision petitions against the framing of charges.

Charges framed Investigation & trial

6 May and 25 September 1997Special Judge, New Delhi

What happened: On 6 May 1997 the Special Judge held there was “sufficient evidence on record to justify framing of charges” against Rao and the other accused. The charges were formally framed on 25 September 1997.

The charges: Conspiracy under Section 120B IPC and offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. The JMM MPs were charged with having “demanded and accepted” Rs 280 lakh, Rs 2.8 crore, to vote against the motion.

Twenty people were charged at this stage, according to contemporary reports.

Shailendra Mahto turns approver Investigation & trial

8 April 1997Special Judge, New Delhi

What happened: Mahto, one of the four JMM MPs, applied for a pardon in March 1997 and made a statement before a magistrate. On 8 April 1997 the court granted him a conditional pardon in return for testifying for the prosecution.

Why it mattered: His evidence became the core of the case. It persuaded the trial court in 2000 and failed to persuade the High Court in 2002.

An approver is an accused person pardoned on condition of giving full and true evidence against the others.

Bhajan Lal and the Ajit Singh group charged Investigation & trial

22 January 1997Second supplementary chargesheet

What happened: The CBI’s second supplementary chargesheet named former Haryana Chief Minister Bhajan Lal and members of the Janata Dal (Ajit) group, including Ajit Singh and MPs such as Ram Lakhan Singh Yadav and Roshan Lal.

The allegation: That members of Ajit Singh’s breakaway group were also paid to help the government survive.

The judgment prints the date as 22 January “1977”, an obvious misprint for 1997.

Supplementary chargesheet Investigation & trial

9 December 1996Special Judge, New Delhi

What happened: The CBI named V. Rajeshwar Rao, N.M. Revanna, Ramalinga Reddy and M. Thimmegowda, alleging they had arranged funds and paid the JMM MPs.

Later accused: M. Veerappa Moily and D.K. Audikesavulu were also among the accused acquitted at trial in 2000.

Several of those named were Congress politicians from Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh.

First chargesheet names the Prime Minister Investigation & trial

30 October 1996Special Judge, New Delhi

What happened: The CBI chargesheeted P.V. Narasimha Rao (accused No. 1), Satish Sharma, the four JMM MPs and Buta Singh. By then Rao was no longer Prime Minister, having resigned after the Congress lost the May 1996 election.

The allegation: That Rao, Satish Sharma and Buta Singh conspired to pay the JMM MPs to vote against the no-confidence motion, and that the MPs accepted the money.

Rao had stepped down as Congress president in September 1996, weeks before the chargesheet.

High Court orders a wider case Investigation & trial

24 May and 11 June 1996Delhi High Court, CWP 23/96

What happened: On 24 May 1996 the Delhi High Court, hearing a writ petition, ordered the CBI to register a case on the wider conspiracy. The CBI registered it on 11 June 1996.

Why it mattered: It moved the investigation from the MPs who allegedly took money to the people alleged to have paid it, including the Prime Minister.

The order came weeks after the Congress lost power at the Centre.

A complaint reaches the CBI Investigation & trial

Complaint dated 1 February 1996Filed with the CBI 28 February 1996

What happened: Ravindra Kumar of the Rashtriya Mukti Morcha complained that MPs had been paid to vote against the 1993 motion, alleging payments of over Rs 3 crore, of which Rs 1.10 crore was handed to Suraj Mandal.

The cases: The CBI registered four cases under the Prevention of Corruption Act against the JMM MPs Suraj Mandal, Shibu Soren, Simon Marandi and Shailendra Mahto.

The complaint came more than two and a half years after the vote, and months before a general election.
28 Jul 1993

The government survives by 14 votes The 1993 vote

28 July 1993Lok Sabha

The result: The no-confidence motion was lost, “251 members having voted in support and 265 against”, as the Supreme Court later recorded.

The swing votes: The four JMM MPs, Shibu Soren, Suraj Mandal, Simon Marandi and Shailendra Mahto, and members of the Janata Dal (Ajit) group voted against the motion. Ajit Singh himself abstained.

Without the votes later alleged to have been bought, the result would have been far closer.
26 Jul 1993

The no-confidence motion The 1993 vote

26-28 July 1993Lok Sabha

What happened: A motion of no confidence was moved in the Lok Sabha against Rao’s minority government, and debated over three days.

The stakes: Rao’s Congress did not have a majority of its own. The vote of every small group, including the JMM, mattered.

The debate ran from 26 to 28 July 1993, ending in a division the same evening.

A minority government The 1993 vote

June 1991Tenth Lok Sabha

What happened: After the 1991 general election, held in the shadow of Rajiv Gandhi’s assassination, the Congress emerged as the single largest party and formed a minority government with P.V. Narasimha Rao as Prime Minister.

Why it matters: A government short of a majority depends on smaller parties and defectors. That dependence is the background to the 1993 vote.

Rao, then 70, had been planning to retire from politics before the election.

Trial and Acquittal, 2000-2002

The prosecution of the alleged bribe-givers.

With the JMM MPs discharged, the trial in the Special CBI Court in Delhi went ahead against those the 1998 ruling did not protect. On 29 September 2000 Special Judge Ajit Bharihoke convicted Rao and Buta Singh, the first criminal conviction of a former Prime Minister, and acquitted the others, including Satish Sharma, Bhajan Lal and Ajit Singh. On 12 October he sentenced Rao and Buta Singh to three years’ rigorous imprisonment.

The conviction rested largely on the evidence of approver Shailendra Mahto. On appeal, Justice R.S. Sodhi of the Delhi High Court found that evidence unreliable and, on 15 March 2002, acquitted both men of all charges. He also dismissed the Rashtriya Mukti Morcha’s challenge to the other acquittals.

The trial and appeal: 4 June 1999 trial court drops the corruption charges against the JMM MPs after the Supreme Court ruling; 29 September 2000 Special Judge Ajit Bharihoke convicts Rao and Buta Singh, and acquits Satish Sharma, Bhajan Lal, Ajit Singh and others; 12 October 2000 three years’ rigorous imprisonment and fines; October 2000 appeals admitted in the Delhi High Court; 15 March 2002 Justice R.S. Sodhi acquits both of all charges, finding the approver’s evidence unreliable, and dismisses the challenge to the other acquittals.
From the first conviction of a former Prime Minister to acquittal.

The Sita Soren Case, 2012-2024

How a Rajya Sabha poll in Jharkhand reopened the 1998 ruling.

On 30 March 2012, as Jharkhand’s MLAs voted for two Rajya Sabha seats, income-tax officials and police seized Rs 2.15 crore from a vehicle near Ranchi. The Election Commission countermanded the poll. The CBI later charged JMM MLA Sita Soren with accepting money to vote for the independent candidate Raj Kumar Agarwal. The open ballot showed she had not voted for him.

That fact cut against her. Applying the 1998 judgment, the Jharkhand High Court held in February 2014 that immunity covered only a legislator who voted in the way connected with the bribe, so she had none. Her appeal moved up through benches of two, three and five judges until, in September 2023, a seven-judge bench was set up to reconsider the 1998 ruling itself.

The road to seven judges: 30 March 2012 Rajya Sabha poll countermanded after Rs 2.15 crore is seized near Ranchi; 19 April 2012 CBI registers its case; 14 February 2014 charges framed in the Special CBI Court, Ranchi; 17 February 2014 Jharkhand High Court refuses to quash, because she did not vote for the alleged bribe-giver; 23 September 2014 two-judge bench refers to three; 7 March 2019 three-judge bench refers to five; 20 September 2023 five-judge bench refers to seven; 5 October 2023 judgment reserved; 4 March 2024 unanimous judgment overrules 1998.
Twelve years from a countermanded poll to a new constitutional rule.

What the Supreme Court Changed in 2024

The 1998 majority view against the 2024 judgment.

Question1998: P.V. Narasimha Rao (3:2)2024: Sita Soren (7:0)
MP takes a bribe and votes as agreedImmune under Article 105(2)No immunity; can be prosecuted
Legislator takes a bribe but abstains or votes otherwiseNot immune (Ajit Singh; applied to Sita Soren in 2014)No immunity; offence complete on acceptance
Person who pays the bribeNot immuneNot immune
Test for privilegeAnything “in respect of” the vote, read broadlyTied to the House’s functioning and necessary to a legislator’s duties
Rajya Sabha polls by MLAsNot addressedCovered by Article 194(2), but not for bribery
House discipline and criminal courtsProsecution of voting MPs barredBoth can act, in distinct spheres
1998 against 2024. 1998, P.V. Narasimha Rao, 3:2: an MP who took a bribe and voted as agreed was immune; one who took a bribe and abstained was not; bribe-givers were not immune. 2024, Sita Soren, 7:0: no legislator has immunity for bribery under Articles 105(2) or 194(2); the offence is complete when the bribe is accepted; whether or how the vote is cast is irrelevant; the House and the courts both retain their powers. The Court called the 1998 outcome paradoxical.
How the rule changed, and why the Court called the old one paradoxical.

The core of the 2024 judgment is a change in the question asked. In 1998 the majority asked whether the bribe was connected to the vote. In 2024 the Court asked whether protecting the conduct was necessary for the House to function and for the member to do their job. A bribe, it held, is “agnostic to the performance of the agreed action”: the crime is complete when the money is accepted, so it cannot depend on what happens later in the House.

Why the JMM Bribery Case Still Matters

It defined the limits of privilege. Parliamentary privilege exists to let legislators speak and vote without fear. The 2024 Court held that it was never meant to place them above the criminal law on corruption.

It ended a perverse incentive. Under the 1998 rule, a legislator who took money was safer if they delivered the vote than if they did not. The Court named this the central flaw.

It extends to every House. The same rule now applies to MPs under Article 105 and to state legislators under Article 194, including MLAs voting in Rajya Sabha elections, where allegations of cross-voting for money recur.

It did not deliver a verdict on 1993. No one in the original case was finally convicted. The ruling changed the law long after the people it would have applied to had been discharged, acquitted or had died.

Key People

PersonRole
P.V. Narasimha RaoPrime Minister 1991-96; accused as a bribe-giver; convicted 2000, acquitted 2002; died 2004
Buta SinghFormer Union minister; convicted with Rao in 2000, acquitted in 2002
Satish SharmaCongress leader; chargesheeted in 1996, acquitted at trial in 2000
Shibu SorenJMM founder and MP; discharged in 1999 under the immunity ruling; died 2025
Suraj Mandal, Simon MarandiJMM MPs; discharged in 1999 under the immunity ruling
Shailendra MahtoJMM MP who turned approver in 1997
Ajit SinghJanata Dal (Ajit) leader; abstained, so not immune; acquitted in 2000
Ravindra KumarRashtriya Mukti Morcha convener whose 1996 complaint began the case
Sita SorenJMM MLA accused over the 2012 Rajya Sabha poll; her appeal led to the 2024 ruling
Justice S.P. Bharucha / Justice S.C. AgrawalWrote the 1998 majority and dissent
Chief Justice D.Y. ChandrachudWrote the unanimous 2024 judgment

Key Dates at a Glance

MilestoneDate
No-confidence motion defeated28 July 1993
Complaint to the CBIDated 1 February 1996; filed 28 February 1996
First chargesheet30 October 1996
Mahto pardoned as approver8 April 1997
Charges framed25 September 1997
Supreme Court 3:2 ruling17 April 1998
JMM MPs discharged4 June 1999
Rao and Buta Singh convicted / sentenced29 September / 12 October 2000
Delhi High Court acquittal15 March 2002
Jharkhand Rajya Sabha poll30 March 2012
Jharkhand High Court refuses to quash17 February 2014
Reference to seven judges20 September 2023
Seven-judge judgment4 March 2024

Explore More Timelines

People Also Ask

What is the JMM bribery case?
It is the case over allegations that four Jharkhand Mukti Morcha MPs, and members of Ajit Singh's Janata Dal group, were paid to vote against a no-confidence motion that P.V. Narasimha Rao's minority government survived on 28 July 1993 by 251 votes to 265. The CBI prosecuted the alleged bribe-takers and bribe-givers from 1996. It produced the Supreme Court's 1998 immunity ruling, which was overruled in 2024.
What did the Supreme Court decide in the JMM bribery case in 1998?
On 17 April 1998 a five-judge bench held by 3:2 that MPs who allegedly took bribes and then voted against the motion were immune from prosecution under Article 105(2). Ajit Singh, who abstained, and the alleged bribe-givers were not immune. Justices S.C. Agrawal and A.S. Anand dissented, holding that bribery is never protected by privilege.
Why was the 1998 JMM judgment overruled?
In Sita Soren v. Union of India on 4 March 2024, a unanimous seven-judge bench held that taking a bribe is not necessary to any legislative function, so it cannot be protected by privilege. It called the 1998 result paradoxical, because an MP who took money and voted as paid was protected, while one who took money and did not vote was not.
Was P.V. Narasimha Rao convicted in the JMM bribery case?
Yes, at trial. A Special CBI Court convicted Rao and Buta Singh on 29 September 2000 and sentenced them to three years' rigorous imprisonment on 12 October 2000. On 15 March 2002 the Delhi High Court acquitted both, finding the approver's evidence unreliable. Rao was never protected by the 1998 immunity, because he was accused as a bribe-giver.
Who were the JMM MPs in the bribery case?
Shibu Soren, Suraj Mandal, Simon Marandi and Shailendra Mahto. All four voted against the 1993 no-confidence motion. Mahto became an approver in April 1997 and testified for the prosecution. The other three were discharged in June 1999 because of the Supreme Court's 1998 immunity ruling, not because the allegations were disproved.

Frequently Asked Questions

Based on the 1998 and 2024 Supreme Court judgments, the 2002 Delhi High Court and 2024 Jharkhand High Court orders, and reporting to 15 November 2026.

When was the no-confidence motion in the JMM case?
The motion against P.V. Narasimha Rao's government was moved in the Lok Sabha on 26 July 1993 and debated until 28 July 1993, when it was defeated with 251 members voting for it and 265 against.
By how many votes did the Rao government survive?
By 14 votes. The motion got 251 votes and 265 members voted against it. The four JMM MPs and members of the Janata Dal (Ajit) group voted with the government, which was why their votes became the focus of the bribery allegations.
How did the JMM bribery allegations come to light?
Ravindra Kumar of the Rashtriya Mukti Morcha made a complaint dated 1 February 1996, filed with the CBI on 28 February 1996. It alleged payments of over Rs 3 crore to MPs, including Rs 1.10 crore to Suraj Mandal. The CBI then registered four cases against the JMM MPs.
How much money were the JMM MPs alleged to have taken?
The charges alleged that the JMM MPs demanded and accepted Rs 280 lakh, about Rs 2.8 crore, to vote against the motion. The original complaint put the total paid to MPs at over Rs 3 crore. These were allegations; no court made a final finding that the money was paid.
Who was named in the CBI chargesheets?
The first chargesheet, on 30 October 1996, named P.V. Narasimha Rao, Satish Sharma, Buta Singh and the four JMM MPs. A supplementary chargesheet on 9 December 1996 named V. Rajeshwar Rao, N.M. Revanna, Ramalinga Reddy and M. Thimmegowda. A second, on 22 January 1997, named Bhajan Lal and members of the Ajit Singh group.
What role did the Delhi High Court play in 1996?
On 24 May 1996 the Delhi High Court, hearing a writ petition, directed the CBI to register a case on the wider conspiracy, which the CBI did on 11 June 1996. This took the inquiry beyond the MPs to the people alleged to have paid them.
Who was Shailendra Mahto?
He was one of the four JMM MPs who voted against the 1993 motion. He applied for a pardon in March 1997 and was granted a conditional pardon on 8 April 1997, becoming the prosecution's key witness. The Delhi High Court later found his evidence inconsistent and acquitted Rao and Buta Singh.
What is Article 105(2) of the Constitution?
It says no member of Parliament is liable to proceedings in any court for anything said or any vote given in Parliament or its committees. It exists to let MPs speak and vote freely. Article 194(2) gives the same protection to members of state legislatures.
Who were the judges in the 1998 JMM judgment?
Justices S.C. Agrawal, A.S. Anand, S.P. Bharucha, S. Rajendra Babu and G.N. Ray. Justice Bharucha wrote the majority view for himself and Justice Rajendra Babu, with Justice Ray agreeing. Justice Agrawal wrote the dissent for himself and Justice Anand.
Why was Ajit Singh not protected by the 1998 ruling?
Because he abstained. The majority tied immunity to the vote actually cast: only MPs who had voted in the House could claim Article 105(2). Ajit Singh had not voted on the motion, so the Court said he derived no immunity, and his prosecution continued. He was acquitted at trial in 2000.
Were the bribe-givers protected in 1998?
No. Both the majority and the minority held that those accused of offering bribes, including Narasimha Rao, Satish Sharma and Buta Singh, could not claim parliamentary privilege. Their prosecution continued, which is how Rao came to be tried and convicted.
What did the dissenting judges say in 1998?
Justices S.C. Agrawal and A.S. Anand held that Article 105 gives no immunity to bribe-takers or bribe-givers, that an MP is a public servant under the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988, and that until Parliament legislated, prosecutors should obtain the Speaker's or Chairman's permission before filing a chargesheet against an MP.
What happened to the JMM MPs after 1998?
On 4 June 1999 the trial court dropped the conspiracy and corruption charges against Shibu Soren, Suraj Mandal, Simon Marandi and others protected by the ruling. A separate perjury charge against Mandal, Soren and Marandi was sent to another court. Mahto, as approver, had already been pardoned.
Did the government seek a review of the 1998 ruling?
Yes. A CBI review petition filed on 12 November 1998 was dismissed on 16 December 1998. The 3:2 judgment then stood as binding precedent until March 2024.
When was Narasimha Rao convicted?
Special Judge Ajit Bharihoke convicted Rao and Buta Singh on 29 September 2000 of criminal conspiracy and abetment of offences under the Prevention of Corruption Act. On 12 October 2000 he sentenced each to three years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine. It was the first criminal conviction of a former Prime Minister.
Who else was acquitted at the 2000 trial?
The Special Court acquitted the other accused tried with Rao and Buta Singh, including Satish Sharma, Bhajan Lal, Ajit Singh, V. Rajeshwar Rao, H.M. Revanna, Ramalinga Reddy, M. Veerappa Moily, D.K. Audikesavulu and M. Thimme Gowda.
Why did the Delhi High Court acquit Rao in 2002?
On 15 March 2002 Justice R.S. Sodhi allowed the appeals of Rao and Buta Singh and acquitted them of all charges. The conviction rested on approver Shailendra Mahto, and the court found his evidence unreliable and insufficiently corroborated. It also dismissed a petition challenging the other acquittals.
Was the 2002 acquittal appealed?
We found no reported Supreme Court judgment reversing the 2002 acquittal. Narasimha Rao died on 23 December 2004, and the case against him ended there in practice.
What is the Sita Soren case?
Sita Soren, a JMM MLA and Shibu Soren's daughter-in-law, was accused of accepting money to vote for independent candidate Raj Kumar Agarwal in the Rajya Sabha election from Jharkhand on 30 March 2012. She actually voted for her party's candidate. She claimed immunity under Article 194(2), and her appeal produced the 2024 ruling.
Why did the 2012 Rajya Sabha election get cancelled?
Hours before polling on 30 March 2012, income-tax officials and police seized Rs 2.15 crore from a vehicle near Namkum, Ranchi. The Election Commission countermanded the poll and a fresh election was held. The CBI took over the investigation in April 2012.
Why did the High Court refuse Sita Soren immunity?
On 17 February 2014 the Jharkhand High Court applied the 1998 judgment. Because she had not voted for the alleged bribe-giver, it held that she was not protected. Under the 1998 rule, immunity attached only to a legislator who voted in the way connected with the bribe.
How did the Sita Soren case reach seven judges?
A two-judge bench referred it to three judges on 23 September 2014. On 7 March 2019 a three-judge bench led by CJI Ranjan Gogoi noted the 1998 ruling covered the exact question and sent it to five judges. On 20 September 2023 five judges referred it to seven. Judgment was reserved on 5 October 2023.
Who was on the 2024 seven-judge bench?
Chief Justice D.Y. Chandrachud, who wrote the judgment, and Justices A.S. Bopanna, M.M. Sundresh, P.S. Narasimha, J.B. Pardiwala, Sanjay Kumar and Manoj Misra. The decision was unanimous.
What is the two-fold test in the Sita Soren judgment?
A legislator's claim of privilege must be tied to the collective functioning of the House, and it must be necessary to the discharge of the legislator's essential duties. A claim of immunity from prosecution for bribery fails both limbs.
When is the offence of bribery complete for an MP?
When the bribe is accepted. The 2024 judgment says the offence is agnostic to the performance of the agreed action: it does not matter whether the vote is cast as agreed, or cast at all. Agreeing to take or taking the bribe is enough.
Does the 2024 ruling cover Rajya Sabha elections?
Yes. The Court held that MLAs voting in a Rajya Sabha election are covered by Article 194(2), rejecting the Attorney General's argument that such votes fall outside it. But it held that the protection does not extend to taking a bribe in connection with that vote.
Can Parliament still punish an MP for taking bribes?
Yes. The 2024 judgment says the House's power to discipline a member and a criminal court's power to try them for bribery exist in distinct spheres. An MP can face both, as in the 2005 cash-for-query expulsions.
Did the 2024 ruling reopen the 1993 case?
No. It settled the law on immunity going forward and in pending cases. It did not revive the charges dropped against the JMM MPs in 1999 or touch the 2002 acquittals, and most of those accused had died by 2024.
Did the 2024 ruling find Sita Soren guilty?
No. The Court said expressly that it was not deciding the merits of her case or whether she committed the offence. It answered the legal question and sent the case back to run its course in the Special CBI Court in Ranchi.
What happened to Sita Soren after the 2024 ruling?
She left the JMM and joined the BJP in March 2024. She lost the Dumka Lok Sabha seat to the JMM's Nalin Soren by 22,527 votes in June 2024, and the Jamtara assembly seat to Congress's Irfan Ansari by 43,676 votes in November 2024.
What happened to Raj Kumar Agarwal's case?
On 21 August 2024 the Jharkhand High Court quashed the proceedings against him, the alleged bribe-giver in the 2012 poll, after an income-tax appeal deleted a Rs 1.5 crore addition central to the money trail. The order covers only Agarwal; the case against the other accused continues.
Is Shibu Soren alive?
No. Shibu Soren, founder of the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha and one of the four MPs in the 1993 case, died on 4 August 2025, aged 81. He had been discharged in the bribery case in 1999 because of the 1998 immunity ruling.
Why is the JMM bribery case important?
It produced India's leading ruling on legislative privilege and corruption twice. In 1998 it created an immunity for MPs who took bribes and voted as paid. In 2024 the same question, raised by Shibu Soren's daughter-in-law, led the Supreme Court to abolish that immunity and restate that legislators are subject to ordinary criminal law.

⚠️ Editorial Note: What We Corrected and What We Could Not Confirm

This page separates allegations in the CBI’s complaints and chargesheets from judicial findings. The 1998 judgment decided immunity, not whether bribes were paid; the 2002 acquittal was on the evidence; the 2024 judgment changed the law but did not reopen the 1993 case or decide Sita Soren’s guilt. Several details in common accounts are wrong. The complaint that began the case was dated 1 February 1996 and filed with the CBI on 28 February 1996; we found no 1994 newspaper report as the starting point. The 9 December 1996 supplementary chargesheet named V. Rajeshwar Rao, N.M. Revanna, Ramalinga Reddy and M. Thimmegowda; M. Veerappa Moily was among those acquitted in 2000, but the Supreme Court’s account does not place him in that chargesheet. Charges were ordered on 6 May 1997 and framed on 25 September 1997. The matter went to the Constitution Bench on 9 December 1997, not in November. The sentence was pronounced on 12 October 2000. In 2014 the two-judge bench referred Sita Soren’s appeal to three judges. We could not confirm the exact dates of the CBI’s first four case registrations, the arrests of the JMM MPs, a public admission by Shailendra Mahto in February 1996, or the date of the Delhi High Court’s 1997 revision order, so we do not give them. As of 15 November 2026 we found no reported verdict in the Sita Soren trial.

Related Reading on AiTimeline

Bhanwari Devi Case: Timeline of Justice & Legal Reform in India 1987 Jammu & Kashmir Election: Rigging, Aftermath and Legacy
New article
→
Next Article